A coulpe of W's in pre-req classes

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Samus Aran

Old member
Moderator Emeritus
20+ Year Member
Joined
Apr 10, 2003
Messages
6,832
Reaction score
83
Since NRAI2001 asked about C's, I thought it best to ask about W's! I currently have 2 withdrawls, one from first semester Bio and the second one from first semester physics. I took the Bio again the following semester and did well, but I have yet to take a stab at Physics again. There's only 1 professor who teaches General Physics at my school and he's not the best teacher (to say the least) so I'm waiting to take the course someplace else during a summer. What effect do you think this may have on admissions? When asked I'll have my reasons for both of my withdrawls (no I won't mention the Physics W being because of a bad teacher), but I'm still unsure of whether or not this will greatly hurt my chances for admission.

Please be gentle!
 
Sounds like you are early on in your college career -- therefore one or two W's won't be that big of a deal. I would just avoid any further W's on your transcript.

Most likely, freshmen (or sophomores) are given a little slack in this regard.
 
Originally posted by Misty504
Since NRAI2001 asked about C's, I thought it best to ask about W's! I currently have 2 withdrawls, one from first semester Bio and the second one from first semester physics. I took the Bio again the following semester and did well, but I have yet to take a stab at Physics again. There's only 1 professor who teaches General Physics at my school and he's not the best teacher (to say the least) so I'm waiting to take the course someplace else during a summer. What effect do you think this may have on admissions? When asked I'll have my reasons for both of my withdrawls (no I won't mention the Physics W being because of a bad teacher), but I'm still unsure of whether or not this will greatly hurt my chances for admission.

Please be gentle!


what reasons do you plan on giving for those withdrawals???.... you know all of this really depends on what your interviewer is like... (and you should have good reasons for withdrawing from the courses)
 
These may not be the best reasons, but they're honest...

Bio: It was the first semester of my freshman year, and I had not exactly come from a strong HS background. I didn't know what to expect from college, and I RARELY studied in HS so I didn't know what study method worked best for me. I didn't know how to take good notes either, so I spent the class time scribbling down every word I heard the professor speak. I ended up getting lost during the lectures, (which is where the entire tests came from) and I ended up making D's on both tests. So really that first semester of freshman year was spent getting used to school since I never really tried before, but I learned pretty quick and thankfully I ended that year with a 3.6.

Physics: (This will probably be a really tough one to explain)
This was taken the first semester of my junior year along with chem w/lab and an upperlevel bio with lab. From the start I decided the bio and chem classes and labs were going to be easier for me to handle, so I spent the majority of my time concentrating on physics. Unfortunately, my time spent with physics wasn't enough because I did horrible on the 2 tests I took so I ended up dropping the course. This then left me somewhat behind in bio and chem, so I spent the rest of the semester making up for lost time (I ended up doing well that semester anyway). I got REALLY stressed out because of physics, and I started fighting a lot with my mom, and eventually I moved in w/my boyfriend during the middle of that semester. It was really tough on me but I definitely think I learned a lot from that situation. I came back this past semester and earned my highest semester GPA so far, so I hope this will show adcoms I'm capable of better...

Should I even bother going into all of this unless asked? I don't want to come off as being whiney...I know both situations were entirely my fault and I will readily admit that to anyone that asks.
 
i have a total of 7 Ws all from my first two years of school, some of which were from 97-98. Very good reasons I think (family/medical) but I'm screwed, aren't I? I guess I will change to a business major.
 
Hi everyone,

You are really not screwed in this process, as long as you are honest and can show major improvement!!!! I had two withdraws and C's and things like that, and I still got over 10 interviews and two acceptances so far!!! Just stick with your goals and keep working hard. My experience has been that they understand that freshman and sophomore year were a long time ago for some of us and that people mature!!!!!! Don't give up on your dreams! I had sooooooo many people tell me I would never get in because of my withdraws and things, and they were WRONG!!!! So I would just like to stick my tongue out to them! 😛
 
Originally posted by Misty504
These may not be the best reasons, but they're honest...

Bio: It was the first semester of my freshman year, and I had not exactly come from a strong HS background. I didn't know what to expect from college, and I RARELY studied in HS so I didn't know what study method worked best for me. I didn't know how to take good notes either, so I spent the class time scribbling down every word I heard the professor speak. I ended up getting lost during the lectures, (which is where the entire tests came from) and I ended up making D's on both tests. So really that first semester of freshman year was spent getting used to school since I never really tried before, but I learned pretty quick and thankfully I ended that year with a 3.6.

Physics: (This will probably be a really tough one to explain)
This was taken the first semester of my junior year along with chem w/lab and an upperlevel bio with lab. From the start I decided the bio and chem classes and labs were going to be easier for me to handle, so I spent the majority of my time concentrating on physics. Unfortunately, my time spent with physics wasn't enough because I did horrible on the 2 tests I took so I ended up dropping the course. This then left me somewhat behind in bio and chem, so I spent the rest of the semester making up for lost time (I ended up doing well that semester anyway). I got REALLY stressed out because of physics, and I started fighting a lot with my mom, and eventually I moved in w/my boyfriend during the middle of that semester. It was really tough on me but I definitely think I learned a lot from that situation. I came back this past semester and earned my highest semester GPA so far, so I hope this will show adcoms I'm capable of better...

Should I even bother going into all of this unless asked? I don't want to come off as being whiney...I know both situations were entirely my fault and I will readily admit that to anyone that asks.

Ok Misty...

here's what I think... you shouldnt go into all this unless asked... (actually, definitely dont go into all this if it's already asked because half your interview would be over by then)

Instead, the reason that you gave for the freshmen bio class seems like a very normal reason for withdrawing... you can turn that into a strength into how you've been able to work on your weaknesses... since you had to take the bio again, you can say that you tested yourself and you were successful.

for the physics, I dunno what to say... you can say that you had family problems but I wouldnt go into much detail... say how you learned from it and all should be well...

dont worry, think of it this way, you're going to get in med school because those adcoms WANT you to be there... (not because joe shmo withdrew from 3 classes and misty withdrew from only 2!)

🙂 😀
 
whatever. i withdrew from 7. i'm not going anywhere.
 
i think it's definitely ok to have a couple of W's. you really shouldn't be excessive about it, but only 2??? i think you'll be fine. if they bring it up, you should have a legitimate excuse for it. i personally don't have any w's...but i wish i had taken a W instead of getting a D in physics 2 quarters ago. now, the D has pretty much brought my gpa down a bit. so, W's can be lifesavers too if you look at it that way. i would definitely try to stay away from any more...
 
Top