I wouldn't depend solely on NAPLEX because the school can just teach you to prepare for NAPLEX. If I were you, I would definitely look at the graduation statistics and see how many students got a job lined up. In addition, looking at the residency stats is just as important if you plan to go PGY-1. Another thing I would look at is the school's alumni pool because it'll be easier for you to network. Of course, the reputation is crucial too because during your rotations, the manager can be biased on choosing a student who they worked with at that school is better than the other school. In the end, it's all about networking but old school has a better name and alumni thus, gives you a better chance to land a job.