Thoughts on step 2 CS errors

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

canwest4554

New Member
7+ Year Member
Joined
Aug 24, 2014
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Hello everyone. I had a few errors that I have been stressing over for the past 5 weeks. I was wondering whether you think I could fail the ICE portion as a result.

1. In one of my cases, I focussed the entire history taking on the HPI and forgot to go into PMH, PSH, FH, SH, drugs/allergies. This patient required counselling and I put most my emphasis on that aspect. I did a summary, completed the physical exam, and solid closure at the end. I walked out of the room and immediately realised the I had missed a major part of the history taking, but at that stage it is too late to walk back into the room so there was little I could do. I did not include the missing parts in my patient note, as we were strongly advised not to do this.

2. In a phone case with an infants father, again I forgot to ask PMH, PSH, allergies, medications and birth history. I was shocked with myself immediate after hanging up the phone with the patient. Again, I had to leave these parts out of my patient note.

3. On one of the cases, I made an error on my patient note and did not put anything into the diagnostic tests section. I didn't realise this until the time had run out and I had scrolled down on the PN. I felt horrible when I realised my mistake, but I had to move on.

4. I made an error on 2 of the top differentials on the exam. The other 10 I was pretty confident that I made correctly.

On a positive note, I did a through introduction, summary, hand washing, counselling when necessary, physical exam, and closure in every single case. I got along quite well with all the patients and never ran out of time while speaking to them. Every thing else was pretty solid for the most part, it's just that the above mistakes I mentioned have been eating away at me and I'm hopeful to get some reassurance on this forum. I am also wondering if it is true that they consider your top 10 highest cases rather than all 12. If this is true, then I will feel a bit less worried. Thanks.
 
Last edited:
What cases they use are random, it's all based on which one was the experimental case. I think if you were able to balance out the rest of the note with a good differential and workup, it will offset the poor HPI. Just remember, it's the overall experience they grade, so 10 mediocre notes will pass whereas 4 awesome notes 2 mediocre and 4 bad notes will probably fail.
 
Hello everyone. I had a few errors that I have been stressing over for the past 5 weeks. I was wondering whether you think I could fail the ICE portion as a result.

1. In one of my cases, I focussed the entire history taking on the HPI and forgot to go into PMH, PSH, FH, SH, drugs/allergies. This patient required counselling and I put most my emphasis on that aspect. I did a summary, completed the physical exam, and solid closure at the end. I walked out of the room and immediately realised the I had missed a major part of the history taking, but at that stage it is too late to walk back into the room so there was little I could do. I did not include the missing parts in my patient note, as we were strongly advised not to do this.

2. In a phone case with an infants father, again I forgot to ask PMH, PSH, allergies, medications and birth history. I was shocked with myself immediate after hanging up the phone with the patient. Again, I had to leave these parts out of my patient note.

3. On one of the cases, I made an error on my patient note and did not put anything into the diagnostic tests section. I didn't realise this until the time had run out and I had scrolled down on the PN. I felt horrible when I realised my mistake, but I had to move on.

4. I made an error on 2 of the top differentials on the exam. The other 10 I was pretty confident that I made correctly.

On a positive note, I did a through introduction, summary, hand washing, counselling when necessary, physical exam, and closure in every single case. I got along quite well with all the patients and never ran out of time while speaking to them. Every thing else was pretty solid for the most part, it's just that the above mistakes I mentioned have been eating away at me and I'm hopeful to get some reassurance on this forum. I am also wondering if it is true that they consider your top 10 highest cases rather than all 12. If this is true, then I will feel a bit less worried. Thanks.

.
 
Last edited:
As usual, another OP who comes to this site, asks for opinions and then never follows up to let everyone know if he passed or not. We need to delete their threads
 
As usual, another OP who comes to this site, asks for opinions and then never follows up to let everyone know if he passed or not. We need to delete their threads

We would rather see people step up and post shortcomings they've had than to not have them post at all. Would you not agree? A post like this, whilst no conclusion per se, at least gives awareness to others that everyone makes mistakes. And that in turn is a fair service.
 
We would rather see people step up and post shortcomings they've had than to not have them post at all. Would you not agree? A post like this, whilst no conclusion per se, at least gives awareness to others that everyone makes mistakes. And that in turn is a fair service.

Everyone has shortcomings on this test. There's multiple posts on ppl explaining their shortcomings. The only way to benefit from reading about these shortcomings is to find out if the OP passed or not. Then we can compare and contrast mistakes and likelihood of passing.
 
Top