I need to get some honest opinions about an incident that recently occurred with my dog.
I was going out to my car and my six month old pup (pictured) squeezed through the door with me. He saw a girl and immediate ran toward them in a friendly manner, which was maybe 5 feet from the door. This person's dog was in between two cars and my dog did not see him until the other dog lunged at him and got him by the throat. I ran to the dog and pried its jaws open to get my pup out. It was absolutely horrible. I thought my dog was dead, to be honest. Turns out he is ok, but we had to rush him to the emergency clinic and he has a broken jaw, a puncture wound and a heart murmur that had never been previously detected (this could be unrelated to the incident, but I feel like it's still important to note). He just got out of surgery last night and I'm picking him up today.
SO my question is: who do you think should pay for our bills? Both of our dogs were off a leash, but her dog had a shock collar on that she failed to utilize, and is much larger than my dog (she told us it was mostly lab but upon further investigation it's mostly pit bull, and she has no history on the dog as it is a rescue). I truly believe even if they had both been on leashes, had we come into contact her dog would have had mine by the throat the same way. Her dog was completely unprovoked. Animal control basically did nothing and gave us each a 25 dollar ticket. According to our landlord she may be evicted because this violates the lease agreement with pets.
I need some honest advice because we do intend to make the other dog's owner pay for at least half and I think that's more than fair. This has been really traumatizing not only for me but obviously my dog and I just want what's fair.