...I completely disagree with this:
...As was said, going to a school which lacks the elite students does have its advantages (possibly better GPA due to curves, more scholarships, better chance of graduating with honors, etc)...
High GPA is taken into account by looking at the school it is from. Scholarships mean nothing if you make $50K less a year b/c of poor training. What do honors mean if you are king of underachievers?
I disagree with those points b/c I don't think that enticing people not reach for the best is not good advice. I feel that wants to be a pod should want to go to the best school and be the best pod possible. If someone is looking for easy roads, I personally don't want them. It cheapens the profession I have chosen.
Please take comments as constructive criticism not insults.
Your disagreement makes sense to me, but there are multiple facors to consider here which may not be sinking in. Not everyone is young and single with no major attachments to a location.
First off, with a limited number of pod school choices, some students will simply choose by a school's location due to proximity to family and friends or maybe climate preferences. It is a four year commitment to schooling (and those years are typically from the physical and social prime of one's lifetime). A student from, say, Texas may not wish to go to a cold climate and snowy winters to study regardless of where they could get into. A prospective pod student with family and friends in Buffalo, NY might choose NYCPM simply because they don't want to spend excessive time and money to travel far to go home on holiday breaks. An applicant whose fiancee has a great high paying job she loves in Chicago may choose to Scholl for largely for that reasoning. Someone whose parent graduated and practices in Cali might choose that school to continue the tradition and because they know some of the professors. A student with limited money and little family support may need to look closely to scholarship opportunities and offerings, tuition, and average living costs in the locations of the pod schools.
My point was simply that you can get a good educaton at any school if you apply yourself and want to learn. It's true that at some schools you may need to read on your own more in some subjects, and other highly academic schools may not have the best labs. All of them are slightly different. I agree that some schools accept too many students or don't tend to attract the top applicants, but the institutions almost certainly would lose their accreditation if they weren't at least minimally adequate in terms of both instruction and facilities.
As far as academic standards, I agree that if a student doesn't care where they live, is not climate sensitive, and they are willing to relocate to any school, then they should probably attend the pod school they view as the best and most prestigous between all schools which they are accepted to.
Yet another academic consideration is a student with marginal ability. A hypothetical student who worked their tail off in undergrad yet only achieved a 3.0 and a only a 20/M on the MCAT even after the Kaplan class might flunk out second semester at AZPOD, but they might be able to get by due to more generous grading curves at a school with less qualified applicants. Eventually, I hope standards at all schools rise, but people who can get in with lower stats right now still has a chance and might not get their top choice school.
Still, in the end, everyone has to pass the boards and any school will flunk or strictly probate students they feel are not performing adequately. The schools some people here consider "lesser" still get their final graduating classes up to a reasonably comparable level to the so-called "top crust" schools. Top podiatrists come from all schools, and prestigious residency positions are represented by all schools also. Whether you start with 80 or 50 in a pod class doesn't really matter to me if both schools end up with roughly 40-45 good qualified students remaining in the program after 3 or 4 semesters.
In the end, it's a personal decision. Personally, I chose Barry for a few reasonings:
-my immediate family was retiring to Florida soon after I was to start grad school
-it's a Catholic university, and that appealed to me
-the weather is absolutely beautiful here and that facilitates friends and family visiting me while vacationing
-by touring the school and speaking with professors and students, I decided I could get a good education
-I got accpeted and was offered a fairly substantial renewable scholarship by the university