When I went down there (December 10) Dr. Thomas said a lot of similar things to me as a few of you I have talked to...it seems as if he doesnt really show interest in anyone who has what is considered "average" numbers. A couple of people I have talked to felt maybe it was due to the fact that he (unlike some other admission counselors) didnt want to get anyone's hopes up only to find out they didnt get in...I have heard this story before and I would much rather be discouraged after an interview and later find out good news rather than be expecting an acceptance and later receiving a denial letter.
I could be generalizing here but from the people I have talked to including a classmate, it seems as if he tells everyone the same thing. He basically said I wouldnt be one of those people selected in December which was initially discouraging.......but after talking to a professor who works in restorative it sounds as if SIU waits until March to make a bulk of their decisions.
Seeing that I have gone through this process last year, I remembered being waitlisted in March....so it rang a bell. From what I gather if you havent gotten an acceptance so far from them, dont expect anything until March. I know its a blanket statement, but the professor who told me mentioned that is just the way SIU does things. If you get an acceptance earlier, great, if not wait until March or later.
Lastly, I am not sure how SIU does interviews. I asked them directly (the admission office) and I was told they interview a select number of people and those not interviewed have just as good of a chance as those interviewed (ie you dont need to have an interview to get in and those who do get interviews arent favored over those who do not).