2009 Match Lists

BU Medical Sciences
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
pntgrd said:
How is that unimpressive? That must be the most ignorant comment I've heard on sdn lately.
Click to expand...

Because a lot of people who can't get into ortho, ENT, derm, ophtho, rad, etc even though they originally wanted to usually end up going into Internal Medicine.

That and also because Internal Medicine is not a very difficult specialty to match into.
 
Demas567 said:
^^^
Almost 30% of the class matched into Internal Medicine. Not impressive.
Click to expand...

How so? To go into subspecialities like cardio, gastroenterology, etc you have to finish a residency in internal medicine.
 
Demas567 said:
Because a lot of people who can't get into ortho, ENT, derm, ophtho, rad, etc even though they originally wanted to usually end up going into Internal Medicine.

That and also because Internal Medicine is not a very difficult specialty to match into.
Click to expand...
Lmao...look at where they matched, not too shabby.
 
Maybe we need more schools here, but so far it seems that Columbia, Yale, and Duke are the main NS depots. Interesting that all are Ivies.
 
Excelsius said:
Maybe we need more schools here, but so far it seems that Columbia, Yale, and Duke are the main NS depots. Interesting that all are Ivies.
Click to expand...

If by "NS" you mean Neurosurgery, and by "main depots" you mean large producers of, Georgetown matched 5 students into neurosurgery as well.
 
Excelsius said:
Maybe we need more schools here, but so far it seems that Columbia, Yale, and Duke are the main NS depots. Interesting that all are Ivies.
Click to expand...

since when was Duke considered an ivy?
 
blackbird11384 said:
If by "NS" you mean Neurosurgery, and by "main depots" you mean large producers of, Georgetown matched 5 students into neurosurgery as well.
Click to expand...

That's pretty good. Actually the only school that I am sure about is Columbia because I have seen their matchlists for several years. All these other schools are from just one year. It would be nice if we could have access to matchlists with aggregated data from three or more years. They would be much more meaningful then and would more or less squelch staunch critics like Law2Doc.
 
Demas567 said:
Because a lot of people who can't get into ortho, ENT, derm, ophtho, rad, etc even though they originally wanted to usually end up going into Internal Medicine.

That and also because Internal Medicine is not a very difficult specialty to match into.
Click to expand...


You have no basis for saying this. How do you know, are you in their class? Don't assume that everyone wants to go into derm or ophtho. It's simply not true.
 
gujuDoc said:
The IVY league is a sports league like the PAC 10, SEC, BigEast, etc.

DUKE IS NOT PART OF THE IVY LEAGUE.

This time I am eyelling and not just emphasizing cuz this is a huge pet peeve of mine. People call all top tier schools IVIES. IVY LEAGUE DOES NOT EQUAL SYNONYM FOR ALL TOP TIER SCHOOLS. It is a specific subset of schools in the NE that just happen to be some of the oldest and most reputated schools.

The ivy league schools include Princeton, Penn, Harvard, Columbia, Cornell, Brown, and I think Dartmouth but someone may have to correct me on the last one or any I may have left out.
Click to expand...

Fixed for you. (Being a Princeton alumnus kid, it's engrained in me to list Princeton first -- that's all) 😉

As for the list, yes, Dartmouth is one and Yale. There are 8.
 
Last edited:
lol @ forgetting Yale 🙂
 
gujuDoc said:
The IVY league is a sports league like the PAC 10, SEC, BigEast, etc.

DUKE IS NOT PART OF THE IVY LEAGUE.

This time I am eyelling and not just emphasizing cuz this is a huge pet peeve of mine. People call all top tier schools IVIES. IVY LEAGUE DOES NOT EQUAL SYNONYM FOR ALL TOP TIER SCHOOLS. It is a specific subset of schools in the NE that just happen to be some of the oldest and most reputated schools.

The ivy league schools include UPenn, Harvard, Columbia, Cornell, Princeton, Brown, and I think Dartmouth but someone may have to correct me on the last one or any I may have left out.
Click to expand...


That's fine. I don't mean Ivies in the strict sense. Perhaps I could use a smaller letter. To me, Stanford, Duke, Hopkins, Rice, and to some extent MIT and Caltech represent a very special level of colleges that are not just "top," but are also very famous (including abroad) in a way that schools like WashU and UCSF do not even come close. I don't have a particular name for these schools, so I call them "ivies" since they are up to par with the prestige and fame of the real Ivies. I haven't come up with a better name and for now will have to just keep using the small letter "ivy." I am sure you can cope. Just call Stanford the Ivy of the West, Duke the Ivy of the South, etc.
 
gujuDoc said:
I'm sure you can find them if you do an SDN search. People post match lists every year.

However, they would not squelch critics like Law2doc because his points still stand.

We do not know the following as premeds:

1. Whether medical students took the residency spots they did either due to lower scores or stuff and not being competitive for higher spots in their field much less for more comp. fields or because they chose their field or location.

2. We don't know what percent got their 1st choice.

3. We don't know what motivates them to rank one vs. another

There are so many variables that it doesn't really say much to us.
Click to expand...

This is irrelevant. You can give me an example of any system and I can tell you hundreds of things that we may not know. Instead, try to concentrate on what we do know. You see a school producing a good number of NS residents on a yearly basis, for example. Then you know for sure that the school has the proper means and the advising process to get you there. Just that fact answers all of your hypotheticals above. Don't be too wooed by lawyerism. I have a lot of experience in that area myself, though admittedly, not as much as Herr L2D.
 
gujuDoc said:
What I don't understand is why they still use this system of IM and then subspecialty instead of just creating direct programs like they do with other specialties like radonco, neuro, derm, etc.
Click to expand...

It's because you need the foundation of medicine in order be be a competent medical specialist. Dermatologists are never the primary team of a patient, but the GI and Cards services are. In fact, much of the IM residency at large hospitals is spent on the GI, Cards, Heme-onc, etc. service.
 
Last edited:
Excelsius said:
This is irrelevant. You can give me an example of any system and I can tell you hundreds of things that we may not know. Instead, try to concentrate on what we do know. You see a school producing a good number of NS residents on a yearly basis, for example. Then you know for sure that the school has the proper means and the advising process to get you there. Just that fact answers all of your hypotheticals above. Don't be too wooed by lawyerism. I have a lot of experience in that area myself, though admittedly, not as much as Herr L2D.
Click to expand...
Not everyone will, but I agree with you. One match list can tell you very little, but 5 years of match lists can give you trends. They can at least hint at the emphasis of the school and the quality of advising in various departments.
 
Ashers said:
Fixed for you. (Being a Princeton alumnus kid, it's engrained in me to list Princeton first -- that's all) 😉

As for the list, yes, Dartmouth is one and Yale. There are 8.
Click to expand...
Now your "Princeton of the South" comment makes total sense. :idea:
 
Excelsius said:
That's fine. I don't mean Ivies in the strict sense. Perhaps I could use a smaller letter. To me, Stanford, Duke, Hopkins, Rice, and to some extent MIT and Caltech represent a very special level of colleges that are not just "top," but are also very famous (including abroad) in a way that schools like WashU and UCSF do not even come close. I don't have a particular name for these schools, so I call them "ivies" since they are up to par with the prestige and fame of the real Ivies. I haven't come up with a better name and for now will have to just keep using the small letter "ivy." I am sure you can cope. Just call Stanford the Ivy of the West, Duke the Ivy of the South, etc.
Click to expand...
There is no small letter "ivy." You're just wrong.
 
scarletgirl777 said:
Now your "Princeton of the South" comment makes total sense. :idea:
Click to expand...

Well... mostly based on hearing that Duke's architectural style was based on Princeton's. Since it was related to Princeton, I just happened to remember the tidbit.

Edit: wow... totally missed MrBurns' post last night. She was right. =)
 
Last edited:
scrambizle said:
It's because you need the foundation of medicine in order be be a competent medical specialist. Dermatologists are never the primary team of a patient, but the GI and Cards services are. In fact, much of the IM residency at large hospitals is spent on the GI, Cards, Heme-onc, etc. service.
Click to expand...

Aren't there some programs looking at "fast-track" residency models for cards?

I think this model may come more into play for residency sort of like integrated plastics, thoracic surgery, vascular surgery...
 
scarletgirl777 said:
There is no small letter "ivy." You're just wrong.
Click to expand...
I know! As I said, it is a personal choice for me. Let's not get too picky. I can call it perhaps "Ivylike" to prevent several posts about the same point.
 
southernIM said:
Aren't there some programs looking at "fast-track" residency models for cards?

I think this model may come more into play for residency sort of like integrated plastics, thoracic surgery, vascular surgery...
Click to expand...
Yep, I believe the "fast track" cards residency is 2 years of IM and 4(?) of cards. It's not too popular right now, but my friend told me it at least exists.
 
MrBurns10 said:
Yep, I believe the "fast track" cards residency is 2 years of IM and 4(?) of cards. It's not too popular right now, but my friend told me it at least exists.
Click to expand...

Just curious - maybe you can help me out here, but what is the main purpose behind a program like Medicine-Pediatrics (Med-Peds)? I've seen that on a few matchlists and was wondering what that was all about.
 
RoadRunner17 said:
Just curious - maybe you can help me out here, but what is the main purpose behind a program like Medicine-Pediatrics (Med-Peds)? I've seen that on a few matchlists and was wondering what that was all about.
Click to expand...

It's a combined residency program. 4 years total when pediatrics or medicine by itself is 3 years each. It gives the person the ability to see adults and children, but have some more specialization with each compared to Family Med. And there's no OB/gyn involved, like in Family Med.

Edit: You can also do a bunch of fellowships and follow patients for their whole lives: eg. med-peds cards and then follow adult patients with congenital anomalies. One meds-peds I met this year is doing a Medicine ID fellowship, and she can see regular peds electively.

There are a few combined programs:
Med-geriatrics
Med-neuro
etc.
 
Ashers said:
It's a combined residency program. 4 years total when pediatrics or medicine by itself is 3 years each. It gives the person the ability to see adults and children, but have some more specialization with each compared to Family Med. And there's no OB/gyn involved, like in Family Med.

There are a few combined programs:
Med-geriatrics
Med-neuro
etc.
Click to expand...
Explained beautifully! I've known a few students who ended up choosing med-peds because they weren't sure which one they'd rather do in the long run.
 
Last edited:
gujuDoc said:
You beat me to it!!!!!!!!! LOL

That said, I agree with everything you said.

Also, EM/IM is a dual program that I've heard exists. and for DO people I've heard they have both the EM/IM option or the dual FP/EM option, but MD programs don't have a dual FP/EM program though they do have IM/EM programs.
Click to expand...

I also edited it, since I forgot a bunch of stuff that is relevant. 😀
 
gujuDoc said:
But in reality, both peds and IM mirror each other to some degree but one is the adult version and one is the children's version. But I would guess that by doing both you are able to work with all age groups like a FP would but yet be able to go slightly deeper then an FP because your level of knowledge is slightly deeper then an FP's knowledge would be.

That is what I think anyways.
Click to expand...
I agree. Plus, FM is more outpatient-oriented while IM/Peds can be inpatient, outpatient, or both.
 
MrBurns10 said:
I agree. Plus, FM is more outpatient-oriented while IM/Peds can be inpatient, outpatient, or both.
Click to expand...

And you can specialize in IM/Peds. You can't do cards, GI, etc fellowships as a FM doc.
 
Anyone have or know where i can find University of Arizona's match results?
 
dude, get a life!!!

gujuDoc said:
The IVY league is a sports league like the PAC 10, SEC, BigEast, etc.

DUKE IS NOT PART OF THE IVY LEAGUE.

This time I am eyelling and not just emphasizing cuz this is a huge pet peeve of mine. People call all top tier schools IVIES. IVY LEAGUE DOES NOT EQUAL SYNONYM FOR ALL TOP TIER SCHOOLS. It is a specific subset of schools in the NE that just happen to be some of the oldest and most reputated schools.

The ivy league schools include UPenn, Harvard, Columbia, Cornell, Princeton, Brown, and I think Dartmouth but someone may have to correct me on the last one or any I may have left out.
Click to expand...
 
gujuDoc said:
Yah Ashers corrected me. Couldn't remember but knew I was missing one. 🙂.

How goes it? Did you match this year or do you have a year or 2 left to go?
Click to expand...

Took a research year out. Too bad I have decided to apply to a different field (whoops!). How about you?
 
Law2Doc said:
Wow. With all the folks leaving medicine altogether at Harvard, it sounds like they aren't doing a great job in inspiring people into various medical fields. When more people go into mgmt consulting than, say, neuro, that kind of suggests the school is doing something to turn off its students to medicine. It should be the very rare person who ditches what they've trained the last 4 years for, or else it signals a shortcoming, IMHO.
Click to expand...

i dont see what the problem with this is
 
can someone post up WAKE FOREST? thank you. this thread needs less useless chat and more MATCHLIST info.
 
idea: post up links to each school's matchlist alphabetically similar to the accepted, waitlist threads.

add each school after each post, so that SDNers dont have to roam through 8 pages of useless arguments over duke being classified as an "ivy" or not. thanks
 
I have the Wake Forest 2009 match list but my copy has student names on it so I don't want to post it. If anyone has specific questions about it, I may be able to post that. There are 95 names on it and it looks like there are 6 that didn't match.
 
BJPENNSTATE said:
idea: post up links to each school's matchlist alphabetically similar to the accepted, waitlist threads.

add each school after each post, so that SDNers dont have to roam through 8 pages of useless arguments over duke being classified as an "ivy" or not. thanks
Click to expand...

You are more than welcome to do that yourself, but don't expect someone else to do it for you. thanks. 🙄
 
medpro said:
I have the Wake Forest 2009 match list but my copy has student names on it so I don't want to post it. If anyone has specific questions about it, I may be able to post that. There are 95 names on it and it looks like there are 6 that didn't match.
Click to expand...

Where are the rads people going?
 
Do any of you have Howard's Match List? I'm trying to find it, but haven't found one yet.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

P
Interpreting match lists
Replies
6
Views
786
Goro
Goro
X0001234
Interpreting match lists
Replies
6
Views
1K
AJS59
AJS59
C
  • Locked
DO schools have worse match lists… does that correct for DO schools accepting students with lower MCATs?
Replies
1
Views
1K
wysdoc
wysdoc
D
TMDSAS Match with IA
Replies
5
Views
2K
dosh24
D
F
Tier List
Replies
2
Views
627
futurebonedr
F
Top