Should I switch?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

TanMan85

New Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Oct 1, 2012
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
This will sound selfish to those who are/were interested in EM and those that will take EM or any residency in any location.

I liked EM in my first 2 months. Sure, some things pissed me off by the 19th or 20th shift like having no weekends, but that should solve by me working less in the following years (I'm in a 4 year program). But it's my location. I moved from Manhattan to a college town. This spot was 7th on my rank list. I didn't know at the time it would be so hard to adjust, but it is. My interests (hip hop/electro music, dance, theater), my fiance, my minority culture is all in NYC. I didn't have any weekends or 2 days off in a row to go to NYC my first two months so I was in the first probably clinically depressive episode in my life. I wouldn't sleep well, I had no interest in anything, etc. The only thing that may have made me sane again is these last two off-rotations I've had weekends off so I am going down every or every other weekend on a 3.5 hr bus ride. But I'm afraid next month back on EM I'll be depressed once again as I have no weekends or 2 days off in a row.
I probably wouldn't be this way if so many of my friends/former classmates took less competitive fields to stay in NYC. I don't know if I did the right thing by going anywhere for the field of my choice. I did enter ERAS again to transfer in EM after talking to select program directors in the area. Chances are slim I'm sure. But I know of an open PM&R PGY-2 spot in the city, where even my friend matched last year as a backup to gen surg. I would definitely shadow a PM&R guy before I apply for that. I know I'm selfish. But anybody out there happy in taking a backup field for the location of your choice? Anybody depressed at their residency location?
 
welcome to the club!
I see what you're saying, man! Can you imagine being forced to listen to contry music while being on call? Yep, it aint cool. In my case, I'm in the wrong specialty and in the friggin wrong location. Hate it!

Anyway, If you think you are going to be happy with PM&R, then switch. Nobody would blame you for wanting to be with family. PM&R is less competitive than EM, I think. Keep in mind it would suck even more if you hate what you do. NYC is one of the best cities in the world; it offers tremendous quality of life with its culture, food, and oh god, grreat food!!! It sucks to go through another match/interview process again. But If you have a good profile to begin with, it wouldn't be hard to match into another specialty.
 
This will sound selfish to those who are/were interested in EM and those that will take EM or any residency in any location.

I liked EM in my first 2 months. Sure, some things pissed me off by the 19th or 20th shift like having no weekends, but that should solve by me working less in the following years (I'm in a 4 year program). But it's my location. I moved from Manhattan to a college town. This spot was 7th on my rank list. I didn't know at the time it would be so hard to adjust, but it is. My interests (hip hop/electro music, dance, theater), my fiance, my minority culture is all in NYC. I didn't have any weekends or 2 days off in a row to go to NYC my first two months so I was in the first probably clinically depressive episode in my life. I wouldn't sleep well, I had no interest in anything, etc. The only thing that may have made me sane again is these last two off-rotations I've had weekends off so I am going down every or every other weekend on a 3.5 hr bus ride. But I'm afraid next month back on EM I'll be depressed once again as I have no weekends or 2 days off in a row.
I probably wouldn't be this way if so many of my friends/former classmates took less competitive fields to stay in NYC. I don't know if I did the right thing by going anywhere for the field of my choice. I did enter ERAS again to transfer in EM after talking to select program directors in the area. Chances are slim I'm sure. But I know of an open PM&R PGY-2 spot in the city, where even my friend matched last year as a backup to gen surg. I would definitely shadow a PM&R guy before I apply for that. I know I'm selfish. But anybody out there happy in taking a backup field for the location of your choice? Anybody depressed at their residency location?

May want to just stick with possible in-specialty transfers to get out of of Albany or Hartford or thereabouts, which is where I assume you are. You may also want to consider programs in Jersey or Long Island, and get a car. Also talk with yoru chiefs or whoever makes the schedule to ask for 2 sets of 2 consecutive days each month if possible.
 
Last edited:
Yea, I would love to stick with EM, but I'm already a borderline candidate by board scores (they were average to slightly above average), which probably made me not match in my top 5 in the first place with this competitive environment of EM today. My dream was to learn EM with the urban and diverse population of NYC, instead I'm with a nearly total low socioeconomic caucasian population and I have used my near fluent Spanish ability (learned in school) like 3 times so far in just over 3 months.

Anyway, I did apply to LI and Jersey as well. And I did talk with a chief, but he was like "I'm sorry man. Interns always get screwed, you just got the worst schedule these two months. You'll have it better." With 20 shifts plus 3-4 didactic days, 2 days off in a row is a luxury for interns. I guess I'll hope for the best.
 
Top