TLDR; My heart wants to go to UMich but my brain says UCSD is the more logical choice (because I want to do a CA residency).
UMich:
+Big Scholarship (same $ as UCSD)
+Curriculum/Atmosphere
+Students love it here
+Ann Arbor is amazing
+National prestige. Top grad schools all over.
+Sports teams/ school spirit
UCSD:
+Great weather
+Family support
-Raised in SD so I wouldn't mind living elsewhere for a while
UMich:
+Big Scholarship (same $ as UCSD)
+Curriculum/Atmosphere
+Students love it here
+Ann Arbor is amazing
+National prestige. Top grad schools all over.
+Sports teams/ school spirit
UCSD:
+Great weather
+Family support
-Raised in SD so I wouldn't mind living elsewhere for a while