Post removed at OP's request.
Last edited by a moderator:
Yes sorry edited post! I received full tuition financial aid at Yale so I’d just need to pay for cost of living.Ah, if that's the case my answer is still the same, it's just not as clear-cut as I had first thought.
+1Debt-free in LA >>> accumulating debt in New Haven.
You'll be able to match back to the east coast from UCLA.
Hey yeah I actually absolutely loved my interview day at ucla (maybe even more than Yale). No red flags whatsoever for me it’s just a comparison of where I want to eventually end up (surgical specialty on east coast) and what would be best primed to get me there. Also my ties/connections to the east coast make me a little apprehensive about leaving. Thanks for the input appreciate itI'll just echo what some of the above have said: match list at UCLA is probably Cali-heavy because most people who go there want to stay in Cali, not because of their inability to match on the east coast. I would also say forget about the prestige. Ask yourself if the stress-free unstructuredness of the Yale System is worth the money to you. The Yale System makes Yale completely different from any other school out there, so if that is the main thing complicating this for you, talk to current students about their experience.
Side note: It blows my mind how many of these posts there are (Geffen vs X)...I didn't apply to UCLA but they must be giving some serious red flags at interview day for people to consider turning down debt-free education in favor of a $100k+ option.
Yesterday morning@iliasis, when did you get your finaid offer from Yale?
That's fair, I think having your SO/support system on the east coast makes Yale that much more appealing.Hey yeah I actually absolutely loved my interview day at ucla (maybe even more than Yale). No red flags whatsoever for me it’s just a comparison of where I want to eventually end up (surgical specialty on east coast) and what would be best primed to get me there. Also my ties/connections to the east coast make me a little apprehensive about leaving. Thanks for the input appreciate it
Yale, hands down. UCLA is a great school but I don't think it has the cache that Yale has. Plus, UCLA has a cut-throat culture while Yale is known for stress-free. AOA at UCLA, I imagine, is a shi*tshow.
Can you elaborate a bit more on the cutthroat culture at ucla? The students seemed happy when I was thereYale, hands down. UCLA is a great school but I don't think it has the cache that Yale has. Plus, UCLA has a cut-throat culture while Yale is known for stress-free. AOA at UCLA, I imagine, is a shi*tshow.
I’m totally ok with going somewhere new but in general I want to settle in east coast. Personally prefer it to the west - I like seasons!People are so different, it’s what makes the world an interesting place. Some people really crave proximity to family and familiar surroundings. I personally love travel, new places. Sounds like OP is from the northeast? If it were me, the freshness of a new place, especially one where it might be 70 degrees in January would send me straight to LA. Plus the money- starting with internship, paying back a thousand dollars a month for ten years at best. Take the money, go to UCLA, you earned it! Congratulations
well, my question is did you meet any MS3 and MS4? Most of people we meet on the trail are MS 1 or 2, ie., before clinical years. Med school really doesn't start until you are on the wards. When you have so many med students and so few spots to rotate and also when you have the pressure to honors, the cut-throatness will be out in the open. MS1 and MS2's are clueless about what's ahead of them. Talk to some MS3 and MS4's if you can. I happened to speak with a lot of MS3's at Yale and I totally saw the advantage of the Yale System. You simply can't judge the environment of a school based on preclinical time.Can you elaborate a bit more on the cutthroat culture at ucla? The students seemed happy when I was there
well, my question is did you meet any MS3 and MS4? Most of people we meet on the trail are MS 1 or 2, ie., before clinical years. Med school really doesn't start until you are on the wards. When you have so many med students and so few spots to rotate and also when you have the pressure to honors, the cut-throatness will be out in the open. MS1 and MS2's are clueless about what's ahead of them. Talk to some MS3 and MS4's if you can. I happened to speak with a lot of MS3's at Yale and I totally saw the advantage of the Yale System. You simply can't judge the environment of a school based on preclinical time.
also, clinical grades.So if I am understanding you correctly, there is no basis for your claim of there being a cutthroat culture at UCLA other than the fact that there is AOA.
The difference in “prestige” is minimal or even nonexistent.That is true, I haven't met with any of the upperclassmen and I was hoping to get to meet with them during second look, which as you probably know is cancelled for most/all schools 🙁
I agree that Yale did seem like much more of a low-stress/collaborative than the other schools which is definitely appealing. Also historically it seems to have been a t10 school - my apprehension about it is mainly that is seems to be decreasing in rank quite steadily every year whereas ucla has been rising in ranks. With step 1 becoming p/f I'd worry that by the time I'd be applying to residency it wouldn't be quite the program it once was amongst residency directors and deans.
I was worried about the same given that I have a choice to make between NYU and Yale. But I decided on Yale. I think it's an excellent program and it will remain so. If you want to talk to upper classsmen at UCLA, you should call the admissions to see if they can arrange it.That is true, I haven't met with any of the upperclassmen and I was hoping to get to meet with them during second look, which as you probably know is cancelled for most/all schools 🙁
I agree that Yale did seem like much more of a low-stress/collaborative than the other schools which is definitely appealing. Also historically it seems to have been a t10 school - my apprehension about it is mainly that is seems to be decreasing in rank quite steadily every year whereas ucla has been rising in ranks. With step 1 becoming p/f I'd worry that by the time I'd be applying to residency it wouldn't be quite the program it once was amongst residency directors and deans.
If I were to go to Yale I would need to pay only for total cost of living which they estimate to be ~32k a year, so over 4 years that would be about 128k. I would certainly need to take on loans in this case.Rather than playing the guessing game, what exactly is your price tag for Yale? If you're talking about close to 100k after the scholarship, then go to UCLA. (This is me assuming they aren't paying for your living whatsoever or any of the misc other. Don't forget tuition/COL inflation each year. Your price tag will certainly be higher than you are estimating.) It's the same product, they're selling with minor differences. The salesmen in question are even wearing the same suit (Same prestige). No reason to pay far more for it
Congrats on some very awesome choices! What drew you to Yale over NYU?I was worried about the same given that I have a choice to make between NYU and Yale. But I decided on Yale. I think it's an excellent program and it will remain so. If you want to talk to upper classsmen at UCLA, you should call the admissions to see if they can arrange it.
I personally feel that Yale is a better fit for me. NYU strikes me as too academic oriented in its student body..If I were to go to Yale I would need to pay only for total cost of living which they estimate to be ~32k a year, so over 4 years that would be about 128k. I would certainly need to take on loans in this case.
Congrats on some very awesome choices! What drew you to Yale over NYU?
That's like saying "Penn is like number 3 on the east coast"...It's also number 3 in the US** lolI would choose Yale. It is an ivy with incredible prestige. UCLA is like number 3 on the west coast.
That's like saying "Penn is like number 3 on the east coast"...It's also number 3 in the US** lol
well, I feel like you might be a bit too extreme on this. I think UCLA is an excellent school.UCLA does not have the cachet of Yale. Its not even close. It is a great school but its no Yale.
Y'all baffle me sometimes...SDN is wildUCLA does not have the cachet of Yale. Its not even close. It is a great school but its no Yale.
UCLA does not have the cachet of Yale. Its not even close. It is a great school but its no Yale.
well, I feel like you might be a bit too extreme on this. I think UCLA is an excellent school.
So 130k to pay to live, potentially after inflation it'll probably be 140k. Then by the time you pay it off, closer to 200k if you decide to live comfortably as a resident and use your attending pay to make bigger payments.
Don't drink whatever Kool-aid the throwaway kid is sipping. Upwards of 200k doesn't justify it when you've got a T10 cost free attendance. Here's one piece of useful business/financial advice I received in the working world "Don't take advice from someone who doesn't have to live with the consequences." You're the only one taking on that burden of debt. We're not concerned with the outcome, you are.
You'll look back in 10 years when all of that attending paycheck goes to your bank account and smile as you drive your Ferrari into the sunset.
^^^this is definitely the more likely outcome.Or you can smile as you drive your Ferrari into the sunset with your Yale degree on your wall. 200k wont make a difference over a 35 year career.
^^^this is definitely the more likely outcome.
-those who make decisions based on prestige/how others will view them are more likely to buy a Ferrari.
-Those who make financially wise decisions and go to UCLA for free are not the type of people who would buy a Ferrari.
I think the ucla/no Ferrari/no debt person cares less about what others think and will be happier in the long run 🙂
Aren’t you the one leaning towards turning down a full COA at washU for Hopkins because, in your own post, it sounds more impressive to tell other people?Or you can smile as you drive your Ferrari into the sunset with your Yale degree on your wall. 200k wont make a difference over a 35 year career.
my question is why stress is always ignored on SDN. Just because we fought so many years to get where we are now, it doesn't mean we have to keep fighting each other going forward. I heard a lot of stories from UCLA being super cutthroat and incohesive.Aren’t you the one leaning towards turning down a full COA at washU for Hopkins because, in your own post, it sounds more impressive to tell other people?
Not sure if it’s because of step 1 p/f, US news ranks just coming out, or if it always has been like this but these school choice posts seem more dominated by perceived prestige... it’s bringing out some wild opinions here on sdn.
UCLA, no debt, amazing weather, living in a vibrant city seems really appealing. Stress free at Yale seems like the biggest selling point, as well as closer to SO (how close though?) you decide if it’s worth the debt, and living in new haven. Good luck.
Aren’t you the one leaning towards turning down a full COA at washU for Hopkins because, in your own post, it sounds more impressive to tell other people?
Not sure if it’s because of step 1 p/f, US news ranks just coming out, or if it always has been like this but these school choice posts seem more dominated by perceived prestige... it’s bringing out some wild opinions here on sdn.
UCLA, no debt, amazing weather, living in a vibrant city seems really appealing. Stress free at Yale seems like the biggest selling point, as well as closer to SO (how close though?) you decide if it’s worth the debt, and living in new haven. Good luck.
Medical school will be stressful wherever you go. The biggest difference constituting less stress sentiment here at Yale seems to be no AOA. I am not privy to these cutthroat UCLA stories. To OP, unless you are getting these stories directly from a med student at the school in question, I would take anecdotal info from anyone, not just sdn posters, with a decent grain of salt and do your own inquiry. Really sucks how second looks are cancelled though.my question is why stress is always ignored on SDN. Just because we fought so many years to get where we are now, it doesn't mean we have to keep fighting each other going forward. I heard a lot of stories from UCLA being super cutthroat and incohesive.
Totally note the biases people definitely have. To answer your question debt certainly weighs heavily for me and it is by no means something that I am taking for granted. It certainly is something that will stress me out. However, a cutthroat culture and having to compete for knowledge/attention during rotations (like many have alluded to will happen at ucla) would also most likely stress me out so at this point I'm not sure which one beats out the other.Medical school will be stressful wherever you go. The biggest difference constituting less stress sentiment here at Yale seems to be no AOA. I am not privy to these cutthroat UCLA stories. To OP, unless you are getting these stories directly from a med student at the school in question, I would take anecdotal info from anyone, not just sdn posters, with a decent grain of salt and do your own inquiry. Really sucks how second looks are cancelled though.
Note also a lot of people in these threads have their own biases based on where they are attending/got in, factors important to them etc. that is evidenced by post histories but sometimes not mentioned. Not trying to call out anyone specifically or anything, just food for thought.
For example, I have my own biases made by financial struggles so I think UCLA wins easy. However you have to decide/inform us on how much debt weighs on you, etc. Will having more debt in turn give you more stress or not?
Do you mean in medicine or as a general institution? It seems like the reputation scores of the medical schools are relatively comparable and the ucla hospital system is quite expansive - perhaps one of the most expansive in the country. During my interview day a huge topic of conversation was how they recently became the #1 health system in california (beating out ucsf).UCLA does not have the cachet of Yale. Its not even close. It is a great school but its no Yale.
Yale provides you with some interesting perks for the rest of your life. I would recommend Yale if you would like said perks, as the name carries a great deal of power in certain scenarios. Back in the day we called it the "Yale card," which you could cash (regardless of your tenuous relation to the institution or YNHH) to make one big move about once in your life if not more so long as it was on your resume. New Haven may not seem that great, but it's got it's perks, hop on Metro North and you can head to Manhattan with your friends while also having enough cash left over to have fun while you're there. UCLA will carry you far out West, but in the Northeast and in the halls of power, that Yale name will mean more than a few spots on some nonsense magazine's rank list ever will.
Yale provides you with some interesting perks for the rest of your life. I would recommend Yale if you would like said perks, as the name carries a great deal of power in certain scenarios. Back in the day we called it the "Yale card," which you could cash (regardless of your tenuous relation to the institution or YNHH) to make one big move about once in your life if not more so long as it was on your resume. New Haven may not seem that great, but it's got it's perks, hop on Metro North and you can head to Manhattan with your friends while also having enough cash left over to have fun while you're there. UCLA will carry you far out West, but in the Northeast and in the halls of power, that Yale name will mean more than a few spots on some nonsense magazine's rank list ever will.
Thanks for the input. It certainly sounds like Yale could bring a lot of perks, but do you think that these perks will translate into the medical field as well? For example, the lay person won't know about Mayo but in medicine Mayo is clearly a huge name that opens lots of doors.Yale provides you with some interesting perks for the rest of your life. I would recommend Yale if you would like said perks, as the name carries a great deal of power in certain scenarios. Back in the day we called it the "Yale card," which you could cash (regardless of your tenuous relation to the institution or YNHH) to make one big move about once in your life if not more so long as it was on your resume. New Haven may not seem that great, but it's got it's perks, hop on Metro North and you can head to Manhattan with your friends while also having enough cash left over to have fun while you're there. UCLA will carry you far out West, but in the Northeast and in the halls of power, that Yale name will mean more than a few spots on some nonsense magazine's rank list ever will.
Thanks for the input. It certainly sounds like Yale could bring a lot of perks, but do you think that these perks will translate into the medical field as well? For example, the lay person won't know about Mayo but in medicine Mayo is clearly a huge name that opens lots of doors.
Could you elaborate on these “perks”? Thanks!Yale provides you with some interesting perks for the rest of your life. I would recommend Yale if you would like said perks, as the name carries a great deal of power in certain scenarios. Back in the day we called it the "Yale card," which you could cash (regardless of your tenuous relation to the institution or YNHH) to make one big move about once in your life if not more so long as it was on your resume. New Haven may not seem that great, but it's got it's perks, hop on Metro North and you can head to Manhattan with your friends while also having enough cash left over to have fun while you're there. UCLA will carry you far out West, but in the Northeast and in the halls of power, that Yale name will mean more than a few spots on some nonsense magazine's rank list ever will.