Top bone pathologists

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Alan Schiller? Sharon Wiess? and others I'm sure.
 
Alan Schiller? Sharon Wiess? and others I'm sure.

Sharon Weiss isnt known for bone pathology. She is soft tissue goddess. Unni and McCarthy and the bone kings
 
Last edited:
I'd trust any diagnosis of a bone or soft tissue specimen coming from Paul Wakely at Ohio State. He also happens to be very good with his turnaround time, and only order immunos that he has to.
 
I thought Unni retired. I will look up McCarthy. Thanks.

I'm sure that is true. He is just the only famous one that comes to mind and I am sure Sharon Weiss knows plenty of bone pathology, certainly way more than me.
 
Howard Dorfman at Montefiore Medical Center is first author of one of the older editions of the WHO book on Bone tumors as well as a classic textbook on Bone Tumors. He is still going strong as far as I know:
http://www.montefiore.org/physiciandirectory/index.cfm?provider=3348

Scott Nelson at UCLA is maybe not a big name (yet) but is an excellent bone pathologist and does very good customer service and turnaround time.
http://faculty.pathology.ucla.edu/institution/personnel?personnel_id=8688
 
Last edited:
Well, Unni and Inwards (the heir apparent? maybe that was someone else) are or were both at Mayo, regardless. I've always liked McCarthy at JHU, at least when he did regular teaching sessions for us, but I don't know what the bone consult TAT's are there, nor whether JHU -requires- the consultant to sign off on all consults vs letting the fellows do it. Though, I suspect bone cases are uncommon enough to get personal treatment. I also suspect he's not cheap.

But frankly, anyone who has done a selective fellowship in ortho path at a decent place and works somewhere they actively/currently do ortho surg-onc, is probably going to do a solid job, assuming you're at a place that gets only a tiny number you pretty much always send out.
 
I've heard grumblings/rumors in our department that Inwards at Mayo (who we send the majority of our limited bone stuff to) has recently had a baby or is pregnant and has dropped to half time, thus affecting her turn around time.
 
Justin Cates at Vanderbilt and John Reith at Florida
 
Do people still send consults out of state??

I thought that died...

I havent sent anything out of state since my second month running a practice when Brigham and Womens told me they couldnt 3rd party bill.

Are you paying for it out of pocket or just putting with patient complaints when they get some mondo bill from Mayo and JHU for out of network care??
 
My limited perspective from spending time with a private group in residency, their consults generally went out of state -- but, being a pretty substantial group the send out consults were quite uncommon and esoteric, as the practice put a lot of effort into dealing with everything internally and having appropriate expertise, stains, etc. to do so, thus send-outs generally went to specific big names rather than the local academic affiliate (which, well, was also them). My impression was that they were paid directly by the practice. There were only rare patient/physician requests for send-outs, which I believe were processed differently. But, it's been a while.

There was also that case out in the midwest somewhere in which, again if I recall correctly, one state basically said specimens couldn't go across state lines as a matter of routine and be read in another state by a pathologist not licensed in the specimen's state of origin -- but that 'consults' were OK in that consulting pathologists didn't have to be cross-licensed. Think that thread was on here somewhere last year or thereabouts.
 
Carrie Inwards has grown children (i.e. she's not pregnant). Mayo has 3 BST pathologists including Folpe, Inwards and a new hire who trained at Cleveland Clinic. It's a solid place to send bone.
 
Depends on who you ask. Some believe Rosai is the One Ring to rule them all.
 
Every One Ring has its Sauron and its hobbit. Maybe even two.
 
Top