Speed WW

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
well people did bandwagon... so I think its within that groupage
 
lynch dyachei Too quiet for my liking.:laugh:
 
Okay, either protected or conversion. Given bbe just got lynched, I'm going with conversion is more probable.
 
and BB would vote for me???

not buying it
 
lynch LIS

nothing really to go on - other than the odd lynching PP for calling him old which happens all the time.....
 
...

Why you?

We have one person who can protect... Now, we know who the seer is so that person should be protected but if you are going to protect one other person, wouldn't it be wise to protect the person who just started the lynch on a wolf? I think this is really straightforward... better than picking a random person to protect... then you could end up protecting a wolf instead.
 
Well since you're all lynching me, I guess I can go back to getting the results post ready for Sherlock. 🙁
 
We have one person who can protect... Now, we know who the seer is so that person should be protected but if you are going to protect one other person, wouldn't it be wise to protect the person who just started the lynch on a wolf? I think this is really straightforward... better than picking a random person to protect... then you could end up protecting a wolf instead.

No, not really.

Wolves don't usually go after people who just stumbled across another wolf. That's dumb. (Ok, dumb wolves might do it.)

Wolves go after people when the kill will take out a villager and push their agenda of having villagers lynch somebody.

So taking out you is pointless unless it makes another innocent look guilty.

If we have a known seer and a protector, the seer should be protected. If we don't, the protector should protect herself to stay alive until a more important person is known.
 
No, not really.

Wolves don't usually go after people who just stumbled across another wolf. That's dumb. (Ok, dumb wolves might do it.)

Wolves go after people when the kill will take out a villager and push their agenda of having villagers lynch somebody.

So taking out you is pointless unless it makes another innocent look guilty.

If we have a known seer and a protector, the seer should be protected. If we don't, the protector should protect herself to stay alive until a more important person is known.

In the majority of games I have played, the protector can not protect themselves...
 
would be a bit silly to out a wolf, claim to be the seer - if you were not... so I would say dyachei is prob telling the truth. she would be toast if not. 🙂

Yup. And the mechanics of this game - no PM'ing - lend itself toward believing Dyachei. She has no other way to get information out, and she has the hope that a protector out there can cover her.

So... I buy it.
 
We have one person who can protect... Now, we know who the seer is so that person should be protected but if you are going to protect one other person, wouldn't it be wise to protect the person who just started the lynch on a wolf? I think this is really straightforward... better than picking a random person to protect... then you could end up protecting a wolf instead.

It's not like you really knew that she was a wolf, so it actually would not make sense to protect you because what's the likelihood of you randomly finding another one?

In the majority of games I have played, the protector can not protect themselves...

But sometimes they can.
 
Yup. And the mechanics of this game - no PM'ing - lend itself toward believing Dyachei. She has no other way to get information out, and she has the hope that a protector out there can cover her.

So... I buy it.


plus there is only one seer, right?

so if dyachei was lying, someone would be like "o crap she's lying b/c i am the seer"
 
🙄

In theory, if the protector can protect themselves in this game, then they could do that every single night and guarantee a villager win.

Incorrect. Eventually the wolf/wolves would win. They would lynch the survivor and most games give the wolves the win if there are equal amounts of villagers and wolves. So if it got down to one and one, wolves typically win
 
Top