You wrote: I have a BS in psychology with Psi Chi honors. I know what I am talking about. Psychology has only been around for about as long as psychologists have been doing psychotherapy.
Reply: You know very little about your field. In
1879,
Wilhelm Wundt (1832-1920), known as "the father of psychology", founded a laboratory for the study of psychology at
Leipzig University in
Germany. The American philosopher
William James published his seminal book,
Principles of Psychology, in 1890, laying the foundations for many of the questions that
psychologists would focus on for years to come. Other important early contributors to the field include
Hermann Ebbinghaus (18501909), a pioneer in the experimental study of
memory at the
University of Berlin; and the
Russian physiologist Ivan Pavlov (1849-1936), who investigated the
learning process now referred to as
classical conditioning.
It wasn't until 1917 that clinical psychologists began to organize under that name, when the American Association of Clinical Psychology was organized, leading to the Section on Clinical Psychology of the American Psychological Association. This section certified clinical psychologists until 1927, but would not allow clinical psychologists full membership in APA.
Slow growth of the field continued in the 1930s as several scattered, applied psychological organizations in the US formed an alliance under the American Association of Applied Psychology. This group became the primary forum for clinical and applied psychology in the U.S. until APA reorganized in 1945, creating its division of clinical psychology, today known as Division 12.
Before the 1940s, individual psychotherapy was conducted by
psychiatrists, leaving clinical psychologists to focus on assessment. This changed during
World War II, however, when the military gave greater recognition to the condition they termed "shell shock" which eventually came to be called
Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. The military called upon psychotherapists and clinical psychologists to help administer treatment.
from wikipedia
But hey, congrats on getting into psi chi!
You wrote: Social work is neither behavioral, nor is it a science. Taking stats and research methodology doesn't make one a scientist. Taking a class or two in psychology doesn't make one a qualified psychotherapist.
My reply: A class or two??? Social work is an applied social science, particularly at the PhD level. I believe that my training in regression, structural equation modeling, HLM, categorical data analysis, systems dynamics, GIS, conducting clinical trials, qualitative research methods, philosophy of science (not to mention my training in advanced psychopathology, personality disorders, social theory, and behavioral genetics) all qualify me to label myself a social scientist, regardless of what you think. Also, to assert that social work is not behavioral is laughable. We have doctoral-level social scientists in our field who subscribe to a variety of theoretical perspectives, with a number of radical behaviorists in our ranks.
Here's a very tiny sampling of some articles by social work researchers who "aren't social scientists":
[FONT=Times New Roman,Times]
Auslander, W.F.; Thompson, S.; Dreitzer, D.; White, N.; & Santiago, J.V. (1997). "Disparity in Glycemic Control and Adherence between African American and Caucasian Youths with Diabetes: Family and Community Contexts," Diabetes Care 20 (10), 1569-1575.
.
McMillen, J.C.; North, C.S.; & Smith, E.M. (2000). What Parts of PTSD are Normal: Intrusion, Avoidance, or Hyperarousal? Data From the Northridge, California Earthquake, Journal of Traumatic Stress 13, 57-75.
[FONT=Times New Roman,Times]
Pollio, D.E.; North, C.S.; Thompson, S.; Paquin, J.W.; & Spitznagel, E.L. (1997). Predictors of Achieving Stable Housing in a Mentally Ill Homeless Population, Psychiatric Services 48 (4), 258-260.
. [FONT=Times New Roman,Times]
Vosler, N.R. & Page-Adams, D. (1996). Predictors of Depression Among Workers at the Time of a Plant Closing, Journal of Sociology and Social Welfare 23 (4), 25-42..
[FONT=Times New Roman,Times]
.
[FONT=Times New Roman,Times]
Stiffman, A.R., Hadley-Ives, E., Elze, D., Johnson, S., & Doré, P. (1999). Impact of environment on adolescents mental health and behavior: Structural Equation Modeling. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 69(1), 73-86..
[FONT=Times New Roman,Times]
.
[FONT=Times New Roman,Times]
[FONT=Times New Roman,Times]Pitner, R., & Moore-McBride, A. (in press). Social psychological theory and the potential for ethnonational cooperation in civic service programs. In M. Sherraden and A. Moore-McBride (Eds.) Civic service worldwide: Impacts and Inquiry
..
Associations of trauma, early home environment, and genetic effects with risk for depression: Towards an examination of gene-environment interplay by McCutcheon, Vivia Van Dyne, PhD, WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY, 2005, 273 pages; 3181188
[FONT=verdana,arial,helvetica,sans-serif][SIZE=-2] Behavior Modification, Vol. 15, No. 3, 310-325 (1991)[/SIZE].. Diagnosis and Treatment of Child and Adolescent Anxiety Disorders
The Relative Effectiveness of EMDR Versus Relaxation Training With Battered Women Prisoners -[SIZE=-1]SD Colosetti, BA Thyer - Behavior Modification, 2000 [/SIZE]
Discriminant and Concurrent Validity of Two Commonly Used Measures of Test Anxiety -
group of 2 »[SIZE=-1]
BA Thyer, JD Papsdorf - Educational and Psychological Measurement, 1982[/SIZE]
[FONT=Times New Roman,Times]
If that's not behavioral science, please explain to me what you think behavioral science is. Do some research before making uninformed statements.
.
[FONT=Times New Roman,Times]
.
[FONT=Times New Roman,Times]
.
You wrote: But they can practice outside their scope and educational qualification by practicing psychotherapy, that's my point.
my reply: No, your original complaint was that social workers can take psychologists' jobs but that the reverse was not true. You are wrong.
You wrote: Not paranoid nor bitter. I just don't like professionals scamming the public by practicing outside their scope. I am a med student, and I don't like doctors practicing psychology either, unless they have a degree in psychology. I don't like nurses practicing medicine without going to med school. I don't like psychologists writing scripts unless they go to med school. Too many professions are trying to move in on other professions' areas of competence without equivalent or adequate training.[/quote]
My reply: As a psi chi member, I am sure that you are familiar with the number of studies which indicate that the effectiveness of psychotherapy outcomes is not associated with the discipline of the practitioner.