Where did we go wrong?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Splenda88

Full Member
5+ Year Member
Joined
Jan 22, 2019
Messages
7,311
Reaction score
7,535



Where is the outrage about NP/PA practicing medicine with less qualifications?

Members don't see this ad.
 



Where is the outrage about NP/PA practicing medicine with less qualifications?
Once the bodies start dropping hopefully some lawyers start sounding the alarm because as physicians we get nothing but grief if we claim that maybe NPs and PAs can't do what we do
 



Where is the outrage about NP/PA practicing medicine with less qualifications?
If you have a PA/NP, you know that you're not getting a physician (or at least you should).

If you're seeing someone with an MD, the assumption is that they are fully trained/licensed.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
If you have a PA/NP, you know that you're not getting a physician (or at least you should).

If you're seeing someone with an MD, the assumption is that they are fully trained/licensed.
'Fully trained' physicians in 34 states is defined as 1-year post grad training as a MD... aka GP (probably all 50 states for DO). IM/FM/Peds are specialists.
 
If you have a PA/NP, you know that you're not getting a physician (or at least you should).

If you're seeing someone with an MD, the assumption is that they are fully trained/licensed.
The thing is, they have to be licensed in a United States jurisdiction. No US jurisdiction requires less than a year of training (except the USVI iirc, I think it's 6 months there). Florida even allows for full licenses after one year of training for US MDs/DOs, and few states allow practice for IMGs after only one year. My bet is most of these people could get a license anyway, I'm kind of curious as to why they didn't. Most likely because the temp license allows medicaid billing, which might not be doable as a GP, but hard to say.

Also the lawyer claiming they don't understaffed the reason some of these licenses are granted its ridiculous, they're HPSA sites. It's really straightforward
 
Unfortunately unlicensed practice exist sporadically in every profession in every state and there are mechanisms to report such illegal activity..,

This is about temporary licenses enacted in the state of FL after the great Maria hurricane and other unfortunate events that swept the island and rendered it incapacitated for years and pushed large swath of its population and health professionals to migrate and settle in Florida and other places..!

There was similar exemption in licensure for so many emergency situations in numerous states as they relaxed inter jurisdiction requirements this past year during the Covid19 pandemic.., special skills licenses and teaching and so forth..!

This to me is about Malpractice..!! And malpractice is what it is.

When a physician violates the standards of care regardless of their required GME length of training for licensure wether it’s one year or 10 years.., they should be judged based on performance of equal peers in similar situation.

It should not be the cause of trashing a profession and some of its underperforming members for sleazy legal reporting to win a public support for larger verdicts.., nor should allow politicians and others to enable midlevels to step outside their scope of practice to fill a very critical voids in societal healthcare needs.
 
'Fully trained' physicians in 34 states is defined as 1-year post grad training as a MD... aka GP (probably all 50 states for DO). IM/FM/Peds are specialists.
Yes and Florida allows that for US MD/DO grads only. The article suggests that these doctors are not US trained and so wouldn't be eligible for the standard GP pathway (since otherwise this wouldn't be article worthy and a completely separate path).
 
The thing is, they have to be licensed in a United States jurisdiction. No US jurisdiction requires less than a year of training (except the USVI iirc, I think it's 6 months there). Florida even allows for full licenses after one year of training for US MDs/DOs, and few states allow practice for IMGs after only one year. My bet is most of these people could get a license anyway, I'm kind of curious as to why they didn't. Most likely because the temp license allows medicaid billing, which might not be doable as a GP, but hard to say.

Also the lawyer claiming they don't understaffed the reason some of these licenses are granted its ridiculous, they're HPSA sites. It's really straightforward
Very few to my understanding will allow it for FMGs
 
Very few to my understanding will allow it for FMGs
Minnesota and Puerto Rico require 1 year for IMGs. The USVI it's 6 months of training after their SPEx exam. So unless there's like, 1,000 doctors that only completed intern year and got licensed in Minnesota or Puerto Rico, I can't see how this many special exceptions became necessary
 
Minnesota and Puerto Rico require 1 year for IMGs. The USVI it's 6 months of training after their SPEx exam. So unless there's like, 1,000 doctors that only completed intern year and got licensed in Minnesota or Puerto Rico, I can't see how this many special exceptions became necessary
Do the differentiate between IMG and FMG?
 
Yeah that does raise questions about this whole thing. Almost like that's why the article got written.
Eh, I just can't imagine there's that many FMGs or IMGs running around with one year but less than two years (the amount required of IMGs in Florida) of US training that specifically sought out licenses in Puerto Rico and Minnesota to use a little known loophole to work in underserved areas in Florida. I'm betting there is much more to the story that is missing and likely misunderstood by the lawyer themselves
 
Members don't see this ad :)
Eh, I just can't imagine there's that many FMGs or IMGs running around with one year but less than two years (the amount required of IMGs in Florida) of US training that specifically sought out licenses in Puerto Rico and Minnesota to use a little known loophole to work in underserved areas in Florida. I'm betting there is much more to the story that is missing and likely misunderstood by the lawyer themselves
Perhaps, but it does beg the question of why stick with this license and not get a new one after 10 years
 
Oh absolutely. I'm quite curious what the deal is
The deal is that these people can not get a regular license... because the 1 yr internship they completed in PR is a non ACGME accredited internship (aka internado)... PR has a lot of these non ACGME accredited internship because most FM doc left the island for greener pasture in the mainland. I believe, for one reason or another, they did not want to go the NP/PA route when the government made that decision. NP/PA is not a thing there except for CRNA.

Most outpatient primary PCP offices in PR are run by these GP... Many ED fast tract are run by them as well. Based on a few I talked to, they make 80k-120k/yr. The majority of the island still practice traditional medicine where PCP (IM/FM not GP) admit and take care of their own patients in the hospital.

The system in FL might still have some loophole cause I know 1 of these docs who was able to get an unrestricted license...
 
The deal is that these people can not get a regular license... because the 1 yr internship they completed in PR is a non ACGME accredited internship (aka internado)... PR has a lot of these non ACGME accredited internship because most FM doc left the island for greener pasture in the mainland. I believe, for one reason or another, they did not want to go the NP/PA route when the government made that decision. NP/PA is not a thing there except for CRNA.

Most outpatient primary PCP offices in PR are run by these GP... Many ED fast tract are run by them as well. Based on a few I talked to, they make 80k-120k/yr. The majority of the island still practice traditional medicine where PCP (IM/FM not GP) admit and take care of their own patients in the hospital.

The system in FL might still have some loophole cause I know 1 of these docs who was able to get an unrestricted license...
That makes sense. Didn't know PR would license people without ACGME training.
 
That makes sense. Didn't know PR would license people without ACGME training.
They are not ACGME accredited but the internship is standardized. I did my one-month EM rotation there when I was a 4th year med student, I worked with these people and think they are good. I remember working with one who would put central lines without using ultrasound. Lol
 
Probably misunderstanding, but I don’t know if I’d use this as an example of someone being good. Do they not have ultrasound there?
They do... PR is not Sierra Leone. It's not about that only. The internado curriculum is standardized (3 months IM, 2 months FM, 2 months peds, 1 month ED, 1 month surgery... etc...) and they were supervised by attending.

Things might change now cause I was there in early 2018...
 
Last edited:
They do... PR is not Sierra Leone. It's not about that only. The internado curriculum is standardized.

I think it’s pretty indefensible to put in a central line without ultrasound if you have it available.

But this isn’t really the topic of the thread. Sorry. Just was caught off guard by that.
 
I think it’s pretty indefensible to put in a central line without ultrasound if you have it available.

But this isn’t really the topic of the thread. Sorry. Just was caught off guard by that.
I did 3-4 with that individual and he never missed one (one needle poke). I think it's because the ED was an extremely busy ED and other residents might need to use the 1 US machine.
 
I did 3-4 with that individual and he never missed one (one needle poke). I think it's because the ED was an extremely busy ED and other residents might need to use the 1 US machine.

Yeah...that extremely small sample size doesn’t mean anything. If you do a central line without u/s and have a complication and it was available...
 
Yeah...that extremely small sample size doesn’t mean anything. If you do a central line without u/s and have a complication and it was available...
True but to have that confidence, he must have done 20+ before.

It's just a different system... I have seen IM PGY1 intubate patients on a regular basis when I was there.
 
Last edited:
Oh, you again, with the same tired nonsense. Now it’s NP/PA fault Florida allows undertrained physicians to practice medicine?
Not as undertrained as NP/PA... This so called journalist did not even do his/her homework.
 
Not as undertrained as NP/PA... This so called journalist did not even do his/her homework.

Why even bring up NP/PA? Oh yeah, it’s that mountain sized chip on your shoulder. It snowed today in my state, should we blame NP/PA’s?
 
Why even bring up NP/PA? Oh yeah, it’s that mountain sized chip on your shoulder. It snowed today in my state, should we blame NP/PA’s?
These are docs that have license in other jurisdiction (aka Puerto Rico). If they are good enough to work for the feds. They are good enough to practice medicine everywhere.
 
These are docs that have license in other jurisdiction (aka Puerto Rico). If they are good enough to work for the feds. They are good enough to practice medicine everywhere.

Has nothing to do with NP/PA’s. This was a physician’s mistake, which happens, nothing more. I stubbed my toe this morning, I blame PA’s for that, makes about as much sense as your post.
 
Has nothing to do with NP/PA’s. This was a physician’s mistake, which happens, nothing more. I stubbed my toe this morning, I blame PA’s for that, makes about as much sense as your post.
And if you'll notice, outside the first 3 posts no one else in the thread really said much about midlevels. You're the one that brought it back up.

Please stop.
 
Unfortunately unlicensed practice exist sporadically in every profession in every state and there are mechanisms to report such illegal activity..,

This is about temporary licenses enacted in the state of FL after the great Maria hurricane and other unfortunate events that swept the island and rendered i
t incapacitated for years and pushed large swath of its population and health professionals to migrate and settle in Florida and other places..!

There was similar exemption in licensure for so many emergency situations in numerous states as they relaxed inter jurisdiction requirements this past year during the Covid19 pandemic.., special skills licenses and teaching and so forth..!

This to me is about Malpractice..!! And malpractice is what it is.

When a physician violates the standards of care regardless of their required GME length of training for licensure wether it’s one year or 10 years.., they should be judged based on performance of equal peers in similar situation.

It should not be the cause of trashing a profession and some of its underperforming members for sleazy legal reporting to win a public support for larger verdicts.., nor should allow politicians and others to enable midlevels to step outside their scope of practice to fill a very critical voids in societal healthcare needs.
The ACN (Area of Critical Need) license has been there for years in FL (dated before hurricane Maria)...
 
And if you'll notice, outside the first 3 posts no one else in the thread really said much about midlevels. You're the one that brought it back up.

Please stop.

I’ll drop it but it was the only comment included in the very first post by the OP and therefore Germaine to the discussion and completely fair game.
 
I’ll drop it but it was the only comment included in the very first post by the OP and therefore Germaine to the discussion and completely fair game.

Right, but I don't think we need yet another thread bashing NPs and PAs.
 
Top