Undergraduate research lab question

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

chemplusmath

New Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Jan 11, 2013
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
I am a freshman that is about to start spring sem this monday. I emailed 6 professors the other day asking for research positions and so far only one has replied to me saying he would take me on if i met with him. He works at my school's affiliated medical school and is researching a topic i feel like i would be interested in but i noticed through searching up on him that he has not published a paper in a while(2009). Should I take his offer and just go with it or it would it be to my advantage to work in the lab of one of the professors that has published multiple papers in 2012?
 
Sometimes it could be that the professor has been working on some major projects and is just getting ready to publish. I had a similar concern - a PI with no pubs since 2008. Turns out, 3 papers got pumped out in 2012, one of which I co-authored.

However, even if a pub isn't in the works, doing research and, perhaps presenting posters at conferences, can be very rewarding.

If getting a pub is a major concern or yours, maybe try and tactfully bring up how he views student authors and the research agenda moving forward? It is likely that the prof will have to churn out some papers to get/stay on tenure track, however it is definitely not guaranteed.
 
I am definitely not turning this offer down if it is the only one I get, and while it isn't everything I was under the assumption that most student researchers strive for getting their name on a published paper. The professor has the title of Chair so I'm not sure if it is particularly pressing for him to bang out papers.
 
As a freshman the best thing you can do is learn some lab skills/techniques/procedures, so go with whoever is willing to take you on. Once you know a little bit about what you're doing, you'll be more valuable to other labs if you decide that the one you started in isn't doing anything you're interested in.
 
Speak to him you can sometimes inquire about the publication drought. The lab I am doing grad school had a 2.5 year drought that my prof brought up in the interview but in the last year we have had 6-7 papers including one in Nature and we have another 3 getting submitted in the next three weeks.

Overall I would worry more if he will be a good mentor for you
 
I am definitely not turning this offer down if it is the only one I get, and while it isn't everything I was under the assumption that most student researchers strive for getting their name on a published paper. The professor has the title of Chair so I'm not sure if it is particularly pressing for him to bang out papers.

I don't think it is very likely you will get a publication in your 1st year. Its certainly possible, but I wouldn't walk in hoping or believing that you will. I'm also hoping to do research this year as well and i'm just hoping to get enough experience in the 1st year.
 
As a freshman the best thing you can do is learn some lab skills/techniques/procedures, so go with whoever is willing to take you on. Once you know a little bit about what you're doing, you'll be more valuable to other labs if you decide that the one you started in isn't doing anything you're interested in.

What is the best time to start worrying about this? I haven't done any lab/research work yet and I'm in my second year. I know I have to get on it soon, but I thought I would have a bit more time. :scared:
 
If research is something you want to do, start looking now. The longer you're there, the more time you have to get something productive done. Doing research for the first time is hard and many a mistake will be made. But starting early gives you time to develop skills and learn something.

If you want to do research in the summer, start looking now. Ppl might already be looking and PIs might need to work out money issues.
 
I'm in a very similar position as you.

Overall, take advantage of it as experience in the lab. Most, if not all, must go through the "grunt work" stage, where you gain experience and work your way up in the lab while doing all the busy work of those higher up than you. You'll have to go through this some time, so why not go through it now?
 
Take the research project.

As a side actvity, ask your advisor for relevant papers, search on your own for more, those will lead to more references, once you have 20+, read them, skim them again, annotate them, try to organize their findings and how they relate in your mind, come up with an outline, and then try to draft a review paper on the subject, complete with your bibliography of references. Make it decent length, but not too long, say 10-20 double spaced pages. THEN when the paper is written, write an abstract for it, trying to distill everything down.

Surprise your advisor by asking him to look at your review and give you feedback.

To get published you need to write papers. To learn how to write, you need to start reading papers. Start by trying to write a review of the area you are working in. It will organize your thoughts, give you knowledge as you read papers, show your advisor you want to write, and maybe even form the kernel of something later, like the intro to a paper. If you write a first draft of something, it is always easier for your advisor or even a Postdoc in the lab to tear it totally apart than for them to come up with something new, but you need that first draft out there first, so the second one is better, and so on.

Start writing early. Don't try to write in a scientific style, just try to write as clearly as you can.

Learning to deal with harsh reviews is something to learn early too.

You also want some deep knowledge of what you are working on, both so it will be more interesting and motivating, but when you go to interviews you can give more details than just how any mLs you pipetted each day.

Passion for a particular area of research s something you just make, not that is inborn. Dive in fully, keep poking at areas you don't understand until you find something cool that you want to tell peope about. That is what a paper is. You can start trying to do that now.
 
I am a freshman that is about to start spring sem this monday. I emailed 6 professors the other day asking for research positions and so far only one has replied to me saying he would take me on if i met with him. He works at my school's affiliated medical school and is researching a topic i feel like i would be interested in but i noticed through searching up on him that he has not published a paper in a while(2009). Should I take his offer and just go with it or it would it be to my advantage to work in the lab of one of the professors that has published multiple papers in 2012?

I wouldn't be too concerned. As other users have written, there are always "lulls" in research. That being said, you do want to see if there are projects that are near completion or papers in the process of being written. If you start doing work and after a while you feel like no one's getting anything done, quietly begin to look for other places.

Also, as a freshman emailing 6 responses isn't very many. Many people at my school email 20+ in order to get 2-3 responses/acceptances. There are a lot of labs that prefer undergrads with some experience. I would continue emailing other PIs if you have the chance. If you don't hear back from anyone else, use this time to build up your skill base so that you're useful to a more active lab.
 
I am a freshman that is about to start spring sem this monday. I emailed 6 professors the other day asking for research positions and so far only one has replied to me saying he would take me on if i met with him. He works at my school's affiliated medical school and is researching a topic i feel like i would be interested in but i noticed through searching up on him that he has not published a paper in a while(2009). Should I take his offer and just go with it or it would it be to my advantage to work in the lab of one of the professors that has published multiple papers in 2012?

Take the offer. Get your feet wet and then move on if you desire. Quality > Quantity. There are many people who made in to top 10 schools with a few years of research and NO pubs
 
Top Bottom