What does it mean to be disadvantaged?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Alexphd

New Member
7+ Year Member
Joined
Jul 15, 2014
Messages
9
Reaction score
2
Hello everyone,

I am struggling to understand what it means to be disadvantaged. It seems by definition I qualify, but I don't feel like I am, and I am certainly better off than many other people.

My parents moved to the US when I was three, and started off with whatever minimum wage jobs that they could find. Both of my parents were college educated in the STEM fields, but those degrees were not applicable. At certain points we received food stamps and medicaid. Most of my childhood was spent in Newark, NJ, where we were a minority in the community. The goals of the students and schools seemed to be just to pass high school, and most kids did not care about working for more than a passing grade. There were certainly plenty of teachers who cared about me and wanted everyone to do better, but the bar seemed low. I managed to get into a good magnet public high school in Newark called science high school where the student body seemed more optimistic and college bound, but the schools financial resources were poor. The school building was a converted factory and we went to the local YMWCA for gym class. Our books and equipment were outdated but seemed adequate for our needs. During my youth, my parents went back to school to get better and relevant degrees, but eventually went through a divorce. When I was 16, my mother, brother and I moved to a middle class neighborhood and I attended a significantly better high school for my senior year. It was a bit of a culture shock in that all of the students aimed significantly higher for their futures, and were definitely more confident. If anything I feel lucky that my parents were able to push themselves out of poverty and raise me to work hard for what I desire and take my education seriously.

It is very hard for me to define exact instances of being worse of than my peers now, and I don't want to write anything negative. After high school I went to a good school, I did well and now I certainly don't feel disadvantaged. I feel a bit envious of my peers for some of the things they had as children, like having an allowance and going to arcades, but I don't feel like I was put into a huge disadvantage.

So is it worth it for me to try and answer this question or should I say no and not worry about it?
 
AAMC usually quantifies disadvantage by either the highest level of education your parents have received (you mentioned your parents are college-educated), their income (you mentioned struggling throughout grade school), or minority status (you mentioned you are a minority, do you qualify as URM?. All of these are important as they apply to your education.

My personal feelings on the subject: if you have to question whether or not you are disadvantaged, you probably aren't. Disadvantaged students are well aware, and reminded consistently, of their disadvantages. Usually, people will cite those special circumstances that kept them from performing.

If you do decide to write the diversity essay, don't try to look at things through rose-colored glasses. Tell the truth—don't downplay your history, but by the same token, do not dramatize it. These people can smell bull**** from a mile away.
 
@intangible and @Goro , Thank you for your replies. After reading through the suggestions, I decided to find a way to fit the information elsewhere without claiming disadvantaged.
 
Top