What goes in a disadvantage statement? I'll explain why I'm asking.

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Gauss44

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2012
Messages
3,185
Reaction score
416
My questions:

Are 1, 2, and 3 below (in bold) true?

And should ANYTHING included in the disadvantage statement be left out of the personal statement?


I found a website that says this,
"If you have experienced any form of social, economic or educational disadvantage—at any time in your life—you can apply to medical school as a disadvantaged applicant. To receive this designation means that you will need to complete an additional essay on theAMCAS application. The character limit for this short essay is 1,325. Examples of each of the three forms of disadvantage are listed below:

1. Social: Being treated differently due to ethnicity, language or religion.

2. Economic: Receiving any form of government aid or growing up in a single parent household on one income that is below the poverty threshold.

3. Educational: Overcoming a learning disability or attending low performing public schools."


Source: http://blog.accepted.com/2014/04/13/how-to-write-the-statement-of-disadvantage/

While the AMCAS instructions from 2016 says this, "Disadvantaged Status: You will then be asked if you wish to be considered a disadvantaged applicant by your designated medical schools. You might consider yourself disadvantaged if you grew up in an area that was medically underserved or had insufficient accesss to State and Federal Assistance programs. Click Yes to be considered a disadvantaged applicant. You will be given an additional 1,325 characters to explain why you believe you should be considered a disadvantaged applicant."
 
I would say all are true.

I applied as a disadvantaged applicant: Single mother/one income household. Subsistence living in Alaska to supplement our food. Small town of 500, high school had 40 students (no advanced courses). Lived 100 miles away from nearest store, hospital, airport, etc.
 
There are many ways to be disadvantaged and you can have any or all of them. There are other ways as well such as being first generation to graduate from high school, losing your parents at a young age, being shipwreck and went through survival experience. It can be physical, economic, psychological, etc. It's something that is a barrier to your success in a truly definitively way.

As for if it should be left out of personal statement. That depends on if you and your wording. Generally people try not to have them overlap too much. But instead of worrying about that focus on the intention of each essay. The disadvantaged essay is to give context and color to your personal story. The personal statement addresses the question of why medicine and other related/relevant why's such as why now.
 
The AMCAS application currently has some questions before the declaration of disadvantaged-ness that will help clarify.

I'm wondering how straightforward I should be in my essay though. Should I just detail the tough stuff and let it speak for itself, or can I use the moment to put a positive spin on my offerings as an individual?
 
For the disadvantaged essay. The word count is very limited so just getting to the point may already use up the limit.
 
No comments specifically about #3 yet. Anyone heard of "overcoming a learning disability" being part of a disadvantage statement?
 
For Amcas, normally they are discussing socioeconomic status and such. On one of my applications I saw they had me labeled as disadvantaged before I even filled in the essay.

I would be very careful about discussing the learning disability in that area. I'd personally, assuming I mentioned it at all, would save it for a secondary... Perhaps greatest challenge. I would be very concerned with someone attempting to discriminate against me based on that fact. I do have an LD that I overcame but this last round (round 4) it was not mentioned when it was mentioned in the other rounds. This time I was accepted. I have no idea if that was a factor.
 
Top