- Joined
- Oct 14, 2015
- Messages
- 128
- Reaction score
- 95
So I need a little advice... I literally JUST committed to Rutgers SURF (because it was the deadline to accept) and got my PI placement, emailed the guy, etc. Apparently he's pretty top notch, his summer students get a lot of awards and some publications...the research isn't exactly what I'm used to but I wanna try new things and explore my interests. Plus, I did get placed in pharmacology which is my choice of career path.
I woke up this morning to an acceptance from SUPERS@UPenn (I was on the waitlist but it had been a while so I wasn't holding my breath anymore). UPenn is obviously a dream, especially since I go to a no-name no-research school. Plus, UPenn offers more money PLUS housing & a meal plan (none of which are covered by Rutgers). Additionally, I would prefer to be in Philly for personal reasons, but New Brunswick isn't a bad location either. I thought UPenn was a clear top choice before, but now I'm just confused about which program is better for me, aligns more with my interests, etc. Plus I'm not sure how I would back out of Rutgers if I wanted to (I don't want to be rude, plus I'm very interested in their grad program). I'm going to have a meeting with my adviser today but does anyone have any advice?
I was in a similar situation when I applied for summer programs during my junior year. I had been emailing the director of the program that I was incredibly interested in going to, got admitted and shortly after committed. A week later, I was admitted to Harvard SHURP, so I had to weigh the pros and cons of each program and I decided to go with Harvard. Ultimately, the administration of the program I declined was very respectful of my decision and they probably moved on to offer my spot to someone else. Ironically, I was admitted to the school I declined for my PhD and rejected from Harvard (LOL).
As long as you send them a courteous email, they won't really care. I agree with people saying that money is a very valid reason to decline a school over another, although it seems that you also think that UPenn is a better fit. At the end of the day, if you work hard in both places, you'll get a great letter from either PI, which should be your goal. However, I think that, if all other circumstances are the same, going to Penn might still prove to be the most beneficial circumstance just because name recognition could help you stand out from other candidates. I'm certain that this won't be a make-break situation, but I can't deny that it will help. Just my two cents. Let me know if you have questions about Penn, I'm currently a graduate student there!