UVA/VCU admissions panel

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

u2ecila

Senior Member
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
20+ Year Member
Joined
Jul 12, 2001
Messages
118
Reaction score
0
Hi everyone,
Tonight my husband and I drove down to UVA to see a panel discussion with the deans of admission for UVA and for Virginia Commonwealth Med schools. It was a great discussion! We learned a lot about each school and what they are looking for. Most of the students were 3rd or 4th year undergrads, but there were a few other post bac's besides us. Here is what I learned!

UVA:
We both initially wanted to come down to this talk to find out more about UVA. Last year's entering class had a 3.6 (in state)/ 3.85 (out) GPA, around a 33 MCAT. The average age of entering students was 22 and 1/4 yrs. The dean said they have a couple of 40 yr olds, and everyone else was 21. Ouch! (I am 28). Several people asked about taking a year off before starting/applying, and the dean said that the school prefers students who are entering straight from college or graduate school. If you take time off from school, you better be able to show how you 'matured' during this time. He actually said that several people on the admissions board thought that time off after college was a sign of immaturity, though he did not agree. Hmm. The curriculum has one problem based learning class each year, and offers rotations for 3rd and 4th yrs at hospitals in Charlottesville, Roanoake, and somewhere else I forgot. Clinical opportunities are available for the first two years, but he did not say if it was an elective or required. The curriculum may change in a few years to shorten the first 2 yrs to 1.5 and then add on the chance to book study the second half of the 4th yr. Average debt of students is $62,000, and financial aid is need based. (not good for working class me). 142 students are accepted each year; roughly 1/3 are out of state. No grades post graduation are seriously counted by UVA, only undergraduate grades only are considered. The dean also said be nice to the 4th yr interviewers; sometimes med school applicants are not. That seemed really weird to me - why would anyone be rude in an interview?

Virginia Commonwealth (the one in Richmond):
The average age is 24 yrs, and they have many students with a wide range of career backgrounds. Average dept is $102, average GPA is 3.6, and MCAT is 29 (combined in and out of state). I asked the dean which was better for an older student working full time or going to school full time? She said either one is great, just as long as you are volunteering in a healthcare environment. She also only had positive things to say about the Georgetown Special Masters Program. She mentioned the VMC one year masters/post bac program (not sure which), and said, while there are no guarentees about getting in, those students usually do excellent in med school. The school actually has several married couples right now (yay for us!), and she encouraged us to tell the admissions office we were married. They would place us in different rotations at the same time so prevent possible dependencies. 180 or so students in the large class. 2 years traditional learning, 9-12 in classroom and afternoons in lab. Also, the first two years you actually work a half day every other week in a local drs office and take a class to learn basic clinical skills. I really like that! Rotations can be done in Richmond and also in Farifax at NOVA starting this year. Roughly 45% of Commonwaelth students go into primary care, the other 55% go into all sorts of specialties. Some guy asked her if he should retake the MCAT because of a 9 verbal, and she said don't bother.


Both schools:
Volunteer work in a healthcare, clinical environment is absolutely necessary, unless you want to be a research dr, in which case you need serious research background. Both schools have lost students recently who looked good on paper, but decided they just did not like sick people! They also both said that volunteer work was considered more important in the admission process than research. Essays are also HUGELY important! Neither school admits to having minimum GPA/MCAT requirements (but I have my doubts on this one). They swear they read _every_ one of the 4000+ completed applications from start to finish!

A student athlete asked if the time spent on sports would be considered for a lower GPA. UVA said not really, and Commonwealth said maybe.

All in all, I was impressed with what Virginia Commonwealth presented. While the curriculum is considered more conservative, the admission policy seems more liberal and down to earth. I am not a younger all numbers applicant (until I take the MCAT in April, hahahaa), and I think they may take that into account. UVA seems to have a definate medical student applicant in mind, which is fine, but its not going to be me or my husband. I did like the UVA campus, and both the dean and the students were very friendly and nice. the new curriculum sounds great too.

Anyway, if anyone has any questions, please post them. Commonwealth said that they only offer tours to premed groups, so if anyone wants to start a SDN Club and go visit, let me know.


Good night all!

u2ecila
 
Hey,

Thanks for the great post!

I went to this roundtable last year and did not find it nearly as informative as you did. It sounds like they did a much better job this year than last. Last year they didn't really do anything except repeat the obvious (UVa is in cville, MCV is in Richmond, etc)

What kindof angers me is U.Va.s attitude towards those who take some time off or did a career change. If what you said is accurate (I havent heard it before) and Im sure it probably is, I would not understand why they would not consider post bac programs to be equally as acceptable as undergraduate performance. It would seem to me that the non traditional student has a lot to offer in terms of deiversifying the class and coming to med school with less of a tunnel vision that so many premeds can bring in.

That being said ... if this is true, I am glad I didn't apply to my alma mater for med school. If the SOM continues to have the same closed minded attitude in the future (and doesn't take a line from MCV!!! (VCU)) it may very well affect future givings to the med school, which I can testify they are in need of.... (look at the tuition increase).

Coops
 
I heard a similar talk from VCU and UVA reps last fall (at VCU). I also got the impression UVA wasn't really interested in me as a candidate (I'm 35 and a career-changer). It's a great school, but I would prefer to go somewhere that values what I bring to the table as a more experienced (read, old!) student.
 
Yep..I don't know about UVA, but MCV is definitely friendly to the "nontraditional student" such as myself (I was 27 when I got in, will be 29 in a couple of months). Many people in my class come from non-traditional backgrounds and from other careers. Many others are married and have children, or actually had children while in school (a girl in our class had her son the summer between M1 and M2).

All in all, they are very sensitive to the needs of students, and pretty much bend over backwards to accomodate us. I am very happy here, and wouldn't trade it for any other medical school.

Please email if you have any questions! [email protected]
 
You know, it?s so interesting to read this since I didn?t know UVA thought this way when I applied there and it?s completely at odds with my experience with them. The irony is that I am the antithesis of the ideal UVA candidate: I?ll be five years out of undergrad when I start school this year; I applied as out-of-state with a mediocre 3.5; the last time I did any medical volunteering was way back in undergrad; heck, the last time I did anything medically related was four years ago working for a medical company, and despite that I received the interview invite in Sep. in ~2 weeks of my completed app, the acceptance letter was in my hands within a week of my interview, and to top it all off, my faculty interviewer was the man himself, the Dean of Admissions, Dean Canterbury.
I didn?t know at the time that he was the Dean, they just told us he was clinical faculty, a psychiatrist, who had stepped in when the scheduled faculty interviewer injured his leg or something. It was only when I saw his name on the acceptance letter that I realized who he was. I had also heard that NYU was skewed towards a young class but they sent me an interview invite too. Now, I?m not saying that you can extrapolate very far from the singular data point of my experience, but it does seem that the ?rules? of any particular med. school are not always very evenly or consistently applied.
 
phenolphthalein:
Thanks for sharing your experience. It's Dr. Canterbury who spoke at the presentation at VCU, and from him that I got my first - negative - impression of UVA as not particularly welcoming to non-trads. I may have been mistaken in that impression, and I hope that I was, because it was disappointing given all UVA's good qualities in other areas.
 
There are a lot of non-traditional students at UVA. Me being one of them. Id' say that about 40-50% of those in our class took some time off after undergrad. There are a lot of "young" people in our class but the class of 2006 is much more diverse than we are in relation to age. DOn't count yourself out if you are a non-trad. I am and thought that I ad no chance at acceptance but as you can see I am here. I think UVA is the best overall program in Virginia and can open quite a few doors when applying for residency. If y'all have any more questions PM me.
 
aquaboy:

I'm curious as to what you mean by "opening doors" for residency. Are the attendings there particularly well-connected? Does the school's reputation carry more weight than most others? This isn't an attack, I am honestly wondering what you mean. Thanks in advance.
 
my husband was admitted to UVa post-bacc, out of state. it seems to me that they *did* take his post-bacc gpa into consideration - significantly - and it surprises me that the dean would have said otherwise. his undergrad was 3.1, post-bacc 3.8-ish, mcat 33. he also took several years off after undergrad and completely changed his career direction.

UVa is definitely a possibility for non-trad applicants. in fact, he got the feeling that they were much more concerned with getting a picture of his application as a whole, than just checking to see if he was 21 (he's not) and had a good undergrad GPA (he didn't).
 
Originally posted by jdr
aquaboy:

I'm curious as to what you mean by "opening doors" for residency. Are the attendings there particularly well-connected? Does the school's reputation carry more weight than most others? This isn't an attack, I am honestly wondering what you mean. Thanks in advance.

Look at the match list, quite a few at well known schools (Harvard, Duke, etc.) The faculty is "well-connected" and the school reputation does carry some weight but not that much, plus the board scores here are around an average of 230. The match list can be seen at:

http://www.med-ed.virginia.edu/handbook/residency/Match/03/index.cfm
 
As a Virginia resident, it's quite clear to me that VCU/MCV is much more accomodating to older non-traditional applicants. UVA has a much younger class than either of the other two state schools.

While I skipped out on the Admissions Panel the other day (I was in my Uechi Ryu Karate class, w00t!), the opinions of deans should always be taken with a word of caution. Sure the dean may have his/her own opinion on admissions, but in the end it's a committee vote that decides your admission, not the dean's. So don't be discouraged by what any one person has to say about your chances at med school. Go get 'em! 🙂

tf
 
Top