• Scariest Story Contest

    Now that it's getting close to Halloween, we're running a contest to hear your scariest stories! These can be scary stories that you've experienced or stories that you've heard and the story with the most reactions will win!

    JOIN CONTEST

Am I good?

BigRedStress

AMEX Black
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Dec 4, 2001
153
0
Ithaca
    Hey all,... here is where I finally stand:
    3.44 Biochem major from Cornell
    8,11,Q,11 = 30 MCAT (English is actually my second language, I gre up in a bilingual household with hindi as my primary language - which is what im putting in my amcas and what one of my recommenders said in his letter)
    I have a good 3 years of solid research with about 4 publications. I want to go to a medschool in a city.
    should i retake the mcat? I really do not want to.
    finally, am i a comp. applicant for any md-phd programs?
     

    relatively prime

    post happy member
    7+ Year Member
    15+ Year Member
    Apr 28, 2002
    2,797
    3
      Well, I personally think that an 8 in verbal is really awesome for someone who has English as a second language! However, I'm not sure how medical schools will feel about it. To my knowledge MD/phD is even more competitive than straight MD. If I were you I would retake and try to boost that verbal. But it's up to you. Just make sure that if you don't retake... your PS is really really good. I think you have a chance with an 8 in verbal... but not a good chance.

      Just my take on the situation...

      Good luck :)
       

      efex101

      attending
      Moderator Emeritus
      10+ Year Member
      15+ Year Member
      Apr 20, 2002
      2,713
      74
      55
      MN
      1. Attending Physician
        I disagree with the above poster, if English is your second language a VR of 8 is pretty good and I would not retake the MCAT. Many Americans do not get an 8 in VR so I think that you are doing great. Your best bet to see if you are competitive for mudphud is to call the schools that you are interested in and explain your situation.
         

        Mr. H

        Full Member
        7+ Year Member
        15+ Year Member
        Dec 12, 2001
        652
        0
          So were born in the US and your parents were first time immigrants? When did you start learning English, in pre-school/kindergarten? Just wondering, because I grew up in a bilingual household, and didn't learn English until I started going to school. BUT, I still consider English my primary language...
           
          About the Ads

          relatively prime

          post happy member
          7+ Year Member
          15+ Year Member
          Apr 28, 2002
          2,797
          3
            •••quote:•••Originally posted by efex101:
            •...Many Americans do not get an 8 in VR so I think that you are doing great...•••••"Many Americans"?!?! This guy IS an American.

            Anyway... I think a lot of people on this board grossly underestimate how competitive medical school admission is these days... especially for students who are ethnically Asian. In fact, this year AMCAS is expecting there to be more applicants to medical school than there have been in the past 5 years.

            If you want to have a good chance, you need to retake. Especially since you're ethnically Indian!! I personally know many Indians who have English as a second language who have earned 9+ scores in verbal. Medical school admittance is just harder for Asian students, and especially for Indian students. The reason is because they are so well represented in the medical field.. and there are so many applying that have great stats and great ECs and recs, etc. Basically, you're competing with some of the best applicants.

            I'm not trying to be mean or discouraging here, I just think that if you really want to secure your chances, you should retake.... especially since your science scores aren't that high.

            But you do have ~a~ chance of getting in somewhere with your stats... it just depends on how safe you want to be.

            Good luck :)
             

            BigRedStress

            AMEX Black
            7+ Year Member
            15+ Year Member
            Dec 4, 2001
            153
            0
            Ithaca
              well i was born in india and came tothe US with my family, i didnt start learning english until i went to school, and not I'm fluent in it and do not speak hindi too much anymore, but nonethelss im sure that the changing of languages made my english no the best. i only got a 630 on my SAT verbal after studying for a year. I studied for well over a year for the mcat, and got an 8. I psyched about that score. I just hope med schools will understand...
              do you guys think i should not put hindi as my primary language? if not, how do i tell them about this? i'm all nervous now....
               

              Tweetie_bird

              Full Member
              7+ Year Member
              15+ Year Member
              Nov 20, 2001
              2,193
              2
              43
                ok guys, I am getting conflicting information from various posters.

                I too, was born and brought up in India till I was 15 and I didn't learn english till i was in school. My transcript says that my primary language is Gujarati. I got a 7 on verbal, Q on essay, and most of you have asked me to retake it. I am not sure on what to do....I see conflicting opinions.

                More opinions here, the better, so could you please fill me in??
                Thanks,
                Tweetie
                 

                Vader

                Dark Lord of the Sith
                Moderator Emeritus
                15+ Year Member
                Jun 5, 2001
                1,066
                17
                1. Attending Physician
                  30 is a good composite score that makes you competitive for medical school admissions. Your science scores are very good. Only retake the MCAT if you feel you can do significantly better (i.e. at least 3 or 4 points). If not, then I would stick with the 30 and explain the language barrier in your personal statement. Apply to a range of programs (there is no such thing as a "safety school") and make sure ALL aspects of the application are high quality. Don't underestimate the importance of the complete package.

                  As for MD/PhD admissions, your MCATs would be below average, but you can make up for it by counterbalancing with strengths in other areas, especially letters of recommendation and your research experience.

                  Hope this helps. :D
                   
                  Well I was born and raised here in the US by my Indian parents, Gujrati was the first language I learned but . . . I learned English immeadiately afterwards. So am I technically an ESL student? I've never thought about this before, and can it be used to my advantage? I don't want to be a dick and milk the system.
                   

                  Mudd

                  Charlatan & Trouble Maker
                  7+ Year Member
                  15+ Year Member
                  Jun 6, 2002
                  376
                  2
                  relocated again
                    Look at the data!!! An 8-11-11 is a score that will open doors, escpecially with 4 publications to back it up. As for MSTP being harder than straight MD, that's variable with schools. The 4 pubs will more than make up for any issues with an 8 in verbal. No matter what language background someone comes from, 8 is still the median. With two 11s, you'd be foolish to waste time repeating the exam.

                    Stengthen the other aspects of your application with that time.
                     
                    i honestly don't think that adcoms will be too sympathetic to indians with low verbal scores even if hindi,punjabi, gujrati, urdu, tamil, taligu etc... were their first languages, and then immigrated to the us at any point. i grew up in a quadralingual household (punjabi/hindi, kiswahili (east african language), dutch and english), but put english as my first language, and didn't include kiswahili and dutch beacuse i can only use them at a rudimentary level these days (sad). i can pm you if you want to know why i have the aforementioned opinion.
                    -jot
                     

                    relatively prime

                    post happy member
                    7+ Year Member
                    15+ Year Member
                    Apr 28, 2002
                    2,797
                    3
                      •••quote:•••Originally posted by jot:
                      •i honestly don't think that adcoms will be too sympathetic to indians with low verbal scores even if hindi,punjabi, gujrati, urdu, tamil, taligu etc... were their first languages, and then immigrated to the us at any point. i grew up in a quadralingual household (punjabi/hindi, kiswahili (east african language), dutch and english), but put english as my first language, and didn't include kiswahili and dutch beacuse i can only use them at a rudimentary level these days (sad). i can pm you if you want to know why i have the aforementioned opinion.
                      -jot•••••I think this is really sad, but probably true... unfortunately. <img border="0" title="" alt="[Frown]" src="frown.gif" />
                       

                      Hendooneh

                      Member
                      7+ Year Member
                      15+ Year Member
                      May 26, 2002
                      41
                      0
                        Just curious bigredstress, but how old were you when you "started school" and learned english? I came to the U.S. when I was 12 not speaking a single word of english and never spoke any english at home but I scored 11 on my MCAT verbal. I am not saying this to put you down in any fashion what so ever but I think if you told the adcom that the reason you have an 8 is because english is your second language and they read the rest of your application and it says you started kindergarden in the u.s. that would just make you look weaker for still considering english your second language.
                         
                        This thread is more than 19 years old.

                        Your message may be considered spam for the following reasons:

                        1. Your new thread title is very short, and likely is unhelpful.
                        2. Your reply is very short and likely does not add anything to the thread.
                        3. Your reply is very long and likely does not add anything to the thread.
                        4. It is very likely that it does not need any further discussion and thus bumping it serves no purpose.
                        5. Your message is mostly quotes or spoilers.
                        6. Your reply has occurred very quickly after a previous reply and likely does not add anything to the thread.
                        7. This thread is locked.