After general chemistry lab at Rutgers-NB (run like a nazi concentration camp when I was there), I developed massive amounts of anxiety when it came to chem labs. Of course, orgo lab was no different. It didn't help that I never had any labs with friends and everyone in lab with me seemed pro at it all (it probably was just me sucking really bad and everyone else was average). I am by no means good at lab. I'm sure the little faith I had in myself played a huge role in my poor lab technique.
Surprisingly, I never broke anything other than 1 glass stirring rod. I was one of those people who had to read a step in the procedure like 100x before I had the confidence to pour it in the damn flask or beaker. Since I was always freaking out, I would often measure something and pour it in and immediately forget what I did.
Everytime we had to use a separatory funnel, I pretty much admitted to defeat. When my professor made me separate a two liquids that were essentially black using the separatory funnel, I just laughed. I don't know how I got A's in both labs, considering purity/yield was like 20% for me as well but I barely ever had any product. My purity was always decent though. Also I was always the kid who would have the brown solid product when it should have been white powder. One time i just burned a paper towel to mimic the brown powder it should have been.
Luckily I'm good at theory/mechanisms/lab techniques so my quizzes/finals were always great. I guess I have performance anxiety lol
edit: correction. I broke a ton of plastic pipette tips, but those are disposable so I guess its no big deal.