Why did you choose Family Medicine?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Chyea

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Nov 19, 2008
Messages
38
Reaction score
0
I will be starting school in the fall and am interested in family med. I know this might/probably change but I am interested in hearing what led everyone to choosing to pursue family medicine. What factors were considered, etc.?
I used the search and really couldn't find anything that is recent.

Thank you all in advance

Members don't see this ad.
 
I am thinking about Family Medicine too, but the debt load is one of the main reasons that i am thinking of a different specialty.

Has anyone gone into FM with ~300k+ in debt? What programs did you use for loan repayment...etc...

Thanks
 
I will be starting school in the fall and am interested in family med. I know this might/probably change but I am interested in hearing what led everyone to choosing to pursue family medicine. What factors were considered, etc.?
I used the search and really couldn't find anything that is recent.

Thank you all in advance

For me:
- I like continuity of care. I know a lot of people pay lip service to it, but I genuinely like taking care of the same people over a span of time.

- I like outpatient work. I like having fairly regular hours. I feel like patients have more dignity, too, when they're sitting in an office, fully clothed, as opposed to a hospital.

- The variety of problems is crucial for me. I don't have the attention span to just do ONE organ system or ONE type of problem. I get bored when you see the same problems over and over and over again (which, in most specialties, you do).

- The lifestyle isn't bad either. Few weekends, mostly home call.

I am thinking about Family Medicine too, but the debt load is one of the main reasons that i am thinking of a different specialty.

Has anyone gone into FM with ~300k+ in debt? What programs did you use for loan repayment...etc...

Thanks

There are a few things:

- As long as you are reasonably financially responsible as a resident and a young attending, you will be able to pay off your debt without too much hardship.

- Most jobs in private practice will either offer you a signing bonus or will offer to assist with loan repayment for your first few years in the practice.

- I did the NHSC as a med student, so they paid for tuition, rent, books, etc. If you're not sure that you want to go into primary care, it may not be a good option for you. However, the loan repayment program, which you apply for in your last year of residency, may be a very good option. They pay $60,000 towards your loans for your first two years as an attending, and then continue to help pay for each year you are in the program.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
#1 Continuity
#2 in one day I get to do critical care, peds, and be in the OR delivering a baby...all in two different languages!
#3 Never have to live in the city again in my life
 
I felt very comfortable in the clinic addressing the needs of the whole patient -- whatever they wanted to discuss that day. And I was impressed by the acuity of care in an FM clinic. People don't come to the doctor just to chat or have fun. Most people are reluctant to go to the doctor. When they come, they usually have -- or think they have -- something seriously wrong with them.

Also, when I was a 3rd year medical student rotating through all of the specialties, I couldn't stand how specialist so and so would be seeing sick patient xyz and would only address their concerns if it related specifically to their specialty. "Oh, you've developed a wicked rash? Why don't you go see your PCP?" "Having chest pain? Why don't you go to the ER." "But doctor, why can't YOU help me with my chest pain?" I didn't like that at all.
 
Can you talk moer about the NHSC thing as it applied to you?

Are you just pledging to serve in an underserved community, or are you pledging a specialty?
 
The NHSC scholars program is a requirement that you go into primary care in an underserved urban or rural area. You have to practice in one of those areas for 8yrs if you take 4yrs of money, OR you have to pay it back at 3x the amount you were granted. It is not for everyone, and specifically, you HAVE to be flexible in where you're willing and able to work, as they can place you where they need you most.
 
Can you talk moer about the NHSC thing as it applied to you?

Are you just pledging to serve in an underserved community, or are you pledging a specialty?

You pledge to do two things: a primary care specialty (which the NHSC defines as Family Med, Peds, Internal Med, Psychiatry, OB/gyn, or Med/Peds), and also to serve in an underserved community. It can be urban or rural.

I knew, going into medical school, that continuity of care and working with the underserved were both very important to me. The scholarship was a natural fit.

The NHSC scholars program is a requirement that you go into primary care in an underserved urban or rural area. You have to practice in one of those areas for 8yrs if you take 4yrs of money, OR you have to pay it back at 3x the amount you were granted. It is not for everyone, and specifically, you HAVE to be flexible in where you're willing and able to work, as they can place you where they need you most.

It is actually 4 years for 4 years of money. 1 year of service for 1 year of scholarship, with a minimum of 2 years of service.
 
I fell into FM because I didn't match into surgery and started with a traditional rotation internship. I liked the diversity of FP so much that I gave up on the surgery gig and continued on with family. I still get to do plenty of procedures and suturing. I can do clinic/urgent care/ hospitalist/rural ER - any or all if I choose depending on the location. I dont' have to do OB or prenatal care.

The pay is fine, I have student loans that I have no problem making the payments on. There are tons of FP jobs out there because of such a shortage in the country.
 
Good to hear that you are considering family medicine. I completed a family medicine residency in 2002. My reasons for choosing family medicine:

1. The biggest reason is that no other specialty gives you such an opportunity to become an important part of your patients' lives over an extended period of time and in many cases to develop authentic and close relationships with them. No other specialty enables that kind of intimacy. Particularly if you choose to deliver babies, you have a chance to take care of a mother throughout her pregnancies, deliver the babies, and then continue to care for the whole family as the kids grow up. It's really a fantastic opportunity to make a difference in people's lives. One fellow family medicine resident had such a strong relationship with a family in her panel that they named their daughter after her.

2. No other specialty gives you as much freedom to choose how you want to practice. As a family physician, you can choose to practice as a hospitalist, deliver babies, do rural full-spectrum medicine, urgent care, etc. And you have the freedom to change how you practice over time. For instance, if you decide you want to spend more time with your own family, you can alter your style of practice to reflect that. Few other specialties offer that kind of freedom.

3. I'm a strong proponent of full spectrum family medicine as a form of primary care that should serve as the foundation for our our currently bloated and overspecialized health care system. I believe that a system based around generalists who are trained to perform a wide variety of evidence-based comprehensive care, including procedures, is in the best interests of patients. As a nation over 15 trillion dollars in debt with our health care system bigger than just about every other economy in the world, we will be forced to head away from our current specialty-focused model and towards one centered around primary care. Family physicians will continue to be at the heart of this transformation.

4. I really enjoy the day-to-day lifestyle of full spectrum family medicne. I like doing inpatient care, procedures, and delivering babies. Clinic is usually okay but I'm not interested in spending all my time in the clinic. Some students have the misconception that family physicians spend all their time in the clinic. Some do, but many more are like me and enjoy doing a lot of other things in addition to spending time in the clinic.

5. I've spent the last nine years as a physican in the military where family physicians play a big role not only in taking care of troops but also commanding clinics and hospitals and doing all kinds of other things. I started out as a medic years ago and am most interested in operational medicine (serving alongside combat troops and accompanying them on exercises and into battle if necessary). As a family physician, I've been able to spend a lot of time in an operational position. Of course, the military also helps out in paying back loans and gives physicians quite a few generous bonuses. They also send you to a lot of schools, both clinical and non-clinical. I'm currently a student for a year at Intermediate Level Education, where the army trains its mid-level officers in operations, strategy and tactics.

6. I also have a passion for working with underserved populations and global health, both of which are very compatible with family medicine.

7. Lastly, as a medical student in a typical medical center dominated by specialists and sub-specialists, you will be subject to a steady undertone of sometimes subtle, other times blatant, bias against family medicne and primary care along with the idea that only a fool would choose not to specialize and that primary care is for idealists and lower tier students. Do your best to ignore it. Once you get out into the community, the family physician has as much respect as any other physican, and a good one is loved by his patients, particularly the hard-working, salt of the earth folks who are the backbone of our country.

LTC Mike Tarpey
ILE Class 12-01
 
Good to hear that you are considering family medicine. I completed a family medicine residency in 2002. My reasons for choosing family medicine:

1. The biggest reason is that no other specialty gives you such an opportunity to become an important part of your patients' lives over an extended period of time and in many cases to develop authentic and close relationships with them. No other specialty enables that kind of intimacy. Particularly if you choose to deliver babies, you have a chance to take care of a mother throughout her pregnancies, deliver the babies, and then continue to care for the whole family as the kids grow up. It's really a fantastic opportunity to make a difference in people's lives. One fellow family medicine resident had such a strong relationship with a family in her panel that they named their daughter after her.

2. No other specialty gives you as much freedom to choose how you want to practice. As a family physician, you can choose to practice as a hospitalist, deliver babies, do rural full-spectrum medicine, urgent care, etc. And you have the freedom to change how you practice over time. For instance, if you decide you want to spend more time with your own family, you can alter your style of practice to reflect that. Few other specialties offer that kind of freedom.

3. I'm a strong proponent of full spectrum family medicine as a form of primary care that should serve as the foundation for our our currently bloated and overspecialized health care system. I believe that a system based around generalists who are trained to perform a wide variety of evidence-based comprehensive care, including procedures, is in the best interests of patients. As a nation over 15 trillion dollars in debt with our health care system bigger than just about every other economy in the world, we will be forced to head away from our current specialty-focused model and towards one centered around primary care. Family physicians will continue to be at the heart of this transformation.

4. I really enjoy the day-to-day lifestyle of full spectrum family medicne. I like doing inpatient care, procedures, and delivering babies. Clinic is usually okay but I'm not interested in spending all my time in the clinic. Some students have the misconception that family physicians spend all their time in the clinic. Some do, but many more are like me and enjoy doing a lot of other things in addition to spending time in the clinic.

5. I've spent the last nine years as a physican in the military where family physicians play a big role not only in taking care of troops but also commanding clinics and hospitals and doing all kinds of other things. I started out as a medic years ago and am most interested in operational medicine (serving alongside combat troops and accompanying them on exercises and into battle if necessary). As a family physician, I've been able to spend a lot of time in an operational position. Of course, the military also helps out in paying back loans and gives physicians quite a few generous bonuses. They also send you to a lot of schools, both clinical and non-clinical. I'm currently a student for a year at Intermediate Level Education, where the army trains its mid-level officers in operations, strategy and tactics.

6. I also have a passion for working with underserved populations and global health, both of which are very compatible with family medicine.

7. Lastly, as a medical student in a typical medical center dominated by specialists and sub-specialists, you will be subject to a steady undertone of sometimes subtle, other times blatant, bias against family medicne and primary care along with the idea that only a fool would choose not to specialize and that primary care is for idealists and lower tier students. Do your best to ignore it. Once you get out into the community, the family physician has as much respect as any other physican, and a good one is loved by his patients, particularly the hard-working, salt of the earth folks who are the backbone of our country.

LTC Mike Tarpey
ILE Class 12-01

I'd like to thank you for reminding me why I chose this field. At times this year, it has been very tough to remember that. I have to believe that things get better outside residency as well..so that keeps me going.
 
I felt very comfortable in the clinic addressing the needs of the whole patient -- whatever they wanted to discuss that day. And I was impressed by the acuity of care in an FM clinic. People don't come to the doctor just to chat or have fun. Most people are reluctant to go to the doctor. When they come, they usually have -- or think they have -- something seriously wrong with them.

Also, when I was a 3rd year medical student rotating through all of the specialties, I couldn't stand how specialist so and so would be seeing sick patient xyz and would only address their concerns if it related specifically to their specialty. "Oh, you've developed a wicked rash? Why don't you go see your PCP?" "Having chest pain? Why don't you go to the ER." "But doctor, why can't YOU help me with my chest pain?" I didn't like that at all.
This absolutely just broke my heart. Wow!
 
7. Lastly, as a medical student in a typical medical center dominated by specialists and sub-specialists, you will be subject to a steady undertone of sometimes subtle, other times blatant, bias against family medicne and primary care along with the idea that only a fool would choose not to specialize and that primary care is for idealists and lower tier students. Do your best to ignore it. Once you get out into the community, the family physician has as much respect as any other physican, and a good one is loved by his patients, particularly the hard-working, salt of the earth folks who are the backbone of our country.

1
This whole post was excellent. I'm quoting this last bit since it is absolutely true. FP's are the core of medical care in much of our country. It is not for the faint of heart and it can be HARD. Being an FP is not shameful nor does it mean you were "bottom of the class" nor does it mean you weren't "good enough" to do anything else. You have to know your stuff, be able to determine who is stable and who is very ill, many times without xray or lab or any other equipment there to assist you. It's the field where the "art of medicine" is so important, it can mean life or death for a patient. As I have also said many times it doesn't matter whether you are MD or DO, whether you went to "low tier or high tier school", whether you did an AOA or ACGME residency. At work you are "doctor cabin" and patient's are grateful to have someone there to help them.
 
I felt very comfortable in the clinic addressing the needs of the whole patient -- whatever they wanted to discuss that day. And I was impressed by the acuity of care in an FM clinic. People don't come to the doctor just to chat or have fun. Most people are reluctant to go to the doctor. When they come, they usually have -- or think they have -- something seriously wrong with them.

Also, when I was a 3rd year medical student rotating through all of the specialties, I couldn't stand how specialist so and so would be seeing sick patient xyz and would only address their concerns if it related specifically to their specialty. "Oh, you've developed a wicked rash? Why don't you go see your PCP?" "Having chest pain? Why don't you go to the ER." "But doctor, why can't YOU help me with my chest pain?" I didn't like that at all.
That's because the specialist has NO CLUE what to do with all the other complaints a patient may have. The FP can usually take care of most of them. Gotta love FP.
 
Top