Which Program Do I choose

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

CAClimber

PBPM
10+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Jul 6, 2006
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Does anyone know anything about the relative rankings of the following PBPM programs:

American University
Georgetown University
NYU
USC
Tufts

Any infomation would be greatly appreciated. Thanks.
 
hi
from my understanding u pick the ones that are most linked (ie affliated) with the med schools that you are interested in. good luck.
 
CAClimber said:
Does anyone know anything about the relative rankings of the following PBPM programs:

American University
Georgetown University
NYU
USC
Tufts

Any infomation would be greatly appreciated. Thanks.

I too am trying very hard to figure out where to go. I have been accepted to USC and Columbia's programs and I have been having a lot of difficulty trying to figure out how to compare programs when there are no official rankings to speak of. I have also applied to NYU, so I can tell you what I know of NYU and USC from off your list.

I personally would not advise the NYU program, but I admit I don't know a whole lot about it. I attended NYU for my undergrad, and was entirely unaware of the program's existence. In my mind, this is not an insignificant fact, as it is the reputation of the program itself that counts more than the reputation of the university as a whole. I am sure that the program is fine, but I was not impressed enough by my experience there thus far to return. (I applied as a backup).

USC on the other hand has greatly impressed me. I have found the individuals running the program to be extremely helpful, which has been key as I am applying from across the country. I find the program there to be very well structured and well put together. The group of postbacs is small, which appeals to me, because it is a relatively tight community that offers a lot of support for students. It's expensive, but most programs are (if they are in a private university).

I hope this helps. Personally, I am leaning toward attending USC. Despite the fact that Columbia may have a little more prestige attached to the name, I feel that the attitude at USC is much more appealing.. they really care about their students.
 
I realize you are considering post-bacc programs and I wish you all the luck. I had a question about something you said and I was hoping you could help me.

You wrote:
"it is the reputation of the program itself that counts more than the reputation of the university as a whole."

I am wondering where you learned of this?

I did mediocre as an undergrad at an Ivy League university. I am looking into NYU or CUNY-Hunter Post-baccs. (Both are quite reputable and location is the key factor for various reasons.) But many people are really discouraging these options because they tell me neither NYU nor CUNY-Hunter has the reputation that an Ivy League school has although Hunter and NYU post-baccs have great reputations.

Does the reputation of the program really outweigh the reputation of the school? With all the hearsay out there nowadays, it's hard to decipher if this is a societal reaction or if one day medical school admissions will react the same way. Thanks for your help...
 
The feelings I have on this are an amalgamation of reading a lot of others peoples' opinions on the web and from taking a look at how successful people are at getting into medical school coming out of various postbac programs. My main feeling is that of course it cannot hurt to go to an Ivy League program, and be able to put the name of the school on your resume and applications. However, many of the programs at those schools are also good in their own right, which is what makes them desirable.

Its so hard to compare programs because each has different things to offer. You can compare them in terms of price, the focus of their student population, location, curriculum etc. but the reality is that med schools are looking to see students achieve the best grades they can in the most difficult classes they can manage. Somewhere, there has to be a balance. Hunter definitely is a plus on the cost factor, but you'd have a hard time arguing that the classes there will be as difficult as at one of the Ivy programs.

That said, I've read of many people who are very pleased with the experience they had at Hunter and who are thrilled not to have payed top dollar. And they are getting into schools. Again, it all depends on your goals and where you are coming from.

I hope this helps. And again, it's just my opinion.
 
Thank you all for your comments. I have decided to go with the rep of the school as a whole as well as the location. I liked the head of the program at USC, but being from CA I know how bad the neighborhood is where it is located. I was really annoyed with NYU because they kept losing parts of my application, and I ended up having to send both my transcripts and LOR's twice. Tufts and American, I really thought were well organized, but the undergrad rank was still not as good as G-town. I decided on Georgetown also because they have a limited link to there medical school. It you get recommended by the committee and 27 or more on your MCAT's you are guaranteed an interview. DC here I come...

Best of luck to all of you in you future endeavors
 
Top