Casrdiothoracic employment scene..

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Celiac Plexus

Senior Member
15+ Year Member
20+ Year Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2002
Messages
1,128
Reaction score
8
Points
4,551
Location
USA
  1. Fellow [Any Field]
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
I was just browsing ctsnet.org. There is a resident forum there: http://www.ctsnet.org/fusetalk/categories.cfm?catid=14&forumid=2

There is a group for "jobs", and I just checked it out. Man, it really seems bleak for graduating CT surgeons... the guys just finishing their fellowships. People on this board periodically post the old "is CT dead?" thread, but to me this is way more alarming than the stent v CABG issue... It seems like if you train at one of the handful of top tier programs then you can get a decent job, but if you train at a lower tier program (most of them), then you may be in for a big shock.

As an example, one of the posts is this....

"I applaud Dr. Tolis's comments.
I wish more people in his position would speak up like him. We need to stop graduating residents like it is 1975. We do not need 130+ residents graduating yearly into a workplace where only 40-60 jobs exist!!

When I graduated from my CT residency in 2002, I mistakenly thought the world was my oyster. Within a short time, reality hit. For the record, I suppose I was your usual resident from a small-tier program with absolutely no connections in the CT world.

For the next two years, my life was spent in front of the computer tracking down jobs in extremely small and far out locations. These job opportunities were extremely competitive with one job in the midwest having 102 applications for 1 job!!

To make ends meet, I did locum tenens in general and trauma surgery in small towns in West Texas. Some of these towns did not have more than 1000 people! I decided to go back and get more training as a superfellow, as jobs continued to be hard to find. While it did get me back into the "heart world" for a brief while, I felt I was just passing time. In the meantime, I passed my Boards Part I.

Then came another period of job searching, mostly unsuccessful.

Thankfully, through the grace of God, I was able to find a good position in my home state in 2004. I now enjoy a mixed practice of Cardiac, Thoracic and Vascular surgery.

Make no mistake about it...you are out on your own for jobs! There are few jobs out there, and the jobs that are available have the luxury of choosing from over 100 applicants for 1 job.

The hospitals and groups out there prefer fully boarded surgeons with 2-5 years of experience, not some rookie finishing a few distals out there!

My suggestions:
1). Make yourself marketable. If you do not have a good resume and or publications, you are SOL!!
2). Make sure your recommendations/evaluations speak well of you. If there is even a HINT of poor technique, bad judgement, you are toast! There are way too many candidates out there.
3). Be flexible...Make sure you do Cardiac, Thoracic AND Vascular.
4). Be prepared to live in anytown, anywhere, USA. If you are the kind that cannot live without Thai cuisine, the opera, or other big-city pursuits, re-evaluate yourself.
5). Be prepared to swallow that ego of yours...you may have just finished 7-10 years of training, but the world could care less.
6). If you do a post-graduate fellowship or superfellowship, make it count and publish and/or pick up new techniques...just don't waste time.
7). Don't even think of failing to become board-certified.
8). Pray nightly."


I mean, if the job outlook for new graduates is really this bad, then do people going in to CT know this? And if the job scene really is this bad, does anyone know of any changes on the horizon to rememdy this, e.g. - reducing the number of fellowship slots?

Finally, for those residents training somehwere with a non-top tier CT fellowship, how are the fellows doing as far as job placement? Wow.
 
I was reading the same post a few night ago. I'm glad you asked this question, I too am curious to know. It would be very unfortunate if nothing changes, because I think CT surgery is one of the coolest surgical fields out there.
 
There were supposedly 70-80 applicants this year for 175 openings in CT surgery. I am a GS resident in a program that has arguably a top 5, definitely a top 10 CT program. We are for sure a regional powerhouse in this area. The fellows here will all get jobs but they are scrambling for less than choice postions. While more than half of our residents used to end up in CT surgery, now it is close to 10%. You could always focus striclty on thoracic (which has lots of job openings) but is less exciting.
 
I can tell you about the fellows here at Columbia....The job market is very weak.....Most end up doing the LVAD fellowship because the market is sooo poor. Some do thoracic only, but not in NYC. In the last 3 years I know of none that have landed in private practice in the greater NY area. One is doing a mix of general/thoracic. Most end up doing additional years of fellowship and then enter academics only to get raped by some of the older surgeons whose salaries themselves are drying up. Another guy I know graduated NYU GS and CT (10 yrs residency), could not land a job and is back as a teaching "super" chief. It is sad, but one of the reasons I switched out of GS after a few years. I was very interested in CT surg, but strongly urged by my attendings not to go that route. I hated colorectal, and could never live with myself selling out to do bariatric surgery. Unlike the vascular surgeons, who really have no medical equivalent, and are taking back the angio suites, the cards guys will never let the CT surgeons in. Just words of thought from a once aspiring CT surgeon, but I could enver recommend this route unless you were interested in congenital cardiac surgery....but that is a very long road. However, those guys are Jedis.
 
classic...


they hire fellows to be their slaves for a while and now the fellows cant even find jobs.. classic exploitation in medicine
 
All this rings true. My brother-in-law is finishing up his CT fellowship in a few months and he's got no job offers. He's signed up with a bunch of recruiters and headhunters and none of them have been able to help him get an offer on the table. Last I spoke with him he said he feels like he's wasted a good 4 years of his life (2 year CT surgery fellowship and 2 years of CT research during his general surgery residency) all for nothing. He wishes he'd just went straight to work as an attending in general surgery right after he finished his GS residency instead of wasting 4 years of his career doing research and a CT fellowship. His plan now is to work locum in GS and CT surgery until he can (maybe) find a permanent job in CT surgery. If not, he said he'll just put his whole CT training behind him and concentrate being a general surgeon. It's rough out there right now in the world of CT surgery as far as jobs for new graduates go. Maybe the pendulum will swing the other way some years down the line. Who knows though.
 
Is the pendulum starting to swing the other way now [5 years later] or is CT surgery still doomed?
 
I can tell you for a fact that there are enough jobs out there for new grads. I'm living the dream.

It can be misleading since most of the stuff on ctsnet and the other job posting boards are crappy jobs or bad situations for one reason or another, thats why they have to pay ctsnet alot of money to post it, hopefully to find someone hard-up enough to take the job. If you watch the boards carefully, they tend to post the same jobs over and over.

The real good jobs for new grads are offered "word-of-mouth" and never make it to needing a headhunter or internet want-ads to fill.
 
Thanks JackADeli and ESU_MD. Appreciate the insight. I'm early in my Ms3 year, but I can tell you right now I belong in the OR. I've always read on these forums the many medical students who are stuck between some medical specialty and some surgical one. And many of the people say wait until third year. I always thought those people weren't offering any good advice until now. By third year it's dead obvious, you either love the OR or you don't.

I'm interested in the sick, SICK patients, and I think I would like CT surgery, neurosurgery, trauma surgery, or the like. But I'll keep an open mind, we'll see how it goes.

Also, JackADeli, you have some mad Google skills. Every time I tried to do a search of the current outlook for CT surgery I always got things from like 2002 or 2003 saying that the field was all but dead.
 
...JackADeli, you have some mad Google skills. ...
:meanie:

I was going to post a "let me google that for you" link. But, it seems the server is overload right now. My google technique is to search the question I am asking and its ~null hypothesis.

What you need to do is search ~"cardiothoracic surgeon shortage". You will find plenty of recent publications and links for your question.... and the links I posted within the first 10 on your search page.
 
Last edited:

I can tell you for a fact that there are enough jobs out there for new grads. I'm living the dream.

It can be misleading since most of the stuff on ctsnet and the other job posting boards are crappy jobs or bad situations for one reason or another, thats why they have to pay ctsnet alot of money to post it, hopefully to find someone hard-up enough to take the job. If you watch the boards carefully, they tend to post the same jobs over and over.

The real good jobs for new grads are offered "word-of-mouth" and never make it to needing a headhunter or internet want-ads to fill.

Yes, but those articles and soon to be New CT grads are forgetting the fact there are still a 130 something spots, of which a high percentage go unfilled every year. So yes, this year and the next ten may prove themselves fruitful due to "shortage", but as soon as job and potential salary outlooks start ameliorating, the supply (or the amount of CT graduates looking for work) will once again increase, and the specialty will find itself in the same predicament.

Until an artificial shortage is created by diminishing the amount fellowship positions as many have advocated in the past, and as other specialties have done ( i.e. anesthesiology), this opportunistic time in CTS may prove itself to be more ephemeral or more so pendulumic than a true representation of a brighter future in CTS. I'd rather remain skeptical, go into it out of passion, expect the worst, and gear up for a fight.
 
Last edited:
...this opportunistic time in CTS may prove itself to be more ephemeral or more so pendulumic than a true representation of...
I'm surgeon, too much big words, my brain hurts:meanie:
 
Top Bottom