Smaller program or prestige? Which should I choose?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Which program should I choose?


  • Total voters
    17

WontGiveUp90

Full Member
7+ Year Member
Joined
Jan 18, 2016
Messages
100
Reaction score
154
So I just got accepted to one of my first choice school's main campus and I was also accepted to a smaller clinical campus for the 3rd and 4th years, I need to decide between the two clinical campuses pretty soon and need help picking A little background: non-trad student with masters in neuroscience, 5+ years of preclinical research experience and some publications; I want to work at an academic hospital and be involved in clinical trials while seeing patients. I'm undecided on a specialty but most interested in neurotology, otolaryngonlogy, neurosurgery, neurology, EM, and trauma surgery. Here's information about the programs:

Main Campus:
-150+ students per year (4 years)
-Hospital very highly ranked in ENT, neuro, and surgery
-Large university in a bigger, cooler, city, but 1-hour further from friends/family
-LOTS of research (can get involved all 4 years)
-Lots of good matches in most specialties

Smaller Campus:
-10-15 students per year (1st & 2nd year at main campus^, 3rd & 4th years at smaller hospital)
-"Focused" on PC but 40% of graduates matched non-PC (some good ones i.e. Cleveland Clinic Rad-Onc)
-Longitudinal patient care clinic (see your own patients long-term)
-$20,000 scholarship
-smaller rural town but 1-hour closer to friends/family
-hospital really felt like a family
-Very little research, don't see a lot of trauma or specialized surgery, but allows for away rotations

So my conundrum is that I am probably going to try to match into a difficult specialty and I'm not sure what is more valuable? The smaller program would allow me to be a bigger fish in a small pond, more hands-on and real doctoring experience, and closer relationships with my professors which will probably lead to better LORs. At the bigger program the hospital is more "prestigious" and would allow me to participate in more research, more clubs/organizations, and work with very skilled and well-known physicians in my potential fields of interest. Regardless, I'll spend years 1 & 2 at the main campus. So which do you think is a better match for me?
 
I think you want to be part of the main campus. Better hospital will allow you more research opportunities, connections with people in academic medicine, and more diverse medical cases.
 
Go to large campus. You want to do competitive stuff, compete on the big stage. The smaller campus seems like they want to send you into PC.
 
Last edited:
Suggest asking the med students at the school.

So I just got accepted to one of my first choice school's main campus and I was also accepted to a smaller clinical campus for the 3rd and 4th years, I need to decide between the two clinical campuses pretty soon and need help picking A little background: non-trad student with masters in neuroscience, 5+ years of preclinical research experience and some publications; I want to work at an academic hospital and be involved in clinical trials while seeing patients. I'm undecided on a specialty but most interested in neurotology, otolaryngonlogy, neurosurgery, neurology, EM, and trauma surgery. Here's information about the programs:

Main Campus:
-150+ students per year (4 years)
-Hospital very highly ranked in ENT, neuro, and surgery
-Large university in a bigger, cooler, city, but 1-hour further from friends/family
-LOTS of research (can get involved all 4 years)
-Lots of good matches in most specialties

Smaller Campus:
-10-15 students per year (1st & 2nd year at main campus^, 3rd & 4th years at smaller hospital)
-"Focused" on PC but 40% of graduates matched non-PC (some good ones i.e. Cleveland Clinic Rad-Onc)
-Longitudinal patient care clinic (see your own patients long-term)
-$20,000 scholarship
-smaller rural town but 1-hour closer to friends/family
-hospital really felt like a family
-Very little research, don't see a lot of trauma or specialized surgery, but allows for away rotations

So my conundrum is that I am probably going to try to match into a difficult specialty and I'm not sure what is more valuable? The smaller program would allow me to be a bigger fish in a small pond, more hands-on and real doctoring experience, and closer relationships with my professors which will probably lead to better LORs. At the bigger program the hospital is more "prestigious" and would allow me to participate in more research, more clubs/organizations, and work with very skilled and well-known physicians in my potential fields of interest. Regardless, I'll spend years 1 & 2 at the main campus. So which do you think is a better match for me?
 
It's just so much easier if you give the actual schools you're considering. There's much more nuance than the few bullet points you listed.
 
Just stay in Charleston (no need to be coy with the school, it's easily searchable from your post history). If you want to match something competitive, you need research and you need exposure to those fields, which that smaller campus won't give you.
 
Last edited:
I think a consideration here that hasn't been listed is where will you be happier? Don't go to a school just because it's prestigious if everyone there is miserable for their 4 years, unless that's something you can seriously put up with.

That's certainly not the only factor, but it's something you should consider.
 
Top