Wanna critique my SHPEP 2025 Personal Essay Draft?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

pinkyless

New Member
Joined
Nov 18, 2024
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
I am applying for the Summer 2025 SHPEP and just wrote up my first personal essay draft. Feel free to give me any critique or advice, I'm really hoping to get into this program so be as ruthless as you can!

Essay:

[Redacted For privacy]

Members don't see this ad.
 
Last edited:
I am applying for the Summer 2025 SHPEP and just wrote up my first personal essay draft. Feel free to give me any critique or advice, I'm really hoping to get into this program so be as ruthless as you can!

Essay:

Laying on my back with the hot Texas sun beaming down on my face, it suddenly occurred to me that I wasn’t going to be able to be a pilot anymore. I still feel the rough grit of the non-skid decking on the back of my head sometimes, and I still see the haunting image of bright red liquid spurting out of my hand as I fall backward onto the deck of the boat. That brief moment is something that I re-live almost every day, and I’m actually grateful for it.

Growing up, I didn’t go to the dentist for the first 10 years of my life. Some of the only memories I have of my mom are of her stuffing my SpongeBob toothbrush into my mouth and brushing until my gums were bleeding. The few times a month she would do that would qualify as the only dental care I would receive for the first half of my childhood. When I moved in with my dad, it would be different. I remember how embarrassed I was going to the dentist for the first time as a kid. My teeth were crooked and yellow, and even though the whole point of going there is for them to treat your oral health, to me it was a death sentence. Instead of getting the evil man in the giant white jacket who would point and laugh at my teeth that I had made up in my mind, my childhood dentist was actually the nicest man I had ever met. From that point on, I was excited to go to the dentist and get my semi-annual cleaning.

Unfortunately, my passion for dentistry would be overlooked by my lack of college funds, and instead of going to school like most people my age after high school, I decided to enlist into the United States Coast Guard and put a few miles on my soul while also getting my college paid for. I was always pressured into being a pilot; my dad was a pilot and wanted a son to follow in his footsteps. That dream would be crushed for both him and me only 4 short months after I graduated boot camp, at the ripe age of 18 years and 3 months.

We had been underway for almost a week at that point, and the constant cycle of standing watch, doing law enforcement boardings, eating, sleeping, and waking up for watch again was wearing on my body. The little 87-foot boat I was stationed on was short and tall, the perfect combination to make you feel every single wave that you came across. I was on watch and was told to catch the small boat that was coming back from a safety boarding, a task I had done dozens of times. This time should’ve been no different. Except for the small fact that my hand got stuck in the hydraulic winch and tore off two fingers from my right hand. Apparently, the first thing I said was “I’m not gonna fly.” I don’t remember that since I was in shock from losing two fingers.

I still vividly re-live that moment, but not with contempt, but with appreciation. I went on to be a flight mechanic on rescue helicopters, but instead of falling in love with the sky, I fell in love with helping people. I want to be that dentist who helps a 10-year-old boy not be scared of being judged, and I want to help treat people who might not have the money it costs at expensive private practices.
it's good
except for the bolded part
it's a run-on sentence...
 
Members don't see this ad :)
Yeah I don't know how that slipped past my first proof read, that things a whole paragraph on its own. Thank you!
it's more than good enough for an shpep essay
would need more fleshing out to be a d school personal statement
but it's a good start...
 
What's the prompt?
“describe how your personal background, interests, and experiences have led you to pursue a career in healthcare, highlighting what unique aspects of your story you want the program sites to know that might not be captured elsewhere in your application, including your potential interest in addressing healthcare disparities and diversity within the field.”
 
It's been a while since I had to review SHPEP essays, so I hope the SHPEP ambassadors who have posted in the forums before are still active. Message them to see if they can also give you advice.

First of all, what year will you complete in the spring? First/second/third year undergrad/community college, etc.? I want to have some expectations on the writing.

In general, I like the story, but I don't like the setup. You will hear different opinions on "show don't tell" in a personal statement, but I am a proponent of "tell me early." The first paragraph sounds very impressionistic, as if I'm staring into a Monet painting looking at different colors blending together to form some sort of image that I'm supposed to see (water lilies)... but it just takes a lot of time and is too far removed from where you want your narrative and this image to converge. If I have to review a few dozen personal statements for SHPEP, it doesn't help me to start there (as opposed to some expository writing for a medical narrative).

In short, get rid of that first paragraph. Why is that paragraph important to show us how you want to pursue a healthcare career? I think everything else stands quite well. Just make sure you address the prompt as necessary.
 
It's been a while since I had to review SHPEP essays, so I hope the SHPEP ambassadors who have posted in the forums before are still active. Message them to see if they can also give you advice.

First of all, what year will you complete in the spring? First/second/third year undergrad/community college, etc.? I want to have some expectations on the writing.

In general, I like the story, but I don't like the setup. You will hear different opinions on "show don't tell" in a personal statement, but I am a proponent of "tell me early." The first paragraph sounds very impressionistic, as if I'm staring into a Monet painting looking at different colors blending together to form some sort of image that I'm supposed to see (water lilies)... but it just takes a lot of time and is too far removed from where you want your narrative and this image to converge. If I have to review a few dozen personal statements for SHPEP, it doesn't help me to start there (as opposed to some expository writing for a medical narrative).

In short, get rid of that first paragraph. Why is that paragraph important to show us how you want to pursue a healthcare career? I think everything else stands quite well. Just make sure you address the prompt as necessary.
Thanks for the reply! I'm a sophomore completing my first year in a 4 year university after a year at a CC.

I also hate the show not tell method; I'm used to being straight to the point when writing, but after being coached by various writing professionals for college apps and essays, this is where I'm at. My idea was that it acted as a hook for the reviewer, but I agree that it takes up too much of the essay. I'll knock it down and and address the prompt a bit more. Appreciate the feedback!
 
I am applying for the Summer 2025 SHPEP and just wrote up my first personal essay draft. Feel free to give me any critique or advice, I'm really hoping to get into this program so be as ruthless as you can!

Essay:

Laying on my back with the hot Texas sun beaming down on my face, it suddenly occurred to me that I wasn’t going to be able to be a pilot anymore. I still feel the rough grit of the non-skid decking on the back of my head sometimes, and I still see the haunting image of bright red liquid spurting out of my hand as I fall backward onto the deck of the boat. That brief moment is something that I re-live almost every day, and I’m actually grateful for it.

Growing up, I didn’t go to the dentist for the first 10 years of my life. Some of the only memories I have of my mom are of her stuffing my SpongeBob toothbrush into my mouth and brushing until my gums were bleeding. The few times a month she would do that would qualify as the only dental care I would receive for the first half of my childhood. When I moved in with my dad, it would be different. I remember how embarrassed I was going to the dentist for the first time as a kid. My teeth were crooked and yellow, and even though the whole point of going there is for them to treat your oral health, to me it was a death sentence. Instead of getting the evil man in the giant white jacket who would point and laugh at my teeth that I had made up in my mind, my childhood dentist was actually the nicest man I had ever met. From that point on, I was excited to go to the dentist and get my semi-annual cleaning.

Unfortunately, my passion for dentistry would be overlooked by my lack of college funds, and instead of going to school like most people my age after high school, I decided to enlist into the United States Coast Guard and put a few miles on my soul while also getting my college paid for. I was always pressured into being a pilot; my dad was a pilot and wanted a son to follow in his footsteps. That dream would be crushed for both him and me only 4 short months after I graduated boot camp, at the ripe age of 18 years and 3 months.

We had been underway for almost a week at that point, and the constant cycle of standing watch, doing law enforcement boardings, eating, sleeping, and waking up for watch again was wearing on my body. The little 87-foot boat I was stationed on was short and tall, the perfect combination to make you feel every single wave that you came across. I was on watch and was told to catch the small boat that was coming back from a safety boarding, a task I had done dozens of times. This time should’ve been no different. Except for the small fact that my hand got stuck in the hydraulic winch and tore off two fingers from my right hand. Apparently, the first thing I said was “I’m not gonna fly.” I don’t remember that since I was in shock from losing two fingers.

I still vividly re-live that moment, but not with contempt, but with appreciation. I went on to be a flight mechanic on rescue helicopters, but instead of falling in love with the sky, I fell in love with helping people. I want to be that dentist who helps a 10-year-old boy not be scared of being judged, and I want to help treat people who might not have the money it costs at expensive private practices.
take out the first but...
 
Top