Hello!
I'm a long-time lurker on the forums, but created an account after seeing this post as I'm a current resident (CA-2) at Yale.
My TL;DR: come to the interview and see the program for yourself! On my 'pre-interview' rank list, Yale was on the lower half, but after all of my interviews I ended up ranking it 1st. I'm biased of course, so take everything I say with a grain of salt, but I'm very happy here and plan on staying after residency, as a large number of our residents do.
Yale: It's a great program, with very strong clinical training (but who doesn't say that!). Our attendings are unbelievable nice, and we usually use first names with most. They are very supportive and always teaching in the OR, if you're willing to listen. I find with most program reviews, people complain about 'intra op teaching', but it's always you get what you give. If you ask a question, I've never had an attending not sit down and spend an hour with you to go over things, and draw all over your papers! They are typically 1:2 coverage, with one room being a CRNA, so they are really focused on you and your room for assistance and teaching. The attendings are also very flexible, as far as your plan for each patient, and are open to anything (reasonable) for your anesthetic plan. We have many experts in the field, including the current editors of Stoetling and Barash, the airway expertise of Rosenblatt, and thoracic/cardiac attendings that are amazing as well. Regional is definitely not a strong suit, and our pediatric service could use improvement as well, there is a lot of turnover of attendings. Our PD Dr Schwartz is so nice and very supportive of us residents, and our attendings are supportive of us as well to a fault.
I googled the Scutwork site you mentioned, and I think it's very outdated. My typical day is showing up at 615-630, to set up my room and see patient at 7A for our standard 730A start. If it's a late start, I arrive at 7A. We are relieved at 4P by CRNAs or the on call residents if you're case is ongoing, I'd say 430 at the latest. If your case is closing at that time, you will usually finish it up though. CA-1s usually finish up the pre-ops for the next day (we have APRNs who do them during the day), but they're all gone by 5. Call is amazing, with 1-2 weekends on call per month, and 2 full weekends off each month for the most part. You may have 1-2 'late calls' during the month, which means until 8P, but you are paid for the extra hours, and it's not bad at all and covers a few bills!
New Haven: love it. Seriously, forget what you've heard. There is a 'Yale Bubble' of several square miles including the undergrad and medical campus, hospital, and downtown and where you will live that is incredibly safe and people walk home all throughout the night. It's covered not just by police but by Yale ($$$) security on every other corner. The bad New Haven is several miles away, and you'll never go there, period. I love living downtown, it's like an urban city but small, where you can walk outside to a million different bars, restaurants, stores, etc while paying half the rent of NYC. Weekend off? NYC is an 1.5 hrs away on the train, which leaves every hour, from the station down the street... or use your car (yes everyone has a car), to drive up to Boston or the beach, or Maine for the weekend.
As far as the above comment, I will keep silent as if you don't have anything nice to say... For intubations that's ridiculous, I was the 'code resident' the other day to respond to all off floor intubations, and I did zero. Disappointed, because I wanted to do a few, but literally zero calls! You are NOT pulled out of the OR, as this is your assignment for the day, and the ICU does their own intubations most of the time. You actually want to be called, or the day gets pretty boring! And his New Haven comments are ridiculous, again it's like any other city with well defined 'good/bad' areas over certain streets, and you're never going to go up there anyway.
In conclusion, I'm very happy with my choice, I am well-rested in the morning and home by 5 on most days, and our call schedule isn't bad at all. We're busy during the day, but it's a case of diminishing returns, how much more would you learn by being forced to stay to 7P every day? Classes are improving, we've made them all chalk-talks and interactive, instead of glazing over during a PPT. (Once a week on Wed afternoons. )
The thing that stuck out to me was during my interview dinners, I went to several programs were a few residents would show up, and they were really weird, or really tired. I went to Yale and about 30 residents came to the dinner and they were all so happy and hugging and having (free) drinks and dinner, and were telling each interviewee how glad they were they chose Yale. CA-3's this year all matched really well to their top choices, and name goes far.
So I would just say, at least come and visit us, it's the largest hospital in New England (yes, bigger than MGH and BWH), but with a great and affordable place to live and happy faculty/residents who most often decide to stay here for good!