I don't see the value in a standardized intern year that resembles a prelim year. For many specialists, including myself, I don't see the value in extensive medicine/ICU months. I am not going to be managing either set of patients and to assume even a working knowledge after a few months as an intern is ridiculous. So where's the value? I dont think most specialities need their residents to have a set of general management skills and would be better off using the TY year set up to get their residents knowledgable on things on the periphery of their specialty, for example subspecialty rotations. Further, while not the initial intention of TY years, it seems to make sense to have a painless internship for those who will have minimal use for it once they move on. I think you have to accept that the TY has gone from a catch all for the undecided to the specialists landing pad.
Agreed. It's funny how surgery and medicine think their fields are the most important and therefore we should all rotate through them extensively to become "generalists.". Wait....I did rotate through them, it's called medical school. Why do I need an extra year of watching appys or treating copd exacerabations when I will never need that knowledge in my real job? When I have a clinical question on a case and I can't figure out the answer, shouldn't I be able to consult my clinical colleagues?
If they ever made an intern year necessary for pathology, I would campaign long and hard to force pathology rotations on the folks in medicine and surgery. The 2nd year med school course does not give any insight into "real" pathology, and based off the ignorant questions/assumptions I get on a daily basis, it would be time well spent for them.
Examples of idiotic questions:
"Oh my god, my patients pottasium has dropped!!! It went from 3.6 to 3.3. Should I treat them?" Newsflash, there is no difference between those two results. The test has quite a large standard deviation.
One hour after submitting blood cultures, "Can we get the results of those blood cultures, we submitted them hours ago?" Uhh yeah, they are bacteria, they take time to grow, hence the word culture!
7 minutes after sending a frozen section, "Do you have the results on depth of invasion of the specimen we sent yet?" No. See I have to weigh it, ink the margins, carefully section the thing so as not to screw it up before I hack into it a million pieces and take sections for frozen. This is why we have 20 minutes. If you stop calling me, you'll get those results alot quicker.
1 day after submitting an undifferentiated spindled cell tumor, "Why does it take you so long to give me an answer? Can't you just look at the H&E and tell me what it is?" Let's see, the differential diagnosis of a spindle cell lesion has about twenty different entitites, hence the use of immunohistochemistry, which takes an additional day. Not to mention, the specimen doesn't magically get put on a slide, there is the whole concept of processing and embedding. Get it?
See? I can go on and on. Maybe a year of pathology should be mandatory for all clinicians. After all, it would make you a better doctor, right? Or, we can keep things the way they are, and you can just ask me those stupid questions, and I won't get angry because I'll understand that I probably ask you my fair share of idiotic questions as well.