Been couped up in a city for too long, haven't you? How about skiing, working out, taking up a sport, dating (or is that too old-fashioned?), boating, fishing, hiking, backpacking, gardening, surfing, snowboarding, reading a book for pleasure...
I find it a bit odd how people have always been so obsessed with losing their sense of perception when they're out for a good time.
I think you're simplifying theology a bit here.
For instance, having true faith would lead to action, wouldn't it? I notice you put "truly" in quotation marks. And you're the first to catch on to this , including a long-line of church thinkers, theologians, priests, preachers, and laymen?
I think your problem with Christianity is that you do not understand it. Not that I do. Or that many who have studied it for years will admit as much.
I'm not a Christian yet, though I'm leaning that way. There's actually a very elegant system of theology at work within the church, one that I don't think you're being wholly honest about.
So from the testimony of the New Testament, the life of Christ, and the emphasis on faith, hope, and particularly love, you would not accept someone who was truly repentent for their actions, who sought out a relationship with God, and who wished to share that love he found in creation with those around him, just because that one person had committed a crime in his past? No apologies accepted? No recognition of past mistakes acceptable? No coming to terms with one's faults and weaknesses? No valiant effort to overcome them enough? This does not sit well with the message of Christ.
Just "You screwed up once, so I don't care about you anymore." By that logic, no one would be reunified with God. Hence the emphasis on humility in all circles of Christian theology.