Why have my supervisors lost interest in me?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Curious_mind

New Member
7+ Year Member
Joined
Feb 3, 2014
Messages
3
Reaction score
1
Hi everyone,

I'm 23 years old and begun a health psychology placement at a local hospital in June of 2012. I did really well, so my placement supervisors offered me a position as a research assistant, and then helped me gain admission to honours in psychology. They always thought highly of me, and often commented on my academic and professional qualities.

Last year they supervised me through writing my 12 000 word thesis. It was a stressful time, especially considering I experienced a bit of illness, but in the end I delivered and managed to score 81% (a high distinction) on my thesis. I did get a bit stressed through the year, but I don't think I did too badly, and I missed a couple of deadlines - but in the end I got it in on time and did well!

After all of my hard work, I was hoping to get into the doctorate program that would begin this year, that I have been working towards for about 4-5 years. Well, I didn't get in, and was quite upset about it. I received the bad news on the same day I was showing some of the current doctorate students (from the same program) around the hospital. I was alone when I received the news, but ended up in tears, so I decided to leave for the day.

I was (and still am) in the process of writing up my thesis for publication, but decided to take a bit of time off. All of the other students who had been accepted were around and it was nearly Christmas, so I thought I would take some time to gather my thoughts.

In the end, I decided to visit the course coordinator from the doctoral program as I wanted feedback, so that I could improve my application for next year. She didn't give me a decent answer, but mostly blamed it on grades. This couldn't have been the case, because I knew other students with lower grades who had been accepted. She also said under her breath that I was "raw" and "flat", whatever that is meant to mean. Then, she said "oh, usually I'd say to students to reapply in years to come, but ah..." So, basically she told me not to reapply.

After that, I was still pretty confused. One of my supervisors came out and said that she thought I wasn't accepted because I "lacked maturity". When I asked how my maturity compared to other students', she referred to the fact that they had been in "several relationships", while I've only been in one, and a few other trivial things. I think the word naive also came up, and one even said "oh, I *think* you can think for yourself".

There was only one other student that was rejected, a 48 year old male. I was compared to him, and apparently he took the rejection much better and was using the year off (and possibly even taking a couple more years off!) to gain experience. I don't think there's much comparison to be made - he is married, has four kids, and begun his current job in IT before I was even born!

One of my other supervisors said that they usually like to take people into the course who live away from home (I live with my parents), as they are more familiar with the ways of the world. She said that they are more likely to have learnt independent living skills, be confident in their presentation, and think more quickly on their feet.

It's obvious they have now lost interest in me. A recent RA position was given to another student, they are helping the other rejected student mentioned above find some RA work, and they don't invite me to health psychology events anymore.

What do you think? Why have they lost interest in me? Is there anything I can do to change their minds?

Thank you in advance!
 
It sounds like you may have done something to offend them. It may not be obvious to you what you did and it sounds like they aren't directly telling you the reason either. I would write letters to your supervisors to get to the truth - but you never may get it. It might be something silly that they themselves don't even remember. The other reality may be that they are a bunch of dicks and there is no valid reason. I can't speak to the person you are, but don't be too discouraged by others - keep trying.
 
Thanks PsychBiker, you may be right - I will begin writing letters to them. Everything was fine up until about October or November last year - very strange! Thanks for your reassurance.
 
I'm with Jon Snow. I think they knew you too well and that bit you in the butt. It is unfortunate and probably even unfair, but it is what it is. I wouldn't keep beating my head against the wall trying to get in. Find other options. They probably did you a favor; you'll find a better fit and be happier in the long run.

Good luck,
Dr. E
 
This going to be blunt, but you need to drop it. Stop obsessing about this program--for whatever reason, fair or unfair, you didn't and won't get in. Look at other options. The more you bug the faculty about this, the more you shoot yourself in the foot. That is especially true because you're showing that you really can't handle rejection, and no matter how good you are, there is a ton of rejection in this field. You will be rejected from programs, practicum placements, and jobs. Your manuscripts will be rejected. Your grant applications will be rejected. You may fail comps/quals/prelims. Clients may bail on you or ask for another therapist. It sucks, yes, but you have to learn to cope with it, if you want to be in this field.
 
Seems like your hurting your chances of a good letter of recommendation going forward. Put on a smile and make the most of your opportunity to even get a college education.

Also- find an appropriate place to vent. It's not the internet, it's not your classmates, and it's definitely not your professors.
 
My wife said I didnt really grow up until our first was born.... which was after finishing my ph.d. There are plently of married immature idiots out there. I suppose I am sucess story though.
 
My 2 cents mirrors what others have said. Don't waste your time trying to get back in there. Explore other options at other schools. I have seen MANY people get burned by not keeping their cards close to their chest. The open book is the one that most quickly ends up in the donation bin. Finish out your current work and then get some research experience, a year or two and you'll be in good shape to get in to a place that will work great for you.
 
Thanks for your comments everyone. I think that, for whatever reason (because I'm still really not sure), my time at the hospital is coming to end - so it's definitely time to look for new opportunities! It's upsetting, because I've really enjoyed my time there, but all good things come to an end I suppose.
 
...but all good things come to an end I suppose.

....Sadly, I learned this lesson during the last season of Breaking Bad.

Seriously, dealing with ambivalence (in terms of sitting with the unknown and possibly never knowing) is a skill that comes with maturity and training (in some professions). You will never truly know the motivations and true feelings of others, only what you can determine from their behaviors and what they report. With that said, I concur with everyone above to let it go and move on. You will burn up your valuable energy and potential resources if you beat a dead horse. :beat:

Spend your time in the immediate future coming up with a newly improved plan. And take everyone's advice in this thread to help shine some light on the following (but certainly not limited to):
...obsessive to the point of being a bully, and lack insight into how your own behavior is affecting others around you.

...find an appropriate place to vent. It's not the internet, it's not your classmates, and it's definitely not your professors.

Good luck with your new plan! :luck:
 
Last edited:
Thanks for your comments everyone. I think that, for whatever reason (because I'm still really not sure), my time at the hospital is coming to end - so it's definitely time to look for new opportunities! It's upsetting, because I've really enjoyed my time there, but all good things come to an end I suppose.
Good luck to you. It can be frustrating getting rejected from a place that you really like (I know from experience). There is probably something to learn from this too that will help you as you move forward.
 
Sorry to say, but you may think of yourself as someone who is excelling when you actually aren't. Just assuming (and looking at your other post) you are not a person to incorporate feed back which is huge in doctoral level training. You also come off as if they owe you something, which I'm sure is how they are perceiving your quest to seek "why" and comparing yourself to others. Your best course of action now before you blow references is to be silent, complete your thesis and find another school. Let this be a lesson in humbling yourself and incorporating suggestions on making yourself better.
 
Top