Hey guys, I posted something like this a little while ago. I also did some research. First of all, though we all love neurology/psychiatry/"awesome brain stuff", we should realize that neurology is still a relatively uncompetitive specialty to match into. Charting the outcomes from 2011 data is very reassuring to those of us that may not have "aced" Step 1. Most programs will not screen out your application with scores >200 and no failed attempts. I'm sure "top notch" places (i.e. Partners, Hopkins, Columbia, UCSF, Penn, etc.) would prefer applicants with higher board scores, but even then, some people have managed to score interviews there.
From what I have heard from other residents and friends who recently matched Neuro, it's important to have good LORs, a strong passion for neuro, and a great personal statement on top of whatever scores and research you may have. Yes... personal statements are looked at pretty closely!
I think in general, if you are a US grad, and have a decent application, you will get plenty of interviews and will match. Do well clinically, get good evals, and try to improve your score on Step 2!