Bluedrapes, unfortunately, you're in a tough position. As I understand it, this question of releasing vs not releasing is relevant for those who apply (and release their USMLE transcript) prior to taking step 2. In your case, having already taken step 2, programs will come to know of your score as it will be automatically released with your step 1 score (which they will definitely want to see). As such, should you choose to apply, you don't really have the choice of not releasing the step 2 score. Re your question of whether to apply or not, I am not really qualified to answer that. Perhaps some of those who applied last year could chime in?