Is my reaction to my past mistakes in premed normal or healthy?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Status
Not open for further replies.

SparklyRainbows

Membership Revoked
Removed
Joined
Nov 10, 2023
Messages
8
Reaction score
0
Not sure if this is the right place, as I think some of this is better for a therapist's office. And I have been seeing a therapist, but I'm not sure if she has been the most helpful so I may fire her soon and look for someone else!

Basically, I started off in college premed. I wasn't HS valedictorian, but I had gotten into one of my top college choices and was proud of the setbacks and wins I had endured/earned to get into that university.

That all being said, I earned a 3 B+'s (calc/stats) and 1 B- (thanks, orgo) in my time in college. It was a competitive and grade deflated college, but doesn't everyone say that about their schools?! LOL.

I felt discouraged by those grades and switched tracks to a major that lets you have a career right out of college.

I was very appreciative of the fact that the "Plan B" career had worked out, but between the multiple rounds of layoffs and the fact that I didn't really "like" the work there, I became depressed at work too, to the point where I was just average and skating by on my "willingness to learn and help" as a new hire vs. someone who was a rising star at that company. Then they laid me off in their most recent round of cuts.

I was venting to my friends and family nearly every week for 2+ hours about how I wished I had stayed premed because at least it's interesting and it helps people. My parents and friends became really concerned about my mental health.

Without getting into too much detail, I would sometimes think that if I became a doctor, life would be really depressing (really extreme) and that the only reason I was in the "stupid" Plan B career was because I was "too stupid for science."

It also didn't help that when I moved cities, I saw this one specialist (a really competitive, sought after field) who was like one of those "popular mean girls" (LOL) and attended a very prestigious Ivy medical school. I will say that she helped me cure my condition in 2-3 visits, but didn't have the best bedside manner (multiple patients have complained) and that I'd see medical students at my favorite places in town, like bookstores or certain food/neighborhood spots. It was like I was being reminded of the path I did not take over and over.

Medicine excites me but scares me at the same time - I know it's not all sunshine and roses, but it keeps drawing me in for some reason. I know there are people who don't match, don't get the specialty they wanted, declining reimbursements, lawsuits, all that. I talked to an OB-GYN in private practice and she scared the hell out of me when she said she thought she was going to have a heart attack from the stress lol.

Not sure why I'm sharing this, but can anyone relate?

Additionally, I feel like, to my horror, that my love of medicine is just to "prove myself" lol, like to show myself I can be like the rich mean girl doctor and that I'm smarter than the premeds who got A's in the classes I struggled with above.

Members don't see this ad.
 
Last edited:
  • Hmm
Reactions: 1 users
I'll be honest, it's more about me being too dumb to be a doctor lol.
Not all of the best doctors are the smartest science experts. They also aren't immune to getting imposter syndrome or getting depressed. Burnout is real in all of healthcare.
 
  • Like
  • Care
Reactions: 4 users
Members don't see this ad :)
Medicine can be a very rewarding field for those who don't mind working hard just for the satisfaction of helping someone in need. But you have to be able to handle a bunch of crappy days that just don't go well. You have to be able to bend against all the external forces (govt, employers, entitled patients, the stupid EMR) that seem to get worse and worse.

Numerous threads are here in SDN on the state of medical practice today. The majority voice seems to be negative, but there are many who love it. The trick is finding out where you are. I agree with @Goro : immerse yourself with some patients. It sounds like you don't really have much experience there. See what it's like.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 users
Can you talk a little about why you wanted to go into medicine (your motivation) and what experiences you've gotten on the clinical side of things?

I find a lot of students associate smart = good grades = go into medicine, but in my experience none of those equivalencies are really true. For example, B-range grades your first semester in college is both perfectly normal and perfectly fine for a career in medicine, if you learn and improve. Often, the first semester can be some of the lowest grades for students as they're acclimating to college.

So I don't see anything that suggests you're "not smart enough" for medicine, but I do wonder how truly interested in it you were / how realistic your knowledge of the field is.
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: 2 users
Not all of the best doctors are the smartest science experts. They also aren't immune to getting imposter syndrome or getting depressed. Burnout is real in all of healthcare.
But many doctors need to be decent at science at least, right? Lol
 
Can you talk a little about why you wanted to go into medicine (your motivation) and what experiences you've gotten on the clinical side of things?

I find a lot of students associate smart = good grades = go into medicine, but in my experience none of those equivalencies are really true. For example, B-range grades your first semester in college is both perfectly normal and perfectly fine for a career in medicine, if you learn and improve. Often, the first semester can be some of the lowest grades for students as they're acclimating to college.

So I don't see anything that suggests you're "not smart enough" for medicine, but I do wonder how truly interested in it you were / how realistic your knowledge of the field is.
Why medicine:
  • 2nd grade teacher shared a story about how her older relative had chest pain at a family event, inspired me to want to take care of people for a living, and was a way for me to get better academically and work hard in STEM because my parents were often angry about my B and C grades in elementary + apathy towards math
  • Human biology is hard but intellectually fascinating - physiology of ob/gyn is really cool particularly
  • Worked in corporate America a year before I got laid off and felt the work I did was meaningless and wasn't worth the effort
And I got B's throughout college but yeah, most of them were in freshman year

I felt I wasn't smart enough for medicine because some of my peers earned mostly A's and I had A's and B's.
 
None of those seem like strong reasons for going into medicine.

If human biology is intellectually fascinating, go into biology. If you didn't like your job, then find a new job.

None of your reasons have to do with patient care, which is the core of being a physician.
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: 6 users
None of those seem like strong reasons for going into medicine.

If human biology is intellectually fascinating, go into biology. If you didn't like your job, then find a new job.

None of your reasons have to do with patient care, which is the core of being a physician.
"2nd grade teacher shared a story about how her older relative had chest pain at a family event, inspired me to want to take care of people for a living"
 
"2nd grade teacher shared a story about how her older relative had chest pain at a family event, inspired me to want to take care of people for a living"
In second grade. Through a story.

Literally means nothing when you're mid-20s and haven't spent any time working on taking care of people yourself.

Personally, I can't take motivations for medicine that are from grade school unless they're backed up with serious investigation once students are adults.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 6 users
I don't judge anyone on the reasons that they enter medicine, but as a medical student who’s almost done my personal suggestion would be to make sure you (1) know you can handle it, (2) like some aspect of it enough (can be the science, patient care, etc.) to get through the really challenging times
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
I don't judge anyone on the reasons that they enter medicine, but as a medical student who’s almost done my personal suggestion would be to make sure you (1) know you can handle it, (2) like some aspect of it enough (can be the science, patient care, etc.) to get through the really challenging times
How do you know if you can handle it?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top