Dr2b:
I did some research of my own, and these are the numbers to back up my claim that optometry school is about as competitive as dental school.
First, in the six years between 1994 to 1999, there were an average of 3943 graduates from US dental schools. Now, adjusting that to a 5% attrition rate between the first and fourth years, that average is more like 4140 first year seats available in the US.
In terms of applicants per year, there were an average of 9290 between 1996 and 1999. So, just dividing by the averages, the acceptance rate (4140/9290) is about 45%, which is not that far from optometry schools rate of 52.9% in 2000.
Also, there has been a downward trend in the number of dental school applicants since it reached its high in 1997 (9,829). This decline correlates with the downtrend of undergraduate applicants to dental school since the high in 1997 (8,602). In 2000, the number of undergrad applicants was at a five year low of 6,735 (this also correlates with the lower numbers of applicants to med school in recent years).
However, there has been a similarly significant upward trend of non-undergraduate applicants, with the average between 1996 to 1999 being 1,202 and rising. Since there wasn't a total number of applicants given for 2000, I figured it to be around 8,400 (the number of 2000 undergrad applicants plus the average number of non-undergrad applicants between 1996 to 1999, as well as an additional 463 non-undergrad applicants to account for the rising trend).
This then gives you a (preliminary) 2000 dental school acceptance rate of approximately 49.3%, which again isn't too far off from optometry school's acceptance rate of 52.9% in 2000. The acceptance rate for medical school in 2000 was 44% (16301/37092). If the trend continues as it has been for next year, I would suspect that the acceptance rate for dental school in 2001 will be over the 50% barrier.
Also, the average GPAs for accepted dental school applicants was 3.35 in 1999; In 2000, the average GPAs for accepted optometry school students was 3.32.
I think that if you compared the profiles of people applying to optometry school and dental school, they have similar GPAs, majors, ages, etc. Probably more people gravitate to dentistry in the past because of the potential for higher earnings, but the relatively stress-less job profile of the optometrist is beginning to gain favor with those choosing between dentistry and optometry.
Also, as I said in my previous post, the dental school applicant has more choices to choose from because of the high number of private dental schools without residency requirements available in the United States. Most, if not all of the optometry schools in the United States, have some preference to in-state residents and to those from surrounding (contract) states that do not have optometry schools.
Here is the ADEA website where I gathered this information:
http://www.adea.org/ck/DentEd%20Fact%20Sheet.htm
[This message has been edited by puffy1 (edited April 26, 2001).]