I'm a nursing student from a CC that is slated to finish in May next year, and I'm 21. If you ask me if I regret going to nursing school, I would say a big fat NO. Going to nursing school assured me of a job, more or less, that will pay me $35 as an entry-level nurse on a nursing residency program on any department aside from Ortho and OR (I'm drooling on either ICU or ED).
That being said, if I had to do it all over again, I would not do nursing and just do a basic science degree (biology, chemistry, etc.). Nursing is kicking my butt right now and my cGPA will go from 3.9 to a mere 3.45-3.5 by the time I finish nursing school next year. THAT will HURT your chances. Every snotty traditional pre-med that posts here on SDN would say that nursing is very easy, especially our sciences. I would dare them to take up nursing school and score an A on every test.
Nursing classes focus more on application of the knowledge and critical thinking, and more times than not, answers depend more on your instructors common sense than yours. It's really different from fact-base question like questions on biology, chemistry, etc. Believe me, I'm getting A's on all of them except for nursing classes. I even had a peek at Step-1 USMLE questions and they seem more straightforward (aka, more easy if you know all the things you need to know). In nursing, even if you memorized everything, nursing style questions would still kill you.
So, my advice would be to do a post-baccalaureate program (Masters, maybe?) and ace it. Stay away from nursing, and if you need clinical experience for a PA, NP, or medical school, there's always an EMT course.
P.S. - I'm very biased against nurse practitioner programs...
I have to completely agree with this statement. My initial intention was never to be an MD for many reasons, but I also thought I would get a more in depth education on hard sciences in nursing school, also. So far, all I've really learned is either a VERY superficial review of our prereqs or stuff I've read online/in general medical science news (ie, VERY dumbed down...I'm not talking about academic/medical journals, but crap like yahoo news). I've picked up on this since day one of my program. I'm only 2 months in and at this point, I'm trying to figure out how I can make a fool out of professors for being arrogant idiots. My grades have gone from all A's to C's (our professors have been lecturing us since before the program started that RN=C). The test questions are more accurately described as "application" based. The style of questions are definitely situational, but the right reasoning IS what the instructor considers most right. And these questions are rarely thrown out.
To give you another idea, my clinical instructor asked me a question that I wasn't 100% sure of the answer on, but it was a more black and white question that you could logically figure out. I told her that logically a certain answer sounded right...she was quite mad/offended by my answer and lectured me on how I just needed to know, not "figure it out." My answer, btw, was correct.
I'm also pretty anti-NP. I think the idea is good, but the lack of standardization/BS nature of the program doesn't IMO truly equate to what a doctorate level degree should in my mind be.
Sounds to me like nursing isn't really teaching by the evidence, then, if you have to use your instructor's "common sense."
It's not. In a lot of ways it's worse than liberal arts, because you have to suck up/figure out what the professor wants for an answer on multiple choice questions. In essay tests I had for courses during my BA (my BA is in German and Religion), I could at least word things in a way that gave me some of credit, even if it wasn't the professor's exact opinion. Then again, the BS 65 my clinical instructor "had to work to give me" (she wanted to give me a 55) on a stupid Philosophy of Nursing paper also points to the subjective "I don't like you so you're getting a lower grade" nature of the program in general. I followed the outline word for word, supported my opinion, and honestly gave my opinion. I really think logic and honesty aren't valued in the nursing profession.
"Every snotty traditional pre-med that posts here on SDN would say that nursing is very easy, especially our sciences. I would dare them to take up nursing school and score an A on every test."
Along these lines.... I agree with the above poster and its great advice. Made straight A's in nurisng pre-reqs..including microbiology + anatomies..only missed (one) question on a college algebra cumulative final. In nursing made an A in nutrition and pharm.. because the questions have answers that are scientific and make sense. Made straight B's in the actual nursing questions. Was told by clinical instructors "no one" could earn an A..we were just beginners..for the clinical portion. Nursing questions are so subjective as to the right answer. If you want to make more money..consider CNA? Waiting tables? If you KNOW you are smart enough to get in and make it through medical school..my suggestion is to avoid nursing alltogether. BTW I'm currently a RN.
As I said above, our nursing instructors have beat it in our heads since before the program even started that RN=C. That's a load of BS. RN=C only for the people they don't like. Pharmacology is pretty easy...it's concrete and more logical. The big problem is that it's fluffy, so nothing is explained in depth enough to understand certain drug applications (and the professors refuse to explain it, also...it's "outside the scope of nursing practice"). I also say go to med school. The only thing keeping me sane is knowing that once I'm done, I can pay some crap off, get a little experience, finish premed courses, and go on to what I truly want to do.
That's the reason why I yearned for the day when I'm done with all nursing classes and just get back to "traditional" classes and exams for premed. I think it's much to do with how our minds are wired to think and I think mine is incompatible with nursing. I have classmates who are just average in science classes but glowing in nursing.
As I said earlier, I went in to take a look at a Step-1 review book at Barnes and Nobles and they seemed more straightforward than nursing questions. Even a close family friend of ours (an MD) expressed frustration about nursing questions. 🙁
There's no way to avoid power trips if you're working with women (I'm a guy). The word lateral violence is notoriously associated with nurses.
Yeah, being good at science definitely does not equate with being good at nursing coursework...and vice versa. If I could put a basilisk fang through my stupid Fundamentals of Nursing textbook and make it all disappear, I would (yes, I'm in my late 20s and referencing Harry Potter). The MCAT review questions I've seen seem much more straight forward than my RN test questions. Granted, I'm not in med school and haven't done a huge amount of research on it, but the bits and pieces I have seen are definitely more logical.
And the further I get into nursing, the more I wish I would've chosen electrical engineering instead (long story) just to NOT have to deal with working with women (I'm a woman). Women, especially in masses, have cat claws and will turn on you faster than you can blink. And every work environment I've been in that has been woman dominated has turned out negatively for me due to these factors (I was convinced otherwise with nursing by my dad...even though the other students in my class aren't this way/have been surprisingly great classmates, my professors are making me expect otherwise post-schooling).
Nursing school is BS. I tutored pathophysiology to a couple of nursing students this past summer and was left speechless by the instructor's decisions. There were several instances where her answer totally contradicted the text and common sense, yet she did not budge. Basically, in her syllabus she stated that she will not allow anyone to challenge questions on the test. How is that a fair learning environment? I call BS. Plus getting an 'A' in Anatomy at at CC does not mean much. I teach Gen Bio and A&P I/II at a CC. We were told by the department to skip several important areas because these areas are not important to the practice of nursing. How is renal physiology NOT important? Hello???
My A&P I/II and Micro was structured by an MD turned college bio department head/professor. While I certainly believe we could have/should now be going MUCH more in depth, they definitely didn't skip over anything like renal physiology. I never would have thought I would enjoy renal physiology, but that is so freakin' vital (no pun intended). Not to mention the depth of how the kidneys work is incredible (it was definitely confusing at first to understand the tubules...it was hard for me to picture, for some reason, but after it clicked, I just want to learn/understand more, which I sadly am not getting). I'm at a CC and we learned this. I'm not sure how other CC are or how large university science classes are (my BA was NOT in the sciences). I do have to say, though, that the GE/liberal arts coursework at this CC is a freakin' joke. I talked about the English Channel in my English 1101 course and multiple people in the class thought I was talking about a television channel.
