It's sad, but I hear ya on that. I have heard some interesting stories from a physician friend of mine on some of his crazy, unstable, etc med school classmates who should never have gotten in, but did because of some high test scores. Go figure. I keep hearing all this talk about holistic review of medical school applicants, but I am somewhat skeptical because of the sheer load of applications schools receive. If you don't meet their magical cut offs in numbers it does not matter if you're Mother Theresa with decent grades, an "acceptable" MCAT, and experience because they will never even see your whole application. It's too bad, but I do understand why some (most?) schools need some procedure for "weeding out" applicants, but it's hard to justify against a lot of holistic review talk these days as well.
I, too, am worried that I did not do exceptionally well (or even just okay for that matter!) on the MCAT and am worried I may get passed over as a result. However, I also realize that at this point there is nothing I can do because I still have no idea my score! I do hold out hope that no matter my unique and "three dimensional" non-trad application will stand out even if my MCAT does not in the end. ktanner777, it sounds like you also bring a lot to the table and from what I have heard medical schools are getting very interested in people like you and I who have a unique vantage point that is only gained from life experience. Throw in all that clinical experience you have and what I am sure are great grades and the MCAT will just be one part of that ap and if it's not a 35+ I really believe the whole of your application will offset that. It's so hard right now in this awful waiting game and I am struggling with it myself, but try to keep positive. We still don't know how our scores will shake out, but many of us have an excellent shot as it is. The MCAT will just complete the picture, but it won't necessarily be the only thing that matters in the end (school dependent I'm sure, but in general I hope this to be true).
Here's to all of us for having reached this point in our pre-med journey! It's not over til it's over. 3 weeks until scores!!!