who sees TBI?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

usr

New Member
10+ Year Member
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2005
Messages
89
Reaction score
0
hello

a neurologist told me that it's neurologists that must see traumatic brain injuries and not neurosurgeons

is this true?

thanks

Members don't see this ad.
 
My understanding (MS2) is that its a mix. Neurosugeons see the ones that need neurosurgery (usually to evacuate a subdural hematoma). You can do neuro-critical care out of either neurosurgery or neurology (maybe anesthesia?), but there are many more neurointensivists through the neurology route, though many hospitals don't have a full time neurointensivist, so the neurosurgeon or neurologist would manage the patient in the ICU.
 
TBI encompasses a wide spectrum, from the very mild to the fatal injuries. So your question does not have a blanket answer.

Most witnessed/documented TBIs get seen in the ER first, at a Level 1 or 2 center, during the acute phase. After initial evaluation in the ER, and based on findings of physical exam, imaging, and associated injuries, as well as specialty service available, the neurosurgical (or general surgery or orthopedics if no neurosurgery on site) team is consulted, and further management planned. The management phase of moderate to severe TBI involves multiple specialties from neurosurgery, other surgical specialties in case of other injuries, to physiotherapists, rehabilitation teams, social workers, neuropsychologists, etc.

Mild TBIs, if they get seen in a timely fashion, get discharged with no clear cut guidelines for further follow-up-it is very location/center dependent. Mild TBI has now proved to be not so mild after all as it has long term damaging neuro-cognitive sequelae. That's why it is the new silent epidemic raging the country, rather the world, but that's a whole 'nother story.

80% of TBIs are mild. When these patients start developing neuro-cognitive deficits a year or so down the line after their "mild" TBI, the association is not made, as most of the time people don't even get seen by any medical personnel. Hence the initial referral by a family physician might be to a neurologist to evaluate the patients for any neuro-degenerative diseases.

So, to come back to your question, AFAIK, there is no "must see", and everything depends on patient presentation. As always, I am open to read/learn what others have experienced.
 
Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation get fairly extensive training in management of TBI, but usually not so much in the acute stages.
 
Top