upset rant about curves in science classes

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Jojo tuna

Junior Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2004
Messages
9
Reaction score
0
Does anyone else feel that having curves in science classes really trip you over when you hear that there are schools out there who do not use curves!? Not to mention my school has about 200 students per/science class! With only top 5% getting 4.0. That means only 10 dudes from 200 people getting 4.0! 😡

Anyone have any constructive opinion regarding this?
 
In my experience, the way that most curves work is that the standard grading system usually falls within the curve, and if it doesn't it's to the student's benefit. For example, in my Organic chemistry class, >84 was an A. On a standard grading scale, >90% is an A. Thus, the curve could only help you. I've never encountered an instance where the curve actually hurt you, especially in classes like organic chemistry or biochemistry where class exam averages frequently fall below the 60% line. Usually a curve is utilized with low class averages. I can see where it COULD hurt you if everyone was scoring 85% on their exams.

I have heard of an instance where the curve was hurting students. A girl in my genetics lecture was telling me how you had to score over 100% in her general physics lecture to get an A because of the curve. In that case, it's just not fair.

I guess since you're posting this you've been the victim of an unfair curve. In that case, I would first talk to your professor. When a professor at my university decides to use a curve system, usually a student speaks up the first day of class and asks "Is it possible that we can score >90% but still get a B"? Usually they'll say no. If that fails, talk to the administration of whatever department your professor is in. Maybe they'll be able to do something.
 
JohnDO said:
In my experience, the way that most curves work is that the standard grading system usually falls within the curve, and if it doesn't it's to the student's benefit. For example, in my Organic chemistry class, >84 was an A. On a standard grading scale, >90% is an A.

I just like to point out some fun facts from my schooling....

My organic average in my classes was in the 50's-60's (ummmm I was the curve breaker....kids hated me)

My Biochem class was NOT curved and he only offered us "bonus" questions to raise our grades....and a bonus assignment that took me 2 months to do!

Now....in my graduate classes you needed to have a >93 to get an A. No joke.....and there was no curve. You had to bust your ass to get that but the staff considers anything below a "B" failing in graduate school. The "B" range was a little nicer it was like 80 or 82 to 93.
 
Haha, I wasn't a "curve buster" in organic 1, as I was one of the 20% who received a "B" in that class. In organic 2 it was ON.
 
Top