Pointlessness upon pointlessness, all is pointless. Has anything good ever come out of these debates? You have every available data at your disposal. Every conceivable opinion at your disposal on this forum. Does it make your decision any easier? I doubt it. More informed? Perhaps, but certainly not decidedly better.
For the 1,000,000th time, just go where you are comfortable and do your darn best with what you are given (sounds like Medicine to me?). I find it hard to believe that there are schools out there that do not care about their reputation to the extent that they will nothing about things like bad board schools. These schools are to a large extent businesses and will do their utmost best to get better with time, try new approaches, recruit better students and whatever it takes to earn a good reputation because I am sure they know that it somehow determines thier bottom line.
So instead of having a silly debate about school rankings and stats,maybe, just maybe, it would make more sense to choose a school and spend time talking to those who go there. Find out how things work there, strategies for survival, which classes suck and which are great and plan for these;
PSYCH yourself up for challenges. Find/connect with some of their residents (several here on SDN!) in programs you
might (being premed and all) like. Ask them how they did it, learn from them and use your own presumably good judgement to decide what will work for you. The worst thing you could do to yourself is have some kind of expectation that a school's match list or board scores will reflect on you once you go there. Its nonsense. If there was only 1 AGCME Rad match for instance at some school, and you should go there (assuming its your only acceptance and you
think you want rad too), why don't you focus on being that 1 guy who made it, rather than on the 100 other guys who did not or quite reasonaly had no interest in rad? There is always
that 1 guy/gal; BE that guy! or at least try. Having come this far as a premed, I bet you appreciate the fact that for the most part effort=results.
I can understand not wanting to go to a provisionally accredited school, but even there, you can make it. After all, I bet all the so called top school were provisionally accredited at some point. Right? So be bold, choose that school that made you not want to leave after the interview, that school that made you want to start there and then, that admin/com that made you feel at home, that school with those amazing facilities,...go there and KILL IT like your life depended on it. Then in four years someone here on SDN will be referring to you as "that guy" at "so and so" school who matched at that residency (FM to NS idc which, as long as you are happy) they really want
. Instead of letting the statistic determine where you go or how you go about your education, why don't you be that statistic you want to see?
My 2 cents