UPenn interns who left?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
ditto on JW's sentiments...i'll be happy whereever I go as long as its not anywhere near philly 4343 or others like him...even if that means not going to a top 10 IM program.

my guess is that this the only place you let your true personality out...everywhere else you just blow smoke up people's ass!!!

i just wonder, philly 4343, is this how you talk day in and day out? is this how you wrote you application essays in the past and for furture residencies? your parents would be so proud, unless of course he's currently Dean of a biggie and isnt impressed by you at all and you are just trying to gain some measure of acceptance?

regardless, i didnt get into the biggest, bestest medschool ever... darn, but i learned plenty and did well on boards and am currently interviewing at Ivy league schools, so someday i can realize the dream of being a small time professor at a big name school and be hated by student like you. Actually, just kidding, although the interviewing part is true, i'm looking for a solid residency no matter what title it has.

i got into medschool to be a good doctor, in addition to being a better person (which puts me 2 up on you), not to brag on some chat room and profess to know so much

the sad thing about a person like you is that there is someone out there who is also from an egomanical, know-it-all, gunner like yourself and will one up you during residency. The universe always settles the score, and you'll get yours...

and i'll still check your school out for myself...

JW😎
 
so from reading this post as an unbiased observer, it seems like you have the opinion of a 'insider medical student' or at least 2 residents currently in the program. People leave programs for varieties of reasons...i think you'll never know everything about any program from the interview itself, so probably should just take everything into consideration and then rank based on that, not just some comments made on a board.

You might go to penn and have fellow interns that just suck, or you might have fellow interns that love football and you get along with them better. You won't know that until you get there...

but whatever, i'm not even in IM and just like checking out the IM boards every now and then.
 
I'm going to chime in here too. I'm also a Penn Med student who has completed the internal medicine clerkship and despite it, decided to apply into medicine. (I don't know philly4343-- glad to see other penn med students use these forums).

Although I can't agree completely with every post that he (or she?) made in his post, a lot of it is unfortunately true. Attendings here do really have big heads and care more about stroking their egos more than taking care of patients.

Also, I have spoken to several residents who agree what philyl4343 said about the interns leaving, but not to the degree that he said it: the interns didnt "run for their lives" but rather disliked the program and decided to switch into different specialties because of it. One left for family reasons. But many residents here are really unhappy -- and have great reasons for it.

As I talk to my classmates now who are also applying into IM, we are all shocked that we weren't scared away by the malignant nature of Penn. In fact, if you ask ANY ANY med student here where they want to do their sub-i, all of them will tell you that the VA or the community hospital is a million times better than the one month hell you endure at HUP. I was unfortunate enough to do a hell sub-i at HUP where I (as a medical student, mind you), went over duty hours 3 of my 4 weeks there. Post call, we were supposed to leave by 12 noon, and I did not ONCE leave before 2pm, often staying until 3 (never later than 3:30). Moreover, regardless of what they say, they do NOT record your hours here. They may estimate them based on their goals of getting you out postcall by 12 noon, but it is not accurate. It's honestly ridiculous that 3 years after the work hour rules have been put in place, we still have not adapted.

The patient load at HUP is the same as all programs mandated by the ACGME, so don't be fooled by anyone telling you they take care of more than the ACGME limit --that would be illegal. The key difference at Penn is that the residents here ALWAYS hover around the maximum numbers on any given day. The patients are not waiting here for disposition issues, either -- you usually take care of 12, actively sick patients who need immediate attention. Every time I went into call, I had exactly the maximum number of patients such that I could admit 5 new patients and reach the cap (if I had more, we would redistribute so I could still admit 5 new patients and max out). Although we do obey the limits of the ACGME, Penn residents work like dogs taking care of their cap # of patients. This is very different than my girlfriend's medical school where some residents can have 2-3 patients going into call.

We also have a new non-teaching service that is run only by NPs and attendings (no residents). However, this non-teaching service was NOT made in response to maintaining the 80 hour/week rule. It was actually made after a hospital in the city, Graduate Hospital, closed its doors and sent enormous numbers of patients to HUP.

However, despite what Philly4343 said, things are not all horrible at Penn.. there are cheesesteaks right outside the hospital for only $3.50. haha, just kidding. There are definite ups at Penn, including how intelligent the residents are, the nurses seem to care about patient care a lot (at least the MICU ones -- the floor nurses are definitely hit or miss, but that's the same at every school). And also, I hear the program director is very nice, although I have never worked with her directly or indirectly, so that is only echoing what some residents told me.

As a side note, I saw a lot of negative comments about philly4343 -- it sucks that his/her posts went from being informative to immature and attacking. Please note that medical students and residents here are, for the most part, very mature and nice people. Don't discount what he/she said, but I apologize for his immaturity.

The nice thing about these forums is you can read the posts, and if you decide to come here, you will at least have some warning about it and not be shocked on your first day/month/year.

Sorry I don't check these forums very often, but I will try to check back now that I have posted here to answer any questions.
 
Originally posted by souljah1
As far as people looking out for themselves- That is true and it is a good thing. Rule number one of a good intern is "Trust no one and expect sabotage". BUT - that doesn't mean that I don't really enjoy working with my co-interns and go out of my way to make sure that my patient list is nice and tucked.
Rule number one is trust no one?? That is so very scary...
The program at our school is not like that -- and I am hoping that most places are not... and "expect sabotage"? I am hoping you didn't mean this like it sounds. Aren't we all on the same team, at least sort of? I mean, if you sabotage someone, it is likely that the patients will be the ones who suffer.
I am missing something here, I hope.
😕
I too have heard things from friends at Penn, such as the IM program being so rough that the surgery residents think it's "hard core".... I think we can all conclude that, like many top programs in the country, it's a tough place. But that doesn't mean it's not an excellent place to train, at least for some.
 
Hey guys,

Never thought I'd run into three people I know on this thread! A whats up to jwag, ro, and paik.

But, lets get to the topic at hand. It seems that there is one medical student here that for whatever reason hates the program. Fair enough, not everyone will love working hard and I wish him good luck in whatever program he ends up going to.

Two residents have posted here and both can't say enough good things about the program. Come interview and talk to us and see if you'll fit in here. You'll learn a ton, work hard, and you'll probably have a great time.
This program really is one of the best places in the country but it has nothing to do with the name -- it has to do with the fact that you'll be surrounded by very nice, caring people that will make working crazy hours not only bearable but ENJOYABLE!

I do want the people reading this thread to know that most people at PENN are nothing like this student. They are NOT this idiotic or this arrogant (dont you love that combination). I hope his rants haven't given applicants a bad sense of what people at PENN are like. An applicant like him would have no chance of being ranked at PENN no matter what his grades, board scores.
 
Cantal: thanks for your honest comments about the Penn program.
Philly4343: your information can be very useful to many people and we're glad you're providing us with a frank opinion of the program at Penn. That said, you really need to lose the attitude! We don't know who you are, but you're not portraying yourself in a very positive light. It probably is true that the Penn grad with High Pass is competitive with the state school grad with Honors (USMLE being similar). However, there's no need to rub it in like a snooty Ivy Leaguer. Again, your data about Penn alumni with High Pass and 230s getting into Derm (with relatively little difficulty) probably is correct. However, a more courteous and professional delivery of this information would go a long way. You're obviously very smart if you got into Penn Med, so why make yourself look silly by making those sorts of comments?
As an alumnus (ugrad) myself, I always liked how Penn was an elite school with a little less 'tude than some of its peers. Your posts are not conveying this image of relative humility. With the recent bad news about the school (former Professor Robb, etc), posts like yours certainly don't help the school's image.
 
Although I can't agree completely with every post that he (or she?) made in his post, a lot of it is unfortunately true. Attendings here do really have big heads and care more about stroking their egos more than taking care of patients.

As I talk to my classmates now who are also applying into IM, we are all shocked that we weren't scared away by the malignant nature of Penn. In fact, if you ask ANY ANY med student here where they want to do their sub-i, all of them will tell you that the VA or the community hospital is a million times better than the one month hell you endure at HUP.

I'm not a Penn med student, but I find your comments interesting about how the more academic of the hospitals you rotate at (HU) is more malignant, . . . I have similar sentiments about big time academic centers, and found that the teaching is as good or perhaps even better at some of the community hospitals. My questions:

1. Do you also feel that you get equivalent training from your community hospital in terms of clinical skills and didactics?

2. What makes HU more malignant or hellish? It seems from your post that it goes beyond long work-hours, but that some of the attendings are not the nicest people around?

Thanks!
 
Top