which NGS testing for solid malignancy do you all use?

Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

boxin

Full Member
10+ Year Member
There's a few players in the market - Tempus, CARIS, Guardant, Natera.

Which do you all use for NGS testing, ctDNA for patients in your practice?
 
Previously were using Tempus for NGS and Natera for CT DNA- now actually shifting to quest for both. Any one that is fully integrated with EPIC is a bonus.
 
with integration into the EMR, I am the one that will order the test on the patient with the appropriate IHC needed for that particular tumor type along with if I need CT DNA testing. The results come back to my inbasket directly hence I am not reliant on the supporting staff to order or follow up on this testing. this has increased the efficiency quite a bit in our department also we are able to start patients on treatments much faster
 
None of them have been integrated with our Epic instance yet so that's not a particular draw for me. I imagine it will be soon though.

We have an in-house tissue NGS that gets resulted quickly because it's reflexed by the pathologist. So if the path is internal, I use that one. If it's from another hospital system or clinic, it really depends.

I used to be a FoundationOne guy but rarely use them anymore.

For comprehensive NGS (and appropriate IHC testing), I've started using Guardant for most of them. Especially since I can do liquid and ctDNA and get those back in a week or less. They also do pharmacogenomic testing without me needing to ask for it (DPYD and UGT1A1).

If all I need is ctDNA, I still use Natera, primarily because their data is more robust than anyone else's. They also have tissue NGS but I don't care for their reporting system.

And if all I need is germline, I still use Invitae for the most part.

TBH, I consider them all largely interchangeable and really don't care. Fastest is best and lately Guardant has been pretty fast for me.