SHOTS WW GAME THREAD

Started by cubsrule4e
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

Browse articles Compare schools My application plan Read Interview Feedback
Practice for interviews Ask an Advisor
BobLoblaw78 said:
That wolfzenge proposed to pass on NK so he could claim an attempt on his life and try to gain village cred. I have used this exact situation before in the same exact manner
Click to expand...
Oooh. I mean. I’d almost never pass on a kill as a wolf. Especially not N1. You’ve gotta whittle those village numbers down before @Dinashadow seers you and role reveals. Numbers is villains.
 
Melchizedek said:
Before I do though I want to elaborate on my current Dubz read, it’s not just a p!vote. Her reads list was safe AF and when I was skimming it started to feel like she’s shut down conversation about people outside of her “POE” now that I’m paying attention, I’ll be looking for exact things that gave me this impression or things that refute it.
Click to expand...
Why does it feel like every time I am vocal about my reads, someone accuses me of shutting down discussion?

Would like an explanation of "safe" too.
 
Wheres my cookie WZ
 

Attachments

  • 16382357946516876338209747281122.jpg
    16382357946516876338209747281122.jpg
    97.5 KB · Views: 130
Zenge142 said:
You seem oddly fatalistic for only having 2 votes on you, two hours before yeet close, with a group that loves waffles.
Click to expand...
Yesterday's board leaders stayed basically the same all day up until the last minute where the only thing that changed was a self-prez, so it doesn't seem unreasonable
 
WildZoo said:
Why does it feel like every time I am vocal about my reads, someone accuses me of shutting down discussion?

Would like an explanation of "safe" too.
Click to expand...
You literally put the 3 sketchiest players, who call themselves the sketchmasons, as your 3 wolfiest reads. How original.

I also wholeheartedly disagree with your analysis that Paws wasn’t wolf hunting. She had good thoughts about the genny/April interactions on pg 1. It was the exact reaction that I had and posted into my mod pm notes that I wouldn’t be surprised if there was a wolf between them. Her continued pushing of genny when genny said she liked your (WZ’s ugh so many pronouns) reads but later genny said something about April that contradicted your reads. That kind of catch in a potential logic slip is wolf-hunting.
 
WildZoo said:
@Zenge142 who would you put in Paws's pack? I'm struggling outside of it being her and Mel because I have some village points for everyone else.
Click to expand...
I could see genny, like I see you just Ninja’d me on.

Maybe I’m wrong about April, and I could see a Paws/April pack.

I never know what Bob’s up to, so…who knows.

Maybe a Mel/Paws pack that’s doing a lot of distancing?

There’s a few compatible options I see.
 
Melchizedek said:
You literally put the 3 sketchiest players, who call themselves the sketchmasons, as your 3 wolfiest reads. How original.

I also wholeheartedly disagree with your analysis that Paws wasn’t wolf hunting. She had good thoughts about the genny/April interactions on pg 1. It was the exact reaction that I had and posted into my mod pm notes that I wouldn’t be surprised if there was a wolf between them. Her continued pushing of genny when genny said she liked your (WZ’s ugh so many pronouns) reads but later genny said something about April that contradicted your reads. That kind of catch in a potential logic slip is wolf-hunting.
Click to expand...
I never had AM as wolfy.

I disagree on the genny/April interactions, it seemed like a misrepresentation to me. And I read some of her posts as asking questions just to ask them.
 
WildZoo said:
I feel better about April, a bit worse about AM, genny didn't get points in either direction
Click to expand...
This is re: the MsP flip. I don’t understand how genny, who started the whole “MsP voted early” and put her in the spotlight, got no points.
Similarly if you (Dubz) are village and you voted for MsP, why does AM get sketch points? Do you think you followed a wolf onto that vote? Or does it make more sense that someone who had the same thought process as you (a supposed villager) is probably village?
WildZoo said:
I'm sorry you feel that way. I've never been wrong on a strong village!Zenge read though, and this isn't the first time I've gotten that read by d2. People said the same thing about us being in a pack in CYO II :shrug:

Where's Mel?
Click to expand...
shutting down zenge discussion
WildZoo said:
Er by my recollection genny and April were applying different logic to MsP
Click to expand...
this and the subsequent posts I replied to about this, felt like her once again steering discussion away from anyone that wasn’t her top 3 (fine she wants to say she’s never wolf read AM so I won’t say wolf reads, but AM paws and I are on her list as the sketchiest or least village however you want to word that) sketchiest reads


April and Zenge analysis is upcoming.
 
genny said:
Oh I actually like this list. Maybe not Dubz.

edit: Meant maybe Dubz is not wolfing. Not maybe I don't like Dubz. LOL
Click to expand...
Okay, so if not Dubz who are you seeing as April’s pack mate?
 
Melchizedek said:
This is re: the MsP flip. I don’t understand how genny, who started the whole “MsP voted early” and put her in the spotlight, got no points.
Similarly if you (Dubz) are village and you voted for MsP, why does AM get sketch points? Do you think you followed a wolf onto that vote? Or does it make more sense that someone who had the same thought process as you (a supposed villager) is probably village?
Click to expand...
genny - because it's genny. I don't just give wolf points for being wrong, and I can see village genny picking up on something abnormal and going "huh, that's weird." I can see wolf genny doing that kind of cherry-picking too. It would have given her village points if MsP flipped wolf, but since she didn't, it's null in my eyes.

AM - I already explained that, in my read of her. Also I don't think we had the same thought process at all, so that didn't enter my headspace. I stayed on MsP because I was at a wedding and drunk by the time she showed up and I didn't see most of her posts. AM was here, which was the original sticking point for me.
 
Melchizedek said:
this and the subsequent posts I replied to about this, felt like her once again steering discussion away from anyone that wasn’t her top 3 (fine she wants to say she’s never wolf read AM so I won’t say wolf reads, but AM paws and I are on her list as the sketchiest or least village however you want to word that) sketchiest reads
Click to expand...
So I'm not allowed to discuss my interpretations when I disagree with someone?

Alright I'll just be over here talking into a corner then.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.