Opinion from a medical student here...
First off, the quality of the program director, Dr. Mahla, is second to none in the entire hospital. Aside from being a master anesthesiologist, he is known quite well for being a model resident advocate.
The program is (well, used to be even more so) large. This program is known for working hard; this is to be distinguished from malignant, and "hard" is usually described in reference to programs where you are done by 3-4pm each day. The program has always been known for working hard, but averages supposedly 55-60 hours/week. There are also lighter months at the VA and outpatient surgical center mixed in with the main OR months. Three + weekends off per month, solid night float here has been in place for years. Good didactics each morning at 0700 Mon-Thurs, with Case Conference Friday AM. UF invented the patient simulator, and implements it well. Also, Dr. Melker (of the Melker cric kit, another UF invention) hosts annual cadaver labs for emergency surgical airways.
UF seems to be strong in most subspecialties. Neuro is especially strong here. If I had to pick a weak spot, it would be peds since there is no free-standing children's hospital. However, UF is a referral center for diaphragmatic hernias and peds liver transplants, and supposedly most residents get almost all of their required peds cases even before they start their peds rotation. PLENTY of hearts to go around; dedicated TEE electives for CA3. Plenty of liver transplants as well. Anesthesiology runs the SICU, and there are some reports that it will also run the CTICU in the near future. Currently applying for level-1 trauma status.
Gainesville is a typical fun, southern college town. We're about an hour from Jacksonville, about 1.5-2 hours from Orlando, 1.5-2 hours from Tampa, 5 hours south of Atlanta. 1.5 hours to East Coast, 1 hour to West Coast. Beautiful campus, and Shands hospital keeps expanding (new tunnel to the MRI center, new breast cancer center, new NICU all currently underway).
Granted, I've yet to hit the interview trail so I have a hard time comparing. Nonetheless, I'm pretty impressed with the program. I get the idea you'll leave prepared for anything, working what I expect would be average for a solid program, in an above-average environment. Huge alumni network, especially in the southeast.