Originally posted by mountaindew2006
And as someone had mentioned I suppose people who place in decent programs from the Carib either have connections or B have connections.
Your logic is a bit flawed. If a Carib student is so well-connected, why did he have to go down to the Carib in the first place? Shouldn't have his connections landed him a spot in a US school? Or perhaps he made them during his clinical years? If he did, then good for him! If George Bush can use his connections to get into Yale (while he was rejected as an in-state resident at UT Austin), why shouldn?t anyone else?
Originally posted by mountaindew2006
I mean the bottom line is this...WHY would you go to a caribbean school to start with? Well...probably because the US schools were out of reach. Thus, by induction one can see which one is superior aka more favorable. So you all do the reasoning, but it's simple logic.
At first glance, this comment may seem like common sense but nothing could be further than the truth. Forget the Caribbean for a second - does everyone from Harvard get a better residency position than, let's say, Boston University? Both are US schools, both are in the same city, both are private, both cost a ton, but one is clearly more prestigious (guess which one). Having said that, I'm sure EVERY SINGLE YEAR there are people at BU who get dermatology or whatever while some Harvard kid gets rejected. Everyone will still think the Harvard kid is "smarter" (and maybe she is), but the ultimate purpose of medical school is to get into residency (and learn the material, which you can do anywhere - whether at the Harvard library, Starbucks or on the beach somewhere in the Caribbean). Of course anyone would pick Harvard over BU, but Harvard can only improve one's chances at getting into a top residency, not guarantee it. Besides, unless you go to Hopkins or Stanford etc, nobody gets into all the schools they apply to, so everyone is a "reject" to some degree.
I have friends who went to the Caribbean, and I was very skeptical, but they all ended up in US residencies and are doing just fine. Obviously anyone would pick a US allopathic school as their first choice - but why waste time getting a masters or working or doing some other career if you can't get accepted into a US school after 4 years of college? If I didn't get into a US allopathic school after 4 years, I would gladly go to the Caribbean rather than wasting time doing things I hated to improve my CV, without any guarantees of getting in the next year (if ever).
BTW, it's Andy Dufresne not "Dufrane"...as long as we're making fun of Caribbean students.
Let me guess - is that the Canadian spelling?