Would a LOR from a psychoneuroimmunology professor be science or non-science?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Occams Chainsaw

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Oct 5, 2012
Messages
15
Reaction score
0
I'm thinking of asking my psychoneuroimmunology professor for a letter. I'm fairly confident it would qualify as a science letter, but I want to make sure because some fields of psychology can be a grey area.
 
psychoneuroimmunology wouldn't be one of those fields, imho
 
I'm thinking of asking my psychoneuroimmunology professor for a letter. I'm fairly confident it would qualify as a science letter, but I want to make sure because some fields of psychology can be a grey area.

The course would certainly be BCMP; however, the professor would likely depend upon the dept and be up to a school's interpretation. I would personally avoid using that person as either science or nonscience simply to avoid having a school reject your app/mark it incomplete for not following directions.
 
Well, the course sounds like it is all about the HPA axis, which is completely BCPM. If you think it would be a good letter, I would get it, especially if there is not an alternative that would provide an equal or better letter.
 
My physiomolecularimmunonephrology course was not considered a science course, but my biopsychophysicalcardiology class was, so it's tough to say.
 
As a neuroscience major, I'm impressed by the big words you guys are using.
 
Neuroimmunology is my dream research gig for the future 👍
 
Well, the course sounds like it is all about the HPA axis, which is completely BCPM. If you think it would be a good letter, I would get it, especially if there is not an alternative that would provide an equal or better letter.

Yeah that's what I figured, It's a fascinating subject material, and we spend just as much time going over the physiology of the immune system and nervous system in about as much detail in my actual upper division physiology courses for my minor (The undergraduate physiology department here is part of the college of medicine).

I'd say the field is equal parts psychology, immunology, and nervous system physiology. Some endocrinology is thrown in too, because cortisol has a profound effect on chronic inflammation levels when glucocorticoid receptor levels are down regulated and you just can't transduce the signal for immune cells to stop pumping out cytokines. We just went over a lot of examples relating to the HPA axis as well.

Our final for the class is writing a 10 page research proposal for a grant study in the field of PNI. Obviously I won't be following up with my own grant idea because I'll be applying to medical school, but I'm excited to try and find a link (read: only write about a theoretical study) between psychosocial stress and circulating cytokine levels (specifically negative adipokines from visceral fat that play a role in insulin resistance)

If such a study were done it would help uncover the mechanistic basis of psychological stress having a measurable effect of the development of metabolic syndrome.

Half the class are graduate students, some professors I've had for classes are auditing the class, and generally I need to pull just as much knowledge from my physiology minor than I do from my psychology base, hence figuring it should be counted as a science letter.

If it doesn't, I still think it would be an incredibly strong non-science letter, to which I can get two physiology professors for my science letters. At the same time, a majority of schools I am applying to next cycle will require a committee letter over the individual letters. Should I still be getting individual letters?
 
My physiomolecularimmunonephrology course was not considered a science course, but my biopsychophysicalcardiology class was, so it's tough to say.

Typed biopsychophysicalcardiology into google to see what would come up... There was only one hit and it was this thread 🙁
 
Typed biopsychophysicalcardiology into google to see what would come up... There was only one hit and it was this thread 🙁

I mean I figured he was being sarcastic. "Physiomolecularimmunonephrology" (The molecular physiology of kidney immune cells...?? Really now?)

Not to mention, even if there was a "biopsychophysicalcardiology" it would just be a subset of PNI. There is a marked relationship between stress, the immune system, and cardiovascular problems.
 
Top