When not to call a psych consult

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Hurricane

Senior Member
10+ Year Member
5+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Aug 14, 2005
Messages
977
Reaction score
7
So I'm doing my IM month now, and I'm sure we'll be calling some psych consults at some point. But I never rotated on psych consults as a med student, and I want to avoid annoying my colleagues with inappropriate consults. What are some of the most annoying consults?

What about depression? If a patient is depressed, but not psychotic or suicidal, is a psych consult necessary?

Members don't see this ad.
 
So I'm doing my IM month now, and I'm sure we'll be calling some psych consults at some point. But I never rotated on psych consults as a med student, and I want to avoid annoying my colleagues with inappropriate consults. What are some of the most annoying consults?

What about depression? If a patient is depressed, but not psychotic or suicidal, is a psych consult necessary?

The most annoying consults for me are often capacity assessments.

Me: So, I'm Dr. X, and I'm from the psychiatry department.
Patient: Why did they call you? I'm not crazy.
Me: Well, it seems like they didn't tell you I was coming, like I asked them to.
Patient: No, they didn't. And I'm not crazy.
Me: Fair enough. I'm here because your regular docs wanted me to help them determine whether or not you understand the procedure that they've got planned for you.
Patient: What procedure?
Me: They must have mentioned the lumbar puncture to you. It's also called a spinal-tap. We use the procedure to help determine or rule-out the possibility of certain types of infections and other conditions.
Patient: Do I really need it?
Me: Well, my job is not really to convince you one way or the other. From reviewing your chart earlier, it does appear that it would help from a diagnostic standpoint. They mentioned nothing to you about this?
Patient: No, it sounds painful. Is it dangerous?
Me: Well, it does have some risks which should have been explained to you by your primary medical team (proceeds to explain the risk/benefit ratio).
Patient: It sounds important. I should do it probably. Ok. They'll come do it now?
😡

If you're going to call for a capacity consult, take the time to tell the patient what you want to do, why, and the risks and benefits of the procedure. If you still aren't sure, then call psychiatry.

I've taken recently to dragging the resident, intern or even attending in with me to have them explain the procedure or discuss the decision to determine if I'm needed.

About depression. This depends on the nature of your particular C/L service. Obvious signs such as (true stories) breaking the window and trying to jump out 15 stories down, trying to hang yourself from the toilet bown handle, or hoarding pills that are then found in the drawer, deserve psych consults. Expressd suicidal ideation deserves a psych consult. Some transient dysphoria when a patient is s/p fall and finds out they'll be in the hospital for 2 weeks, or a few tears because they missed their daughter's piano recital do not deserve psych consults.

Some C/L departments, depending on their orientation, do engage in bedside psychotherapy for benign cases. I hate doing this and find it quite awkward. Frankly, our psych c/L service is too busy to do 45-minute therapy sessions at the bedside. Others like it a great deal.

If someone is on Paxil, Seroquel, Lexapro, or some other psychotropic, and they are stable, express no symptoms, and express no desire to see a psychiatrist, a consult is generally not necessary.

One thing that really irks me is when (DS might disagree with me here) a consult is called because "the patient wants to see a psychiatrist." My feeling is that this is not a private wellness spa, and that patients do not dictate their treatment or get to see a psychiatrist because they have minor issues or are bored.

If a patient said to you on rounds..."I want to see a nephrologist." Would you leave the room and call one? Of course not. Why would you do it to psychiatry? You should ask them why they want to see one, ask if they're suicidal or have a psychiatric history, then make a determination whether or not psychiatry should be consulted to offer an opinion on the case.

Some of these thoughts are just my own view. Others might disagree.
 
The most improtant thing is have a question you want answered. I hate the 'well they just seem a bit odd and can you please come and fix them' calls. I had a really good reputaiton as an itnern for beign able to get psych consults when other people couldn't- made me look great. And the reason was that I knew to present the patient mrs X with history of depression ahs tried XY&Z antidepressants without effect could you please review and suggest the best antidepessant for her? Oh and by the way here's a list of her previous meds so you don't have to spend 4 hours hunting through the charts for them.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
most annoying C/L consults were (a) as Sazi mentioned above, the completely psychiatrically stable pts on whom the attending often wants a psych consult "just to have you on board" b/c the pt is on some kind of psych med or had a hx of depression in the distant past and (b) the "we're just about ready to d/c this patient and s/he looks sad..."--what, I'm going to start her on Prozac as s/he's heading down to the parking lot? The "dispo" consults, which are essentially requests for referrals which could be handled by the discharge planner &/or SW are also irritating.
 
One thing that really irks me is when (DS might disagree with me here) a consult is called because "the patient wants to see a psychiatrist." My feeling is that this is not a private wellness spa, and that patients do not dictate their treatment or get to see a psychiatrist because they have minor issues or are bored.

If a patient said to you on rounds..."I want to see a nephrologist." Would you leave the room and call one? Of course not. Why would you do it to psychiatry? You should ask them why they want to see one, ask if they're suicidal or have a psychiatric history, then make a determination whether or not psychiatry should be consulted to offer an opinion on the case.

Some of these thoughts are just my own view. Others might disagree.

No disagreement here.

An additional caveat... if you're calling a consult for depression because the pt "looks withdrawn", you'd better be damn sure you've done a thorough cognitive exam (not "A+Ox3). 9 times out of 10 the pt is delirious out of their minds. Quickest assessment = clockface = poor man's EEG. If you don't know what's going on, but feel you need CL help to figure it out... say so. That'll get you much more respect than "I need you to see him, because, he's.... ummm... he's depressed?"

My top 11 most annoying consults:

1) "Pt with h/o mental illness"... right, and that prior diagnosis of dysthymia really has a lot to do with the DKA you admitted them for.

2) "Pt asked to see a psychiatrist"... and I have a pt asking to see a dumb-ass medicine intern. Let's trade!

3) "Pt could use someone to talk to"... and here's the number for social work.

4) "? competency"... well, competency is a judicial issue, I can only assess capacity. "Right, ? capacity"... capacity for what? "Capacity to make decisions?"... About what? "About his care?"... <me repeatedly smashing phone handset on desk>

5) "90 yo woman adm with urosepsis, ? depression"... Order the Haldol IV now, I'll be there eventually.

6) "His family wanted..." - I've already hung up

7) "The nurse thought..." - I've already hung up

8) "The attending wanted the consult"... for what? "I dunno, the attending said so."

9) "STAT consult for suicide attempt"... pt did attempt suicide, is now a C4 quad, intubated and sedated - I'm sprinting to make sure he doesn't harm himself further with that sluggish corneal reflex.

10) "45 yo woman, 1 day post-op appy, requiring inc. opiates for pain, ? addiction/conversion." 😕

11) "tearfulness/depression when we told her we had to amputate her leg." Tearfulness does NOT equal depression.

And always, always, always tell the pt we're coming to see them - and explain to them why.
 
One thing that makes me irate is when my beeper goes off and it's a nurse or unit clerk telling me that a family member is on the floor and wants to see me...that they have questions about their family member's care, and the intern/resident/attending referred them to me.

It's one of the few times I'm instantly rude, call (usually the) intern myself, and give them hell for trying to dump family member questions and demands onto me that have little or nothing to do with psychiatric care.
 
Consults for acutely intoxicated patients, we're talking patients with BALs of 0.200 or more, like I'm going to rush over and start working the 12 steps with him right now when he can barely tell me his name.
 
Consults for acutely intoxicated patients, we're talking patients with BALs of 0.200 or more, like I'm going to rush over and start working the 12 steps with him right now when he can barely tell me his name.

Indeed, the intubated/GCS=3 consult is rarely appreciated. Neither is the "I've got a 84 yo woman with urosepsis in the ICU who's pulling out her lines--you've got to come in and put her on a hold!" No, July intern 😉 , I don't... you need to write some freakin' restraint orders! Anyone over 70 should get a posey as part of their admit kit, just in case.

I've been stunned at the EtOH tolerance of some of my ED detox consults--clear, unslurred conversations with women in their 30's with BALs of >350. But then there are those you have to greet with a sternal rub...
 
I am on "consulting staff" of 2 local hospitals. I got a call recently to come in to help an attending give some hard news. I showed up, attending did the disappearing act, and I was supposed to tell a pt she had "nothing" wrong with her. Well I am qualified to do that...lol, but what a crockof ****. This pt had 10 seizures over the past 72hrs unknown etiology. Neuro said they were pseudo-seizures in the chart. Point is nobody took the time to tell any of this to the pt; that was my job. I did it, they got mad, and I ordered a prolactin level at next post-sz...............guess what?😕
 
I am on "consulting staff" of 2 local hospitals. I got a call recently to come in to help an attending give some hard news. I showed up, attending did the disappearing act, and I was supposed to tell a pt she had "nothing" wrong with her. Well I am qualified to do that...lol, but what a crockof ****. This pt had 10 seizures over the past 72hrs unknown etiology. Neuro said they were pseudo-seizures in the chart. Point is nobody took the time to tell any of this to the pt; that was my job. I did it, they got mad, and I ordered a prolactin level at next post-sz...............guess what?😕

Not to nitpick, but if the neurologists looked at the eeg, the clinical presentation isn't representative, and if the prolactin wasn't drawn properly and at the correct time (you drew it yourself?), it means nothing. I'm sure they did a 24 hr EEG?

Granted, they should not call a psychologist to tell the patient a neurologist's diagnosis. Which brings up another good point...don't call a c/L psych consult to tell a patient bad news. It's inappropriate. Part of your job as a medicine doc is to give bad news and learn to do it well.
 
They never did the prolactin until after I saw the pt and she had another "seizure"; it was totally negative. The point is I usally get called for help, not to just tell someone something they did not want to hear like "you have pseudo seizures".
 
What I am trying to imply here is I think the attending, the neuro consultant, everyone knew she did not have a real sz disorder. However this pt's mother insisted they were real, so she was on meds etc.., and nobody had told her they may a conversion response to recent stress. I think they know me well enogh to know I would want to see a prolactin after the next sz, and then I could conclude they were not seizures when I saw no elevation. Being as I "found" it, they would ask me to gently tell the pt and fam. BTW no 24hr EEG was done. This was is a small rural general med-surg unit.
 
I thought you were implying that you found an elevated prolactin, which must be interpreted in the context of her other medical conditions and med regimen, and found some hidden seizure disorder.

Pseudoseizures are difficult to diagnose. As we know, eeg is not 100% sensitive. Just FYI, prolactin is even much less so than eeg. You cannot rule out seizures when receiving a negative prolactin level...or ck for that matter.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
Nope sorry for the confusion, I am not really one of those...... I just think they all thought Dr. Psisci can handle the people end.
 
(b) the "we're just about ready to d/c this patient and s/he looks sad..."--what, I'm going to start her on Prozac as s/he's heading down to the parking lot? The "dispo" consults, which are essentially requests for referrals which could be handled by the discharge planner &/or SW are also irritating.

That's why here in NYC I LOVE 1-800-LIFENET, the ultimate outpatient mental health referral source. I have saved myself at least 2 dozen ER consults through that single referral source alone!

Gotta agree wholeheartedly with Dr. S on the top 11 worst reasons to call a psych consult.

I am a big fan of the final recommendation "reconsult psychiatry PRN any additional problems" which in my experience conveys the message "bogus consult, psychiatrically stable, & I'm not going to do daily psychotherapy to appease your narcissistic, entitled, demanding patient."
 
I thought you were implying that you found an elevated prolactin, which must be interpreted in the context of her other medical conditions and med regimen, and found some hidden seizure disorder.

Pseudoseizures are difficult to diagnose. As we know, eeg is not 100% sensitive. Just FYI, prolactin is even much less so than eeg. You cannot rule out seizures when receiving a negative prolactin level...or ck for that matter.

...and let's remember that the population most likely to have pseudoseizures are the folks with real seizures.
 
Thanks for all of the responses - very helpful!

Last night was my first IM call night, and right off the bat I got a psych patient. Schizoaffective lady who's delirious right now, probably due to the 3 grams of lamictal she OD'd on. So I guess we'll call psych after we fix her delirium...
 
In a case like that you might want to get psychiatry involved sooner rather than later. If she's truly schizoaffective, she's likely on other meds for the psychosis, and you wouldn't want a psychotic decompensation on top of the delirium. Besides, psychiatry can help with the management of the delirious symptoms, particulary in a case like this - they're better suited to recognize symptoms of delirium vs. psychosis and can help treat accordingly.
 
In a case like that you might want to get psychiatry involved sooner rather than later. If she's truly schizoaffective, she's likely on other meds for the psychosis, and you wouldn't want a psychotic decompensation on top of the delirium. Besides, psychiatry can help with the management of the delirious symptoms, particulary in a case like this - they're better suited to recognize symptoms of delirium vs. psychosis and can help treat accordingly.

Thanks for the advice. I was a little uncertain of whether to consult psych for delirium, as it's a medical issue, right? But I see the point - delirium in a patient with a known psychotic disorder is more complicated than delirium in a little old lady with a UTI.

She actually had already decompensated, as she'd been off all of her meds (both psych and diabetes meds) for 2 weeks, which probably led to her OD'ing in the first place. Then I ran into the consult team today, and they said they'd appreciate the consult tomorrow rather than today, because they were swamped and they knew I knew to write for her to have prn haldol in the meantime. Speaking of which, when I reviewed her chart this AM, I noticed she hadn't gotten any haldol prn, yet the nurse was like "she's reeaaallly paranoid whenever she wakes up..." Y'think? Grr. 🙄
 
There seems to be some variation, which is institution-specific, in which types of conditions are referred to psych vs. other disciplines.

For example, some hospitals call neuro for overdoses with mental status changes, other places psychiatry. Some call neuro for delirium, others call psychiatry. Some call detox or ICU for DTs, others get psychiatry much more involved. Same goes for delirium - some neuro, some psych.
 
There seems to be some variation, which is institution-specific, in which types of conditions are referred to psych vs. other disciplines.

I think the variation often boils down to "whichever service is staffed by residents". God forbid an attending ever had to roll out of bed... 🙄
 
And then there are the places, like where I operate where there is not 1 psychiatist on staff....... My new job puts me in a position to be working directly with a psychiatrist, and I look very forward to it..
 
Thanks for the advice. I was a little uncertain of whether to consult psych for delirium, as it's a medical issue, right? But I see the point - delirium in a patient with a known psychotic disorder is more complicated than delirium in a little old lady with a UTI.

She actually had already decompensated, as she'd been off all of her meds (both psych and diabetes meds) for 2 weeks, which probably led to her OD'ing in the first place. Then I ran into the consult team today, and they said they'd appreciate the consult tomorrow rather than today, because they were swamped and they knew I knew to write for her to have prn haldol in the meantime. Speaking of which, when I reviewed her chart this AM, I noticed she hadn't gotten any haldol prn, yet the nurse was like "she's reeaaallly paranoid whenever she wakes up..." Y'think? Grr. 🙄

Delirium is always a good reason for a psychiatry consult... it's our bread and butter. Your wrote for that Haldol to be given IV, right?
 
Delirium is always a good reason for a psychiatry consult... it's our bread and butter. Your wrote for that Haldol to be given IV, right?

Possibly not, depending on where she is. I know at my hospital, only certain floors are authorized to use the IV formulation due to FDA approval concerns.

What are your thoughts on IM/PO haloperidol for delirium?
 
oops double post
 
Possibly not, depending on where she is. I know at my hospital, only certain floors are authorized to use the IV formulation due to FDA approval concerns.

What are your thoughts on IM/PO haloperidol for delirium?

I wrote for it IV/IM prn, and then found out later that they can't give it IV on the floor, so I'm glad I did the /IM thing. By that time her delirium had cleared up, so I changed it to PO/IM for her psychosis (scheduled, since the nurses only ever gave the prn doses when I came down there and asked them to). Then consults saw her this afternoon and decided she could go home, and I discharged her. Yay 🙂

I got another overdose patient on short call today (tylenol this time). I must attract them somehow...
 
Possibly not, depending on where she is. I know at my hospital, only certain floors are authorized to use the IV formulation due to FDA approval concerns.

What are your thoughts on IM/PO haloperidol for delirium?

Works fine, but you run a significantly greater risk of EPS not seen with IV administration, then you have to give an anticholinergic which exacerbates the delirium, and you're back to square one. I'm not sure I could work at a hospital where they got all antsy about IV Haldol... It'd drive me way too crazy.
 
Top