What specialties are the most fulfilling

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

FunnyDocMan1234

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Aug 22, 2012
Messages
87
Reaction score
24
I think a lot of people entered medicine for the rewarding nature of the work but then i hear all these stories about specialties that make you "lose faith in humanity." I can understand it in things like ER with tons of frequent flier alcoholics who never get anything substantial and for sleep-deprived attendings in surgery or ICU for whom each new patient becomes simply a burden keeping them from going home. So, what specialties are the most fulfilling in terms of not losing your faith in humanity as well as patients being grateful for your services?

Members don't see this ad.
 
I think a lot of people entered medicine for the rewarding nature of the work but then i hear all these stories about specialties that make you "lose faith in humanity." I can understand it in things like ER with tons of frequent flier alcoholics who never get anything substantial and for sleep-deprived attendings in surgery or ICU for whom each new patient becomes simply a burden keeping them from going home. So, what specialties are the most fulfilling in terms of not losing your faith in humanity as well as patients being grateful for your services?

Oh to be this naive again !!
Short answer - NONE
Just pick what YOU like & can see yourself doing for the next 30 years & derive fulfillment from that
 
I think a lot of people entered medicine for the rewarding nature of the work but then i hear all these stories about specialties that make you "lose faith in humanity." I can understand it in things like ER with tons of frequent flier alcoholics who never get anything substantial and for sleep-deprived attendings in surgery or ICU for whom each new patient becomes simply a burden keeping them from going home. So, what specialties are the most fulfilling in terms of not losing your faith in humanity as well as patients being grateful for your services?

Every specialty has a large number of patients who are grateful. Likewise, every specialty is going to have a certain percentage of 'problem' patients. The proportion may be higher in one than the other, but the gap is not as large as you might thing.

I also am a little confused by your use of the word "fulfilling" and trying to equate it to not becoming cynical. If I had to guess, the most insulated specialty is Dermatology. Extremely rare emergencies, a lot of cosmesis on a non-urgent basis. My guess is that they and people in other specialties that have a similar patient population are the least cynical as a result of their work. At the same time, I would never consider that to be "fulfilling". Personally, I'd feel like I wasn't maximizing the amount of good that I can do in this world and would feel relatively empty doing it. As FutureInternist said, you have to pick what YOU like, not what others tell you to do.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
I agree with the other posters. What makes something "fulfilling" is completely based on the individual. Cynical doctors are in every specialty. There are some doctors in specialties that in my opinion have no reason to complain about anything, but have the most negative outlook on patients. Conversely, in specialties where I think I'd have to kill myself before dealing with the crap they do every day, there are some doctors who have a very inspiring outlook on what they do.
 
i'm a ms2 and i think from my clinical shadowing/preceptorship from before and during med school i have already lost my faith in humanity. people for the most part just come to the dr to get some pills and go home. they aren't going to really change their habits. its sad but its what this society has come to. most patients are incredibly lazy and everyone just wants a quick fix. the institution of healthcare in this country is a joke. there are 3rd world countries are healthier than america.

after i have paid back my loans i might volunteer in non-profit organizations like doctors without borders or maybe a local non-profit where my work and knowledge will be more appreciated.
 
Primary care I can see causing cynicism with the amount of obese people of whom 95% will never improve.
 
You certainly can't find your fulfillment in patients being grateful. If that's where your fulfillment lies, you'll be let down in every medical specialty out there. The numbers might vary a little, but in every specialty, you'll have a lot of patients that respect you and thank you, and you will have a lot of patients that treat you like a pill dispenser and you'll never be able to please them. Your fulfillment can't come from finding that perfect specialty with great patient care and no red tape, because they typically don't exist. It can't come from finding the specialty that is able to work outside of our deeply problematic healthcare system, or from anything else that really doesn't exist. Your fulfillment has to come from something that won't be broken by insurance companies, medical hierarchy, or ungrateful patients. I can't tell you where to find that fulfillment/meaning, but I can tell you where you won't find it. If your standards for happiness are salary, prestige, respect, or changing the world, you never really "achieve" those. You've got to be happy and fulfilled outside of work, and then with the work you choose to do every day. For me, the little things give me fulfillment. All of my jobs have been disappointments because we usually have unrealistic expectations going into a new job. But in the middle of entitled patients, insurance companies that work against you, and a broken healthcare system, you've got to find meaning, fulfillment, or "calling" in the one patient whose life you change, the one sick child you make smile and for a few seconds they forget that they're in a hospital when they should be outside playing with their friends. I know this is easier said than done, and specialties have different balances of good and bad, but you won't find one where only grateful people come down with the type of illness you work with. Find the area of medicine you're most interested in, and find fulfillment in the small things.
 
You certainly can't find your fulfillment in patients being grateful. If that's where your fulfillment lies, you'll be let down in every medical specialty out there. The numbers might vary a little, but in every specialty, you'll have a lot of patients that respect you and thank you, and you will have a lot of patients that treat you like a pill dispenser and you'll never be able to please them. Your fulfillment can't come from finding that perfect specialty with great patient care and no red tape, because they typically don't exist. It can't come from finding the specialty that is able to work outside of our deeply problematic healthcare system, or from anything else that really doesn't exist. Your fulfillment has to come from something that won't be broken by insurance companies, medical hierarchy, or ungrateful patients. I can't tell you where to find that fulfillment/meaning, but I can tell you where you won't find it. If your standards for happiness are salary, prestige, respect, or changing the world, you never really "achieve" those. You've got to be happy and fulfilled outside of work, and then with the work you choose to do every day. For me, the little things give me fulfillment. All of my jobs have been disappointments because we usually have unrealistic expectations going into a new job. But in the middle of entitled patients, insurance companies that work against you, and a broken healthcare system, you've got to find meaning, fulfillment, or "calling" in the one patient whose life you change, the one sick child you make smile and for a few seconds they forget that they're in a hospital when they should be outside playing with their friends. I know this is easier said than done, and specialties have different balances of good and bad, but you won't find one where only grateful people come down with the type of illness you work with. Find the area of medicine you're most interested in, and find fulfillment in the small things.

Yo thanks pre-med
 
i'm a ms2 and i think from my clinical shadowing/preceptorship from before and during med school i have already lost my faith in humanity. people for the most part just come to the dr to get some pills and go home. they aren't going to really change their habits. its sad but its what this society has come to. most patients are incredibly lazy and everyone just wants a quick fix. the institution of healthcare in this country is a joke. there are 3rd world countries are healthier than america.

after i have paid back my loans i might volunteer in non-profit organizations like doctors without borders or maybe a local non-profit where my work and knowledge will be more appreciated.

Im inclined to agree with you. But there is still good patients out there. For every 2 or 3 useless patients, im sure you will get one cooperative patient

Primary care by far has the biggest potential impact thus could be the most rewarding. However, with our current society it requires a physician with a LOT of patience. I personally dont have this patience so am looking to other fields
 
Members don't see this ad :)
Yo thanks pre-med

I'm a non-trad, and I've had a lot of jobs. Don't write me off that I don't know anything about finding fulfillment in menial work. I apologize if I said anything wrong, but I was trying to offer my advice because I think finding fulfillment is the same process in any career, and you don't have to be a doctor to know about that.
 
Last edited:
I'm a non-trad, and I've had a lot of jobs. Don't write me off that I don't know anything about finding fulfillment in menial work. I apologize if I said anything wrong, but I was trying to offer my advice because I think finding fulfillment is the same process in any career, and you don't have to be a doctor to know about that.

Look at the beginning of your paragraph and you'll see why you sound so funny. Actually the whole thing. You make it seem like you've been an attending for 20 years rather than some guy that hasn't even been to medical school for a day.

Also, the one giant paragraph thing just hurts my eyes.
 
.....and for sleep-deprived attendings in surgery or ICU for whom each new patient becomes simply a burden keeping them from going home.

I've not once ever heard a NICU attending say this or anything resembling this and I've been in the business a really long time. Many of us do shift type work or in-house call anyway and most of us like having new patients as that way we still have a job and can do what we believe is important for children.

YMMV as always.
 
Short answer: whatever the hell makes you happy
 
Sorry OP, apparently my post was misleading, confusing, and not spaced in proper internet feng shui 🙂 My contribution, through my experience (NOT as an attending), is that I don't think certain specialties will have mostly grateful patients and only a few bad ones. I would think, based off of my work experience, that it will be more fulfilling in the long run to try to pick something you are interested in doing for the rest of your life, and to find meaning in using it to make people happy. There's my point without using medical examples, which has held true for me in my work experience not as a doctor.
 
Sorry OP, apparently my post was misleading, confusing, and not spaced in proper internet feng shui 🙂 My contribution, through my experience (NOT as an attending), is that I don't think certain specialties will have mostly grateful patients and only a few bad ones. I would think, based off of my work experience, that it will be more fulfilling in the long run to try to pick something you are interested in doing for the rest of your life, and to find meaning in using it to make people happy. There's my point without using medical examples, which has held true for me in my work experience not as a doctor.

👍
 
Every specialty has a large number of patients who are grateful. Likewise, every specialty is going to have a certain percentage of 'problem' patients. The proportion may be higher in one than the other, but the gap is not as large as you might thing.

I also am a little confused by your use of the word "fulfilling" and trying to equate it to not becoming cynical. If I had to guess, the most insulated specialty is Dermatology. Extremely rare emergencies, a lot of cosmesis on a non-urgent basis. My guess is that they and people in other specialties that have a similar patient population are the least cynical as a result of their work. At the same time, I would never consider that to be "fulfilling". Personally, I'd feel like I wasn't maximizing the amount of good that I can do in this world and would feel relatively empty doing it. As FutureInternist said, you have to pick what YOU like, not what others tell you to do.

Oh god...we get our share of neurodermatitis/dysesthesia patients. Those are really hard to deal w/.... We also get our share of chronic atopic derm patients and delusions of parasitosis patients....
 
Oh god...we get our share of neurodermatitis/dysesthesia patients. Those are really hard to deal w/.... We also get our share of chronic atopic derm patients and delusions of parasitosis patients....

Morgellons is a real disease, sir. If you'd stop suckling on the corporate teat of modern medicine/big pharma and open your eyes you might see it, man. The fibers are there (and coincidentally identical to those from the towel the patient used this morning)!
 
Top