- Joined
- Dec 26, 2006
- Messages
- 229
- Reaction score
- 0
It seems like there's a lot of disdain for perio on these forums. How come? In other words, why does perio tend to be the least competitive speciality?
Surgical perio stuff is pretty cool, in my book, that that's the type of stuff that the average dental student gets minimal exposure to.
By "surgical perio" do you mean the bone grafting, implants, etc. that Dr. Hobie said OMFSs wish periodontists didn't get into? It seems to me like perio is unpopular with students for what is has traditionally been and unappreciated by oral surgeons who don't like periodontists doing the fun stuff (surgical perio?)
As was said, most students don't appreciate non-surgical perio (SRP).
?
I think most american students don't like it because SRP sucks, everyone had a bad experience with their nazi like perio department in dental school, and if you become a periodontist in todays world you have to tell lies like "our specialty is thriving..", then sneak around and spend all day putting in implants and taking out teeth to make money.
! that's pretty much what I was trying to say. still, what exactly is "surgical perio?" Forgive my D1 ignorance please.
More "traditional" perio surgery usually consists of crown lengthening, soft tissue grafts, regeneration procedures, and pocket reduction procedures. They mainly deal with small modifications to the alveolar bone or gingiva. There are some brief explanations here: http://www.perio.org/consumer/procedures.htm
I think this covers just about everything.?
I think most american students don't like it because SRP sucks, everyone had a bad experience with their nazi like perio department in dental school, and if you become a periodontist in todays world you have to tell lies like "our specialty is thriving..", then sneak around and spend all day putting in implants and taking out teeth to make money.
I think the reason for perio bashing here is that ego ladden OS residents want to have the EXCLUSIVE title to the word "surgery". To call SRP surgery or placing implant "surgery" a bit much but tissue grafting or correction of bony defects in my book is surgery. DP
I think the reason for perio bashing here is that ego ladden OS residents want to have the EXCLUSIVE title to the word "surgery". To call SRP surgery or placing implant "surgery" a bit much but tissue grafting or correction of bony defects in my book is surgery. DP
After speaking with numerous general dentists, they all say that periodontists place the best implants. I don't know how true this is....
I agree. After speaking with numerous general dentists, they all say that periodontists place the best implants. I don't know how true this is, but it seems fairly accurate coming from the people referring out. So I wouldn't say they're sneaking around trying to place implants because, according to GPs, they are the best at doing it anyway!
If periodontists are considered surgeons, then all dentists are surgeons. This however, is just not true. A "surgeon" i.e. general, pediatric, CT, plastic, ENT, OMFS, colorectal, orthopedic etc. spends time training on a general surgery service. Without this general surgery training, none of them would be able to complete their residencies. That is why they are considered surgeons. A periodontist spends no time with general surgery and is therefore not a surgeon. They are dental specialists that do some surgical procedures, but they shouldn't call themselves "surgeons" because of it.
Ok, bring the noise...
I don't know of many people who would want to risk being crippled by getting bone taken from their leg, when a periodontist can just take it from their chin.
I don't know of many people who would want to risk being crippled by getting bone taken from their leg, when a periodontist can just take it from their chin. And I'm not saying all dentists cannot place good implants, I'm saying from what I've heard from GPs, their periodontists have placed the best ones consistently. The oral surgeons have many other things to worry about. You're right, oral surgeons are the final go-to for dental treatment - maybe that's where all the unnecessary arrogance comes from.
OK, you are not yet a 1st year dental student so it's expected that you will be somewhat naive and excited by the limited information you have acquired to this point. The iliac crest (which is the hip, not the leg) is a safe and common location for bone harvesting associated with little morbidity when done properly. Iliac crest bone grafts are done on a regular basis at many oral and maxillofacial surgery residencies. You can't get that quantity of cancellous or cortical bone from any intraoral site, and I doubt if you could get it anywhere else on the body as easily.
As mentioned previously, a common story from GPs I know is that periodontists have acted in financial self-interest (by placing implants not requested by the GP) when referred a patient with a very specific treatment plan, often crown lengthening/pocket reduction. It is a breach of trust and professional conduct to initiate costly, irreversible restorative treatment without consulting the restorative dentist. I can not say enough about how messed up that is! It's a bummer because one of my best friends is going into perio. But what can I say? Sometimes good people make bad choices. Okay, okay. I'm sort of joking.
Perio has an unenviable task. Their specialty took a major hit with the advent of the dental implant. It no longer became necessary to save a tooth at all costs. So much of their specialty revolves around that. It is built into their philosophy. Now they are trying desperately to preserve their future by becoming implant specialists. This propaganda is frequently promulgated by claiming superiority with soft tissue. This is a slap in the face to oral surgeons who have far more surgical experience with far more friable and delicate tissues (e.g. nasal mucosa, the orbit, nerves, vessels, skin, and undoubtedly more that I'm unaware of. Gingiva is one of the most forgiving tissues in the body. Do a few perio surgeries and you'll immediately recognize this. The stuff is incredible.
Ok, I'm done. If you want to do perio that's great. But do PERIO: pocket reduction, crown lengthening, S/RP, CT grafts, gingival grafts, pedicled whatchamajiggers, gingivectomy, bone in a bottle grafting, molar hemisection, root amputation....and sure why not let 'em do simple implants. But don't expect to do treatment under the umbrella of oral and maxillofacial surgery and not catch any flak for it, especially when complications arise.
I agree. After speaking with numerous general dentists, they all say that periodontists place the best implants. I don't know how true this is, but it seems fairly accurate coming from the people referring out. So I wouldn't say they're sneaking around trying to place implants because, according to GPs, they are the best at doing it anyway!
I thought Perio was basically for people who want to be able to SAY they specialized, but don't really WANT to specialize. Sort of to stroke their own ego. You know, the kind of people who want to charge higher fees, but don't really care what they are doing to justify those fees.
Any Thoughts. . .
The fact of the matter is that oral surgeons hate that they spend 100-hour weeks as a hospital resident doing the same stuff as periodontists, while the periodontists are out on the beach with 2+ females bringing in nearly the same amount of dough.
If I do not get into a perio residency, general dentistry is where I'm headed.
If other specialties were to be more proactive on placing implants OMFS would also discredit them.
most of you guys are just going to be extracting thirds and placing implants in your private practices anyway.
Only the most talented OMFS surgeons do the the more complicated procedures.
And what do the more talented OMFS surgeons say about this subject? "who cares about implants if in this specialty you get to reconstruct broken faces".
The only reason why we're all having this discussion is because of the few demi-god OMFS residents with little experience that think they are better than other dentists.
Personally, I think all of the specialties are important and the focus should be on the patient's well being rather than money.
Have some self respect and try to do more complicated procedure rather than bashing other specialties just because they are also doing implants.
I also hate the fact you can't understand half of them.
I personally find it strange why anyone would specialize(with the exception of OMFS, particularly treating pathology, trauma, and jaw reconstruction) when as a general dentist, when you graduate, you really begin your learning and internal specialization. GENERAL DENTISTS PLACE IMPLANTS everyday. Its not brain surgery. If you get the proper training, do the proper treatment preparation, you can place implants, treat molar endo, treat ortho cases, etc.... I can't understand why dental professionals criticize other specialties or GPs unless there is a specific incidence of miscare or unethical treatment of a patient. JMHO
I would suggest you re-read this thread and tell me who has the real ego problem. Honestly, this thing w/ implants is getting old. Any dentist can place them and if other specialties were to be more proactive on placing implants OMFS would also discredit them (there's ego for you). Why you ask? MONEY. I admit OMFS surgeries are pretty cool but lets face it, most of you guys are just going to be extracting thirds and placing implants in your private practices anyway. Only the most talented OMFS surgeons do the the more complicated procedures. And what do the more talented OMFS surgeons say about this subject? "who cares about implants if in this specialty you get to reconstruct broken faces".
The only reason why we're all having this discussion is because of the few demi-god OMFS residents with little experience that think they are better than other dentists. Can you say ego.
Personally, I think all of the specialties are important and the focus should be on the patient's well being rather than money.
OMFS residents: don't dumb yourself by attacking other specialties. There are enough patients to go around. Have some self respect and try to do more complicated procedure rather than bashing other specialties just because they are also doing implants.
Yes, but you don't know what you don't know. I have a friend here in D-school who's dad is a dentist that does lots of Ortho. He did all the ortho on his own kids. My buddy has straight teeth but also has almost an edge to edge bite with shortened root tips and popping and clicking in his jaw, but his dad thought he did a great job. My buddy thought that his dad did well too until after we had ortho classes and labs.
Nice example. Apparently his dad didn't do his homework. If a general dentist does that right training, he can treat ortho cases to the standard of an orthodontist. edge to edge???? please, how can anyone feel this is a good result. Shortened root tips....thats inappropriate force control(although some are just prone to this happening regardless of the treatment). Let me guess, you are interested in ortho residency after your dmd/dds degree...
This is so true at my school as well.
I was talking with one the other day who was from India and asked why they all were so desperate to come here (just to see what he would say).
After talking about it for awhile, he said that when you cut out all the bull, most of them will admit its just to make lots of money. I said," You don't do well in your own country"? He replied that they do very well there too, but that the lifestyle and money here is the best.
:I was a little annoyed and I told him that I dont want to see people coming here "just to make money". I said, "We want people from other countries but we need people of integrity, honesty, and honor. People who will work hard and do the right thing and not just for the money". People who are here for the money are simply here to take advantage.
I was also talking to someone from Iran who basically said the same thing that the money and lifestyle are the most important thing it seems to them and that they push procedures to make money (they didn't say it exactly like this of course). I have to admit I have seen this happen several times and have also had it happen to me and family members outside of D-school and all of them involved foreign trained dentists.
You are a fool if you do not understand why people from other countries want to live here. You obviously have never been to India, Iran, or any developing nation. Do not comment on matters which you fail to comprehend.
Even more evidence of your ignorance regarding the quality of life in foreign countries. After the Indian doctor said that "the lifestyle and money here is the best" and that many come here to make "lots of money", you failed to ask him what constitutes a "lot of money". To you, obviously, it's enough money to drive a benz, live in a million dollar home, put your kids through college without acquiring significant debt, dine out whenever and wherever you feel like, etc. But in a poor country like India, where 700 hundred million people out of 1.1 billion lack access to adequate sanitaton facilities (http://www.csmonitor.com/2007/0215/p04s01-wosc.html), where the per capita income is $3,320 (rank:122 out of 181, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)_per_capita) a "lot of money" means something different entirely. It means you have food on your plate, clothes on your back, a roof over your head, access to running water and sanitation facilities, and electricity. Things most of us living in this country take for granted. In regards to lifestyle, it means living in a country with a lack of significant corruption and enjoying the freedoms that go hand in hand with living in this country. It means you won't be picked up off the street in Iran and taken to jail for a flogging because you decided to wear denim jeans today, and denim jeans are a sign that you have been influenced by western culture. It means you'll never have to worry about significant political or police corruption. You'll never experience corruption so bad that it'd make the New Orleans Police Department look like the NYPD, or leaders like Dick Cheney/Rep. William Jefferson (D) look like Gandhi. It means you'll never be imprisoned for criticizing Ahmadinejad in Iran or Hosni Mubarak in Egypt.
You are a racist and a xenophobe. The second you saw that you would be treated by an Indian doctor, you assumed his purpose for being in this country was inspired by greed and a desire to exploit the American patient population. Without cause, you interrogated your doctor on his motives and assumed that he was here "just to make money". You then had the gall to lecture him on honor, integrity, and honesty.
I find it interesting that so many evil foreigners just walk right up to you and tell you what horrible people they are. It would be interesting if you, too, confessed your true malignant nature, but that would require honor, integrity, and honesty, now wouldn't it?
You are a fool if you do not understand why people from other countries want to live here. You obviously have never been to India, Iran, or any developing nation. Do not comment on matters which you fail to comprehend.
Even more evidence of your ignorance regarding the quality of life in foreign countries. After the Indian doctor said that "the lifestyle and money here is the best" and that many come here to make "lots of money", you failed to ask him what constitutes a "lot of money". To you, obviously, it's enough money to drive a benz, live in a million dollar home, put your kids through college without acquiring significant debt, dine out whenever and wherever you feel like, etc. But in a poor country like India, where 700 hundred million people out of 1.1 billion lack access to adequate sanitaton facilities (http://www.csmonitor.com/2007/0215/p04s01-wosc.html), where the per capita income is $3,320 (rank:122 out of 181, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)_per_capita) a "lot of money" means something different entirely. It means you have food on your plate, clothes on your back, a roof over your head, access to running water and sanitation facilities, and electricity. Things most of us living in this country take for granted. In regards to lifestyle, it means living in a country with a lack of significant corruption and enjoying the freedoms that go hand in hand with living in this country. It means you won't be picked up off the street in Iran and taken to jail for a flogging because you decided to wear denim jeans today, and denim jeans are a sign that you have been influenced by western culture. It means you'll never have to worry about significant political or police corruption. You'll never experience corruption so bad that it'd make the New Orleans Police Department look like the NYPD, or leaders like Dick Cheney/Rep. William Jefferson (D) look like Gandhi. It means you'll never be imprisoned for criticizing Ahmadinejad in Iran or Hosni Mubarak in Egypt.
You are a racist and a xenophobe. The second you saw that you would be treated by an Indian doctor, you assumed his purpose for being in this country was inspired by greed and a desire to exploit the American patient population. Without cause, you interrogated your doctor on his motives and assumed that he was here "just to make money". You then had the gall to lecture him on honor, integrity, and honesty.
I find it interesting that so many evil foreigners just walk right up to you and tell you what horrible people they are. It would be interesting if you, too, confessed your true malignant nature, but that would require honor, integrity, and honesty, now wouldn't it?
You are a fool if you do not understand why people from other countries want to live here. You obviously have never been to India, Iran, or any developing nation. Do not comment on matters which you fail to comprehend.
Even more evidence of your ignorance regarding the quality of life in foreign countries. After the Indian doctor said that "the lifestyle and money here is the best" and that many come here to make "lots of money", you failed to ask him what constitutes a "lot of money". To you, obviously, it's enough money to drive a benz, live in a million dollar home, put your kids through college without acquiring significant debt, dine out whenever and wherever you feel like, etc. But in a poor country like India, where 700 hundred million people out of 1.1 billion lack access to adequate sanitaton facilities (http://www.csmonitor.com/2007/0215/p04s01-wosc.html), where the per capita income is $3,320 (rank:122 out of 181, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_%28PPP)_per_capita) a "lot of money" means something different entirely. It means you have food on your plate, clothes on your back, a roof over your head, access to running water and sanitation facilities, and electricity. Things most of us living in this country take for granted. In regards to lifestyle, it means living in a country with a lack of significant corruption and enjoying the freedoms that go hand in hand with living in this country. It means you won't be picked up off the street in Iran and taken to jail for a flogging because you decided to wear denim jeans today, and denim jeans are a sign that you have been influenced by western culture. It means you'll never have to worry about significant political or police corruption. You'll never experience corruption so bad that it'd make the New Orleans Police Department look like the NYPD, or leaders like Dick Cheney/Rep. William Jefferson (D) look like Gandhi. It means you'll never be imprisoned for criticizing Ahmadinejad in Iran or Hosni Mubarak in Egypt.
You are a racist and a xenophobe. The second you saw that you would be treated by an Indian doctor, you assumed his purpose for being in this country was inspired by greed and a desire to exploit the American patient population. Without cause, you interrogated your doctor on his motives and assumed that he was here "just to make money". You then had the gall to lecture him on honor, integrity, and honesty.
I find it interesting that so many evil foreigners just walk right up to you and tell you what horrible people they are. It would be interesting if you, too, confessed your true malignant nature, but that would require honor, integrity, and honesty, now wouldn't it?
T/F:
ALL of them came from affluent families in these countries you speak of, where most got good education and got into expensive medical schools on their families money. Hell, most of them tell me back in their country they had servants.
And guess what else. We all got into this dentistry gig for the money, the job, and lifestyle. Do you think anyone here would take out hundreds of thousands of dollars in loans, spends countless hours in school and the hospital just to get paid what the guy diggin' ditches gets paid? Hell no. You put in the time, you get a better life. That is why America is great. (now if we could just stop the socialist democrats from trying to reverse this.....)
This is so true at my school as well.
I was talking with one the other day who was from India and asked why they all were so desperate to come here (just to see what he would say). After talking about it for awhile, he said that when you cut out all the bull, most of them will admit its just to make lots of money. I said," You don't do well in your own country"? He replied that they do very well there too, but that the lifestyle and money here is the best. I was a little annoyed and I told him that I dont want to see people coming here "just to make money". I said, "We want people from other countries but we need people of integrity, honesty, and honor. People who will work hard and do the right thing and not just for the money". People who are here for the money are simply here to take advantage.
I was also talking to someone from Iran who basically said the same thing that the money and lifestyle are the most important thing it seems to them and that they push procedures to make money (they didn't say it exactly like this of course). I have to admit I have seen this happen several times and have also had it happen to me and family members outside of D-school and all of them involved foreign trained dentists.