- Joined
- Feb 15, 2009
- Messages
- 19,181
- Reaction score
- 26,643
"I'm a Democrat. I also prefer cheddar cheese and am a Green Bay Packers fan. Can we do this professional psychotherapy thing now? Yes? Great."
Eww, just eww.
"I'm a Democrat. I also prefer cheddar cheese and am a Green Bay Packers fan. Can we do this professional psychotherapy thing now? Yes? Great."
Eww, just eww.
In the hierarchy of all things Wisconsin, is insulting the Green Bay Packers above or below insulting cheddar cheese?
In the hierarchy of all things Wisconsin, is insulting the Green Bay Packers above or below insulting cheddar cheese?
I hear you. I just want to be alone, and am finding it hard to sit in session with patients without trying to guess in my head whether or not they voted to strip me and so many others of our fundamental rights. It is also so difficult to make room for space for both patients and those in my personal life who are struggling. Broke down in my office today between sessions for probably the first time of many.I probably needed another day or two at home. I'm just sitting in my office in tears. Fortunately, I almost never get emotional in session, so that shouldn't be an issue. I'll set firm boundaries about election talk. I truly just want to be left alone by the vast majority of people right now.
My stance at work has always been to fix a problem when I see one and advocate hard when I see injustices. It is a weekly, often multiple times a week, grind that I have been doing behind the scenes to make things less terrible for everyone. It's funny that I was just talking about burning out. I think I, along with a lot of Black women, are letting other people lead the charge for change. We are tired. Whatever folks need in this moment is probably in a book written by a Black woman/queer person in the 70s.
I hope you are taking the time to take care of yourself too.I hear you. I just want to be alone, and am finding it hard to sit in session with patients without trying to guess in my head whether or not they voted to strip me and so many others of our fundamental rights. It is also so difficult to make room for space for both patients and those in my personal life who are struggling. Broke down in my office today between sessions for probably the first time of many.
I'm no legal expert, but I think it's exceedingly unlikely they'd be able to make substantive changes for existing borrowers. Other than maybe telling whoever it is that reviews the applications for forgiveness to be very strict with rules.Do we have any knowledge of if the Trump admin can gut EDRP for those already approved? No reason for me to stay at VA and make less as the hiring freeze continues if they're not going to cover my student loans.
It's been a long time since I did anything at a VA but this does not seem like the utter catastrophe that you might have feared.
Yeah, this chapter really wasn't looking for any radical sea change. Especially compared to other sections. And, as seen in many of my comments over the years, I actually agree with reducing waste and fraud in the VA/VHA/VBA. Hard to think they'd do anything meaningful with SC, though, as it'd piss of a very vocal part of their base which is in favor of unlimited welfare as long as they are the only recipients.
I agree that this does not sound terrible. Where I am concerned is if we will get the DEI training ban again and concern for loss of LGBT groups and women’s services. The stuff I’ve seen floating around online about a loyalty oath to the administration is also highly concerning.So, I am . . . so much not a fan of the Heritage Foundation, but if you read the section of the proposal on the VA, it is at odds with what you might naïvely expect.
1. They envision shifting resources from aging healthcare campuses to CBOCs and actually expanding CBOCs as the main priority for new facilities.
2. Pilot program of Saturday and extended weekday hours if excess capacity is identified and delays are past a certain standard
3. "Identify clinical services that are consistently in high demand butrequire cost-prohibitive compensation to recruit and retain talent, andexamine exceptions for higher competitive pay."
4. "Assess recruitment and retention in highly competitive medical markets to identify common limiting factors for attracting high-demand, specialized occupations."
5. "Consider expanding VA tuition assistance in exchange for reciprocal service in rural or understaffed VAMCs."
6. Examine surpluses and deficits of mental health personnel "recognizing that the department needs a blend of social workers, therapists, psychologists, and psychiatrists with a focus on attracting high-quality talent."
7. "Continue to maximize the use of new VA hiring and pay authorities providedby Congress in the RAISE Act6 and PACT Act as well as existing authorities in student loan forgiveness and the Public Service Loan Forgiveness program."
8. Accelerate time table for revising disability/service-connection standards (they are 100% trying to shrink this)
In the section covering overall proposed bureaucratic reforms the main thing that seems to be suggested for GS-13 to GS-15 is to introduce an actual system of merit pay.
It's been a long time since I did anything at a VA but this does not seem like the utter catastrophe that you might have feared.
Reading a bit more, this seems to coincide with a plan to prioritize primary care and outpatient mental health, and substance abuse while relying on private medical centers for specialty care. There was a reference to a 2018 study of VHA facilities that can be found online that breaks tecs down by VISN. It seems this includes closing a number inpatient psych units.So, I am . . . so much not a fan of the Heritage Foundation, but if you read the section of the proposal on the VA, it is at odds with what you might naïvely expect.
1. They envision shifting resources from aging healthcare campuses to CBOCs and actually expanding CBOCs as the main priority for new facilities.
This has been done before. Problem is that VA staff don't want to work Saturdays often. Frankly, I don't want extended week days either. One benefit of VA hours and lack of non-competes is having a part-time PP.2. Pilot program of Saturday and extended weekday hours if excess capacity is identified and delays are past a certain standard
How #6 is implemented matters greatly. I had this issue pop up a few years ago and the problem is the talking heads don't understand what specialty psych folks do.3. "Identify clinical services that are consistently in high demand butrequire cost-prohibitive compensation to recruit and retain talent, andexamine exceptions for higher competitive pay."
4. "Assess recruitment and retention in highly competitive medical markets to identify common limiting factors for attracting high-demand, specialized occupations."
5. "Consider expanding VA tuition assistance in exchange for reciprocal service in rural or understaffed VAMCs."
6. Examine surpluses and deficits of mental health personnel "recognizing that the department needs a blend of social workers, therapists, psychologists, and psychiatrists with a focus on attracting high-quality talent."
This is going to be aimed at vets with new sc that won't know any better. I imagine some of the caregiver support money may go as well.7. "Continue to maximize the use of new VA hiring and pay authorities providedby Congress in the RAISE Act6 and PACT Act as well as existing authorities in student loan forgiveness and the Public Service Loan Forgiveness program."
8. Accelerate time table for revising disability/service-connection standards (they are 100% trying to shrink this)
The issues I am concerned about are the stances on remote work (suggesting elimination of positions or pay reductions), the push for community care that was draining the VHA budget, and a reduction in specialty areas such as MST or GEC.In the section covering overall proposed bureaucratic reforms the main thing that seems to be suggested for GS-13 to GS-15 is to introduce an actual system of merit pay.
It's been a long time since I did anything at a VA but this does not seem like the utter catastrophe that you might have feared.
This has been done before. Problem is that VA staff don't want to work Saturdays often. Frankly, I don't want extended week days either. One benefit of VA hours and lack of non-competes is having a part-time PP.
The other problem that is massively contributing to 'access' issues are people using the VA mental health clinics as a means to a service-connected end. The pending re-definition of the service-connected rating scale (0-100%) criteria for mental health conditions (including PTSD) is going to lead to a massive influx of cases into MH and PTSD specialty clinics over the next couple of years when veterans are being told to go to their mental health providers to gather/document 'evidence' that they actually qualify for a higher (especially '100%') s/c rating. Since the criteria for MH conditions have always been vague and based on patient self-report, this has always been a problem (and led to the massive increase in average %age of s/c over the past several decades--driven primarily by high %age s/c for mental health conditions) but it will get MUCH worse as the specific clinical criteria (e.g., things like lack of personal hygiene, chronic/severe risks to self/others, frank psychotic symptoms, forgetting one's 'own name' at times [dementia/delirium]) will no longer apply to the 100% threshold.You could probably get enough staff interested in Saturdays if the incentives were good enough. However, I suspect that incentives would be minimal and it would be implemented via metric (i.e. you have to have X% of department clinical hours on Saturdays or we get mad at you). I don't think they even can meaningfully incentivize physicians to work Saturdays, since we can't get overtime, comp time, etc.
One problem with Saturdays would also be that the cost-efficiency of care would be dramatically reduced - you probably incur practically all the expenses of having the facility open (i.e. lights, HVAC, etc.) to run it a fraction of weekday capacity.
There would be a better case for Saturdays if we were facility-limited (it would increase effective facility capacity by ~20%) we are more staffing-limited. The problem right now is much more the clinicians not having time to see their veterans than vice versa. Forcing people to work Saturdays would make that staffing issue worse rather quickly.
The other problem that is massively contributing to 'access' issues are people using the VA mental health clinics as a means to a service-connected end. The pending re-definition of the service-connected rating scale (0-100%) criteria for mental health conditions (including PTSD) is going to lead to a massive influx of cases into MH and PTSD specialty clinics over the next couple of years when veterans are being told to go to their mental health providers to gather/document 'evidence' that they actually qualify for a higher (especially '100%') s/c rating. Since the criteria for MH conditions have always been vague and based on patient self-report, this has always been a problem (and led to the massive increase in average %age of s/c over the past several decades--driven primarily by high %age s/c for mental health conditions) but it will get MUCH worse as the specific clinical criteria (e.g., things like lack of personal hygiene, chronic/severe risks to self/others, frank psychotic symptoms, forgetting one's 'own name' at times [dementia/delirium]) will no longer apply to the 100% threshold.
I'd estimate that only about one in five cases I see on a regular basis are actually there to participate in active and effective psychotherapy.
We don't really have an 'access' problem...or, for that matter, even a problem with 'under-staffing' of competent MH therapists.
We have a systems problem that fails to properly redirect veterans who are merely seeking to audition for higher levels of s/c benefits to other destinations than MH treatment clinics.
Agreed. The system is utterly, utterly broken and there are absolutely NO incentives for the providers for responding any differently within the context of such a broken system. And there are plenty of very harsh disincentives to engaging in any course of action that would upset a veteran.I'll add to this a poorly designed grid system of employee evaluation that reinforces "forever supportive therapy" in order to make your numbers rather than engaging in proper care. Combine that with political headaches if you don't offer a veteran any care they want (Whitehouse hotline, congressional complaints) and there is no reason to engage in proper care other than wanting to make your own life a bit harder.
Same--years ago, we had a Saturday half-day clinic that I think was limited mainly to primary care and MH, and that basically went unused. Evening hours seem like they were/are somewhat more popular, but then you have to get leadership either to approve extra compensation for the providers for working past their normal TOD (and I doubt comp time would swing it), or to approve non-traditional work schedules (e.g., 4x10, showing up later then 07:30 or 08:00), which they seem hesitant to do for some reason.I'll do you one better: we HAD Saturday clinic for a long time at our CBOC, but ended up discontinuing it because patients never used it and it was just wasting money.
Project 2025 did talk about reducing eligibility for VA healthcare for certain groups. Now that would actually help access and f/u access issues, lol.
I always loved the fact that leadership was so stingy with compensating providers for time spent in scheduled appointments delivering actual care (and verifiable difficult 'work') to patients but has absolutely no issue with all the 'frills' like paying people full-time FTE's to do things like send emails all day long and conduct 'drum circle' sessions or order t-shirts with slogans on them or, etc., etc., etc.Same--years ago, we had a Saturday half-day clinic that I think was limited mainly to primary care and MH, and that basically went unused. Evening hours seem like they were/are somewhat more popular, but then you have to get leadership either to approve extra compensation for the providers for working past their normal TOD (and I doubt comp time would swing it), or to approve non-traditional work schedules (e.g., 4x10, showing up later then 07:30 or 08:00), which they seem hesitant to do for some reason.
I always loved the fact that leadership was so stingy with compensating providers for time spent in scheduled appointments delivering actual care (and verifiable difficult 'work') to patients but has absolutely no issue with all the 'frills' like paying people full-time FTE's to do things like send emails all day long and conduct 'drum circle' sessions or order t-shirts with slogans on them or, etc., etc., etc.
Also, with all the provider vacancies we have...where the hell is all that saved money going to? They couldn't at least pay the providers they have now for time and effort providing extra services after hours? It makes no sense.
You know, it strikes that in all these discussions of the VA healthcare system, there is not one where it is suggested that the VA is getting better any time soon. Certainly, the days I head about with stories of two hour lunches where clinicians played golf are gone. If all the good jobs are gone, what is the draw of the VA? I get the frustration over drum circles and other nonsense, but those are the last jobs where people are not being squeezed for the last ounce of "productivity". I have managed to have a fairly productive career helping folks without being beholden to "the grid" but I do fear those days are coming to a close. It is quite a shame that we have gotten to a point where even federal service is not considered a decent and stable job (if boring). I remember my dad (a civil servant himself) saying many years ago to go work for the government if you want work and life balance. I wonder what he would say now.
when i was on internship 12 years ago, the lunches were an definitely always an hour. There was ongoing lunch ping-pong league/tournament amongst some of the psychologists in the rec room. Some psychologists went home for lunch and came back (relatively small town area). The chief locked everything up at 4:29 exactly and really everyone left at 430 on the dot. No one seemed overly stressed or overworked. Like at all. At least not there.
Funny you say that. My internship at the VA was nothing like that and that was about 15 yrs ago. However, it was also in NYC and I think the culture there is also different. VAs where I did my externship were also quite busy, but not as bad. One of the reasons I chose jobs in less populated areas was a slightly slower pace and the ability to take my time with patients.
This was before the MH suite program, MH tx coordinators, CPRS checkbox overloads, and before the Shinseki scandal and really any push for access, much less same day access. It was a college town with a VA medical center with full range outpatient medical services, a CLC, A PTSD residential tx program, and an inpatient psych unit. But no inpatient medical beds, i dont think.
well, they weren't really that busy, pretty confident of that. lunches were long (no one EVER ate lunch at their desk), people went home for lunch often, and everyone left right at 430, even the service chief. I'm sure there were plenty of frustrations but it simply was not as busy or overwhelming there at that time as its seems to be at most places now.To be fair, interns and even post docs are also often shielded from the issues that staff psychologists face within the VA. I know that I was!
Unsurprisingly and nothing will happen, unfortunately.
What did he say?Incoming SecDef coming in hot on SC.
I just saw a brief clip a friend sent. Paraphrasing, it was something like--he briefly described the SC rating system and then said veterans organizations are encouraging veterans to apply for anything and everything, and to try to take everything they can get from the government, rather than to just apply for what may be necessary based on their service, and to then go on with the next phase of their lives.What did he say?
I just saw a brief clip a friend sent. Paraphrasing, it was something like--he briefly described the SC rating system and then said veterans organizations are encouraging veterans to apply for anything and everything, and to try to take everything they can get from the government, rather than to just apply for what may be necessary based on their service, and to then go on with the next phase of their lives.
Oh man, this is going to be a fun four years to watch. Truly FAFO in action.
Trump is picking Matt Gaetz as AG, hoo boy.
I mean, how much damage could a rejected, likely pedophile, extra from Swingers do in four years?
I plan on doing my Black job and trying to stay out of the crossfire.I'm kind of at a stage where I'm like, just busting out the popcorn. As awful as it sounds, like, this is apparently what people wanted sooo
I plan on doing my Black job and trying to stay out of the crossfire.
I was spared because that story went stale and now something else is scary. I think we're mad at the generals right now.I thought dog eating Haitians took all of those jobs?
The solution is in the problem: before we can grasp one despair-invoking absurdity, they come out with a new one, ad infinitum (or at least ad 2029)I was spared because that story went stale and now something else is scary. I think we're mad at the generals right now.
I'm kind of at a stage where I'm like, just busting out the popcorn. As awful as it sounds, like, this is apparently what people wanted sooo
I'm kind of at a stage where I'm like, just busting out the popcorn. As awful as it sounds, like, this is apparently what people wanted sooo
So...what is the quality of work-life there now? I have been gone 7 years now. As I said before, it used to be pretty cush before mid 2014, especially at the smaller places. Now it seems more like a workhouse??? Unless in some specialty area?I'm not happy but I was always prepared for this possibility and planned accordingly. Unfortunately, a lot of good folks will likely face some setbacks who are not as well prepared as I am. That said, all that is left to do is to breakout the popcorn.
Who knows, maybe Trump will double my pay as a government contractor.
"10 to 15 psychologists on staff there at one time to address VA org dysfunction, Lean Process, and other troubleshooting."So...what is the quality of work-life there now? I have been gone 7 years now. As I said before, it used to be pretty cush before mid 2014, especially at the smaller places. Now it seems more like a workhouse??? Unless in some specialty area?
Do they still do those cushy "Central Office" jobs for the Psychologists where you do some trainings and mostly work remotely and travel once a month or so?
What happened to the Org Development Office based out of the Cinci VA? They had like 10-15 psychologists on staff there at one time to address VA org dysfunction, Lean Process, and other trouble shooting. I almost applied for a post-doc doing that stuff.
So...what is the quality of work-life there now? I have been gone 7 years now. As I said before, it used to be pretty cush before mid 2014, especially at the smaller places. Now it seems more like a workhouse??? Unless in some specialty area?
Do they still do those cushy "Central Office" jobs for the Psychologists where you do some trainings and mostly work remotely and travel once a month or so?
What happened to the Org Development Office based out of the Cinci VA? They had like 10-15 psychologists on staff there at one time to address VA org dysfunction, Lean Process, and other trouble shooting. I almost applied for a post-doc doing that stuff.
I wonder what that would look like for all the clinics struggling with space. Even with teleworking and remote positions, space is a significant issue. I imagine addressing actual problems isn't the goal though. We're working off vibes here.There are some pretty substantial rumors that the new administration is not going to allow any telework for federal employees, so I'm not sure what that would mean for those cushy VACO jobs