I guess this thread was bound to be hijacked...
sophiejane said:
But still, even if no one goes into FP... everyone has to do an intern year and you need to know all that basic stuff to survive it...rad onc, derm, and optho and getting out at 1 pm is nice but they ain't gonna help you at 3 am when you have 5 admissions...
I'm personally a bit terrified at the prospect that nurses will be following my orders in <12 months, so my 4th year schedule is a little less cush, but that's just me...
Pathology is the exception-- we are not required to do an internship year (therefore no admissions at 3AM, when I'll be in the middle of 8 glorious hours of sleep

). It is of little benefit to me as a pathology resident to have knowledge of admit orders for a patient in DKA (although I learned as a 3rd year), so I scheduled my 4th year with areas that I was interested in learning more about and in a few specialties that I would be working with (ie issuing pathology reports to) in the future. I would have scheduled an ICU month and other rotations accordingly if I was going into a patient care specialty.
sophiejane said:
It used to be that you applied for a specialty after your intern year, which makes a whole lot of sense,when you think about it. Yeah, it's an extra year, but look at how many people lose a year (or two or five) because they chose the wrong field?
It doesn't make any sense, and still impedes one from getting exposure to other specialties that lie outside of peds, IM, and surgery. First, is this intern year going to be surgery, IM, or peds? In this intern year, undoubtedly you will be doing a ton of scut and working the majority of your year in the ICU or general wards. You might get 2 electives during this year in which you can explore subspecialties. Now try and get time off during this intern year to interview (people who didnt match and scrambled into a prelim do this, but it aint easy). Other than providing an additional year of patient care experience in either IM, surgery, or peds I can't see how this *helps* you in deciding what specialty to pursue.
I am not arguing that we should not have exposure to the primary care fields, GS, and OB. In fact, I think my medicine rotation was probably the most helpful in terms of developing a differential, physical exam skills, and the like. I am arguing in favor of allowing a little more freedom to choose to do some subspecialty rotations during third year, along with medicine and surgery as requirements.
Anyway, that's my 0.10.